Tweet
Pasadena Star-News, CA
Los Angeles Daily News, CA
July 17 2004
Measure on Armenian killings fought by GOP leaders
Schiff's genocide amendment threatened
By Lisa Friedman
Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON -- A provision deploring the massacre of Armenians in the
Ottoman Empire after World War I has run afoul of Republican leaders
and the Bush administration, who are demanding it be stripped from a
foreign aid bill.
The largely symbolic amendment by Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Pasadena, would
forbid Turkey from using U.S. funds to lobby against a resolution
designating the killing of 1.5 million Armenians between 1915 and
1923 as a genocide.
The law already prohibits foreign governments from using American
foreign aid to lobby. Schiff, however, acknowledged his real goal was
to put the House on record as recognizing the Armenian genocide.
His amendment passed by voice vote late Thursday.
House Speaker Dennis Hastert, R-Ill, reacted angrily Friday, issuing
a statement belittling Schiff's provision. He and House Majority
Leader Tom DeLay, R-Texas, and Majority Whip Roy Blunt, R-Mo., vowed
the resolution will never see the light of day.
"Our relationship with Turkey is too important to us to allow it to
be in any way damaged by a poorly crafted and ultimately meaningless
amendment," Hastert said.
Eliminating the amendment will likely avert a diplomatic crisis with
Turkey, a NATO ally that is home to the strategic Incirlik Air Base.
But the dispute also has provoked a furor in Southern California,
home to more than 54,000 Armenian-Americans.
"We find it deeply offensive that these officials would let a foreign
nation impose its dictates on Congress," said Armen Carapethian,
spokesman for the Glendale-based Armenian National Committee of
America-Western Region.
"If we don't recognize past genocides, then future genocides will
occur."
Armenians estimate more than 1.5 million died in a planned genocide
campaign. Turkey has consistently denied the assertions, putting the
number at about 300,000 and contending that thousands of Turks also
died in what was a multi-party conflict during the last years of the
Ottoman Empire.
Hastert also was responsible for shelving an Armenian genocide
resolution in 2000. At the time, Turkey threatened not to renew the
mandate for U.S. forces using the Incirlik Air Base to patrol what
was then the no-fly zone in northern Iraq.
Schiff noted Friday that Turkey's threats to France and other
European nations that have recognized the genocide have not
materialized, and said he isn't worried about retaliation.
"Our relationship with Turkey will survive recognition of the
Armenian genocide," Schiff said.
Schiff said supporters of the amendment will fight to keep the
language in the bill, which will be negotiated by House and Senate
leaders.
Los Angeles Daily News, CA
July 17 2004
Measure on Armenian killings fought by GOP leaders
Schiff's genocide amendment threatened
By Lisa Friedman
Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON -- A provision deploring the massacre of Armenians in the
Ottoman Empire after World War I has run afoul of Republican leaders
and the Bush administration, who are demanding it be stripped from a
foreign aid bill.
The largely symbolic amendment by Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Pasadena, would
forbid Turkey from using U.S. funds to lobby against a resolution
designating the killing of 1.5 million Armenians between 1915 and
1923 as a genocide.
The law already prohibits foreign governments from using American
foreign aid to lobby. Schiff, however, acknowledged his real goal was
to put the House on record as recognizing the Armenian genocide.
His amendment passed by voice vote late Thursday.
House Speaker Dennis Hastert, R-Ill, reacted angrily Friday, issuing
a statement belittling Schiff's provision. He and House Majority
Leader Tom DeLay, R-Texas, and Majority Whip Roy Blunt, R-Mo., vowed
the resolution will never see the light of day.
"Our relationship with Turkey is too important to us to allow it to
be in any way damaged by a poorly crafted and ultimately meaningless
amendment," Hastert said.
Eliminating the amendment will likely avert a diplomatic crisis with
Turkey, a NATO ally that is home to the strategic Incirlik Air Base.
But the dispute also has provoked a furor in Southern California,
home to more than 54,000 Armenian-Americans.
"We find it deeply offensive that these officials would let a foreign
nation impose its dictates on Congress," said Armen Carapethian,
spokesman for the Glendale-based Armenian National Committee of
America-Western Region.
"If we don't recognize past genocides, then future genocides will
occur."
Armenians estimate more than 1.5 million died in a planned genocide
campaign. Turkey has consistently denied the assertions, putting the
number at about 300,000 and contending that thousands of Turks also
died in what was a multi-party conflict during the last years of the
Ottoman Empire.
Hastert also was responsible for shelving an Armenian genocide
resolution in 2000. At the time, Turkey threatened not to renew the
mandate for U.S. forces using the Incirlik Air Base to patrol what
was then the no-fly zone in northern Iraq.
Schiff noted Friday that Turkey's threats to France and other
European nations that have recognized the genocide have not
materialized, and said he isn't worried about retaliation.
"Our relationship with Turkey will survive recognition of the
Armenian genocide," Schiff said.
Schiff said supporters of the amendment will fight to keep the
language in the bill, which will be negotiated by House and Senate
leaders.