Tweet
Group Says Russia Now at 'Not Free' Status
By JUDITH INGRAM
The Associated Press
12/20/04 15:20 EST
MOSCOW (AP) - Russia has restricted rights to such an extent that it
has joined the countries that are not free for the first time since
the 1991 fall of the Soviet Union, Freedom House said Monday, marking
Moscow's march away from the Western democracies it has embraced as
diplomatic partners.
"This setback for freedom represented the year's most important
political trend," the U.S.-based non-governmental organization wrote
in its annual study, Freedom in the World 2005.
Freedom House noted increased Kremlin control over national television
and other media, limitations on local government, and parliamentary
and presidential elections it said were neither free nor fair.
"Russia's step backward into the 'Not Free' category is the
culmination of a growing trend under President Vladimir Putin to
concentrate political authority, harass and intimidate the media,
and politicize the country's law-enforcement system," Executive
Director Jennifer Windsor said in a statement.
"These moves mark a dangerous and disturbing drift toward
authoritarianism in Russia, made more worrisome by President Putin's
recent heavy-handed meddling in political developments in neighboring
countries, such as Ukraine."
The report accused Putin of exploiting the terrorist seizure of a
school in southern Russia to ram through what Freedom House called
the dismantling of local authority.
In the wake of the September attack, which killed more than 330
people, Putin introduced a plan to end the election of governors
by popular vote and the election of legislators in individual
races. Currently, the 450 seats in the lower house of parliament are
equally split between those filled through party lists and those
contested in district races.
The Russian Foreign Ministry had no immediate comment on the report,
which said that Russia had reached its lowest point where political
rights and civic freedoms are concerned since 1989.
Grigory Yavlinsky, a former member of parliament with the liberal
Yabloko party, said Russia has been "not-free" for more than a
decade now.
"Today in Russia there are no independent mass media, no independent
court, parliament, business. There is no public control over special
forces and police. There are practically no elections which are not
controlled by the authorities," he said.
Freedom House said that on balance, the world saw increased freedom
in 2004: 26 countries showed gains while 11 showed decline. Of the
world's 192 countries, it judged 46 percent free, 26 percent not free,
and the rest partly free. Eight rated as the most repressive: Burma,
Cuba, Libya, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Syria and Turkmenistan.
The NGO said that only Central and Eastern Europe had seen "dramatic
progress" over the past year. It noted that Bosnia-Herzegovina's
rating had improved following the first elections organized entirely
by Bosnian institutions.
In the Middle East, Freedom House rated just Israel as free. Five
countries in the region, including Jordan and Yemen, are partly free,
and 12 are not free. It said the territories occupied by Israel and
run by the Palestinian Authority were not free.
Egypt, Jordan, Morocco and Qatar registered modest gains, Freedom
House said.
It registered democratic gains in the former Soviet republics of
Georgia and Ukraine, where popular protests forced the cancellation
of the results of fraudulent elections in the past 13 months.
"The positive experiences in Georgia and Ukraine indicate that
democratic ferment and nonviolent civic protest are potent forces
for political change," Windsor said. "They also reinforce freedom's
gradual global advance."
The former Soviet republics of Belarus, Armenia and Lithuania saw
setbacks - the first two due to the authorities' increasingly harsh
response to dissent, and the latter because of "worrying questions
about the full autonomy of Lithuania's political leadership" in
the wake of President Roland Paksas' impeachment amid allegations
of influence by the Russian mafia.
Freedom House, a Washington-based, nonpartisan group, was founded
nearly 60 years ago by Americans concerned about threats to
democracy. It conducts advocacy, research and training to encourage
and nurture democracy.
By JUDITH INGRAM
The Associated Press
12/20/04 15:20 EST
MOSCOW (AP) - Russia has restricted rights to such an extent that it
has joined the countries that are not free for the first time since
the 1991 fall of the Soviet Union, Freedom House said Monday, marking
Moscow's march away from the Western democracies it has embraced as
diplomatic partners.
"This setback for freedom represented the year's most important
political trend," the U.S.-based non-governmental organization wrote
in its annual study, Freedom in the World 2005.
Freedom House noted increased Kremlin control over national television
and other media, limitations on local government, and parliamentary
and presidential elections it said were neither free nor fair.
"Russia's step backward into the 'Not Free' category is the
culmination of a growing trend under President Vladimir Putin to
concentrate political authority, harass and intimidate the media,
and politicize the country's law-enforcement system," Executive
Director Jennifer Windsor said in a statement.
"These moves mark a dangerous and disturbing drift toward
authoritarianism in Russia, made more worrisome by President Putin's
recent heavy-handed meddling in political developments in neighboring
countries, such as Ukraine."
The report accused Putin of exploiting the terrorist seizure of a
school in southern Russia to ram through what Freedom House called
the dismantling of local authority.
In the wake of the September attack, which killed more than 330
people, Putin introduced a plan to end the election of governors
by popular vote and the election of legislators in individual
races. Currently, the 450 seats in the lower house of parliament are
equally split between those filled through party lists and those
contested in district races.
The Russian Foreign Ministry had no immediate comment on the report,
which said that Russia had reached its lowest point where political
rights and civic freedoms are concerned since 1989.
Grigory Yavlinsky, a former member of parliament with the liberal
Yabloko party, said Russia has been "not-free" for more than a
decade now.
"Today in Russia there are no independent mass media, no independent
court, parliament, business. There is no public control over special
forces and police. There are practically no elections which are not
controlled by the authorities," he said.
Freedom House said that on balance, the world saw increased freedom
in 2004: 26 countries showed gains while 11 showed decline. Of the
world's 192 countries, it judged 46 percent free, 26 percent not free,
and the rest partly free. Eight rated as the most repressive: Burma,
Cuba, Libya, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Syria and Turkmenistan.
The NGO said that only Central and Eastern Europe had seen "dramatic
progress" over the past year. It noted that Bosnia-Herzegovina's
rating had improved following the first elections organized entirely
by Bosnian institutions.
In the Middle East, Freedom House rated just Israel as free. Five
countries in the region, including Jordan and Yemen, are partly free,
and 12 are not free. It said the territories occupied by Israel and
run by the Palestinian Authority were not free.
Egypt, Jordan, Morocco and Qatar registered modest gains, Freedom
House said.
It registered democratic gains in the former Soviet republics of
Georgia and Ukraine, where popular protests forced the cancellation
of the results of fraudulent elections in the past 13 months.
"The positive experiences in Georgia and Ukraine indicate that
democratic ferment and nonviolent civic protest are potent forces
for political change," Windsor said. "They also reinforce freedom's
gradual global advance."
The former Soviet republics of Belarus, Armenia and Lithuania saw
setbacks - the first two due to the authorities' increasingly harsh
response to dissent, and the latter because of "worrying questions
about the full autonomy of Lithuania's political leadership" in
the wake of President Roland Paksas' impeachment amid allegations
of influence by the Russian mafia.
Freedom House, a Washington-based, nonpartisan group, was founded
nearly 60 years ago by Americans concerned about threats to
democracy. It conducts advocacy, research and training to encourage
and nurture democracy.