Tweet
Village of Discontent : Residents of Dimitrov charge they are being mistreated
By Zhanna Alexanyan ArmeniaNow reporter
ArmeniaNow
04June2004
During Soviet times Ararat Region's Dimitrov village was populated
mainly by Assyrians. There were also Armenians living in the village,
but just a few. After Armenia became independent or, as villagers say,
"in the years of perestroika", many people left, mostly the Assyrians.
Today, there is either 1,550 villagers or 550, depending on who
you listen to. The higher number comes from village head Ludwig
Khlkhatyan, who cites the total registered residents. Villagers say
the true population is closer to the lower number, about 30 percent
of which are Assyrian, and others refugees from Azerbaijan.
It is a small settlement, but big enough for political problems: Some
in the village accuse Khlkhatyan of misappropriating humanitarian
aid and of maintaining his office through election fraud.
After crops and gardens were damaged last year, International Food
Organization allotted 2,100 kilograms of wheat seeds for families
who suffered loss.
Villagers claim they never got the wheat, and lay the blame on village
head Khlkhatyan. They filed a complaint with the Prosecutor General's
Office, charging that Khlkhatyan sold wheat intended as aid, and gave
some to friends, rather than to families who needed it.
Further, they claim that Khlkhatyan faked the signatures of the
villagers for whom the wheat was intended.
Villagers say they are always late with getting information about aid -
flour, potatoes, etc. - that is sent to the village.
"Humanitarian aid, which the government gives, is stolen and after that
they are surprised when people fill streets protesting and organizing
demonstrations. We have a lot to protest about but we lack fact and
this is the fact," says villager Feodor Badalyan, showing a document
he of what he claims are faked signatures.
"If they fake our signatures can you imagine what else they do? Grabbed
wheat is a fact. Law-enforcement bodies love facts. The crime has
been committed and let it be solved," says Assyrian Ernest Yakubov.
"We had no idea the aid was sent to village and I bought 150 kg. of
wheat for 180 drams (about 33 cents per kilo)," says Assyrian Liova.
However, villagers are more concerned with the fact of faking
signatures than about mis-assigned seeds. They allege that the village
head cohorts with those above him to make profit off of charity.
"So this is how they live on villagers. If head of the village is
punished then crimes committed by people of higher ranks will be
revealed and that's why they protect him," concludes specialist of
Russian and Assyrian languages Taisia Muradova.
Taisia Arsentievna, 79, was born in Dimitrov. She was deputy principal
of the school and is an Honored Teacher.
"For many years head of the village has been stealing and people see
that. But who gets ' Paros' aid? Poor people don't get the aid. Those,
who have cars and cattle, get the aid," the teacher says. "The father
of head of the village says residents of Dimitrov are sheep and his
son is shepherd and he will treat them the way he wants. How long
are we going to live like this and be subjected to mockery?"
For his part, Khlkhatyan is confident of his actions. And, since the
Regional Prosecutor's Office threw out the villagers' case on grounds
that there was "absence of crime in the act", he does not deny that
signatures were faked.
The 39-year old village head says it is wrong to give the villagers
humanitarian aid.
"They teach people to become beggars," Khlkhatyan says. "It doesn't
matter among whom I distributed aid as people would have complained in
any case. If they complain why did they elected me for the third time?"
Villagers answer that they didn't, in fact, elect Khlkhatyan, but that
his election was assured by outdated election rosters that inflate
the number of voters.
The election list, Badalyan says "contains the names of dead
people. Many people are registered in the village but haven't been
living here for a long time."
A winning village head candidate must get two thirds of the
votes. Badalyan says there is no way the actual number of villagers
can outvote the number that were fraudulently counted for Khlkhatyan.
Villagers, both Assyrians and Armenians, are displeased with
administration of the region, especially with Minister of the Regional
Administration Hovik Abrahamyan.
Villagers say all positions in the region are held by relatives of
the minister, including the position responsible for the water pipe
supply, and water is the most painful problem in the village. As a
result of the lack of water people cannot grow vegetables, which is
a more profitable business than wheat (which requires less water).
"Everything dries up and dies and only then we get water," says
villager Nadia Alaverdova. "That's why people leave. And if Assyrians
had water and grew vegetables would they leave? They work in Krasnodar
and Rostov but in that case they would have worked here."
By Zhanna Alexanyan ArmeniaNow reporter
ArmeniaNow
04June2004
During Soviet times Ararat Region's Dimitrov village was populated
mainly by Assyrians. There were also Armenians living in the village,
but just a few. After Armenia became independent or, as villagers say,
"in the years of perestroika", many people left, mostly the Assyrians.
Today, there is either 1,550 villagers or 550, depending on who
you listen to. The higher number comes from village head Ludwig
Khlkhatyan, who cites the total registered residents. Villagers say
the true population is closer to the lower number, about 30 percent
of which are Assyrian, and others refugees from Azerbaijan.
It is a small settlement, but big enough for political problems: Some
in the village accuse Khlkhatyan of misappropriating humanitarian
aid and of maintaining his office through election fraud.
After crops and gardens were damaged last year, International Food
Organization allotted 2,100 kilograms of wheat seeds for families
who suffered loss.
Villagers claim they never got the wheat, and lay the blame on village
head Khlkhatyan. They filed a complaint with the Prosecutor General's
Office, charging that Khlkhatyan sold wheat intended as aid, and gave
some to friends, rather than to families who needed it.
Further, they claim that Khlkhatyan faked the signatures of the
villagers for whom the wheat was intended.
Villagers say they are always late with getting information about aid -
flour, potatoes, etc. - that is sent to the village.
"Humanitarian aid, which the government gives, is stolen and after that
they are surprised when people fill streets protesting and organizing
demonstrations. We have a lot to protest about but we lack fact and
this is the fact," says villager Feodor Badalyan, showing a document
he of what he claims are faked signatures.
"If they fake our signatures can you imagine what else they do? Grabbed
wheat is a fact. Law-enforcement bodies love facts. The crime has
been committed and let it be solved," says Assyrian Ernest Yakubov.
"We had no idea the aid was sent to village and I bought 150 kg. of
wheat for 180 drams (about 33 cents per kilo)," says Assyrian Liova.
However, villagers are more concerned with the fact of faking
signatures than about mis-assigned seeds. They allege that the village
head cohorts with those above him to make profit off of charity.
"So this is how they live on villagers. If head of the village is
punished then crimes committed by people of higher ranks will be
revealed and that's why they protect him," concludes specialist of
Russian and Assyrian languages Taisia Muradova.
Taisia Arsentievna, 79, was born in Dimitrov. She was deputy principal
of the school and is an Honored Teacher.
"For many years head of the village has been stealing and people see
that. But who gets ' Paros' aid? Poor people don't get the aid. Those,
who have cars and cattle, get the aid," the teacher says. "The father
of head of the village says residents of Dimitrov are sheep and his
son is shepherd and he will treat them the way he wants. How long
are we going to live like this and be subjected to mockery?"
For his part, Khlkhatyan is confident of his actions. And, since the
Regional Prosecutor's Office threw out the villagers' case on grounds
that there was "absence of crime in the act", he does not deny that
signatures were faked.
The 39-year old village head says it is wrong to give the villagers
humanitarian aid.
"They teach people to become beggars," Khlkhatyan says. "It doesn't
matter among whom I distributed aid as people would have complained in
any case. If they complain why did they elected me for the third time?"
Villagers answer that they didn't, in fact, elect Khlkhatyan, but that
his election was assured by outdated election rosters that inflate
the number of voters.
The election list, Badalyan says "contains the names of dead
people. Many people are registered in the village but haven't been
living here for a long time."
A winning village head candidate must get two thirds of the
votes. Badalyan says there is no way the actual number of villagers
can outvote the number that were fraudulently counted for Khlkhatyan.
Villagers, both Assyrians and Armenians, are displeased with
administration of the region, especially with Minister of the Regional
Administration Hovik Abrahamyan.
Villagers say all positions in the region are held by relatives of
the minister, including the position responsible for the water pipe
supply, and water is the most painful problem in the village. As a
result of the lack of water people cannot grow vegetables, which is
a more profitable business than wheat (which requires less water).
"Everything dries up and dies and only then we get water," says
villager Nadia Alaverdova. "That's why people leave. And if Assyrians
had water and grew vegetables would they leave? They work in Krasnodar
and Rostov but in that case they would have worked here."