Tweet
This Crisis Should be Resolved Too
By EKREM DUMANLI
Zaman, Turkey
Feb 10 2005
One cannot deny the long-term crisis in Turkish-American relations.
The tension, which began with the objection to the March 1
deployment, deepens a bit at every opportunity.
Turkey has many concerns about the developments in Northern Iraq.
Turkey's expectation of an operation against the Kurdistan Workers'
Party (PKK) has turned into disappointment. Kurdish leaders make
provocative statements on the Kerkuk (Kirkuk) issue and the US
usually foots the bill. The idea that Iran will benefit the most from
a new Iraqi state with a Shiite majority is cause for concern…
The problem is not just limited to Iraq. The US position and Turkey's
official discourse conflict with one another on the ecumenical
debate. Turkey wants to play a role in the Middle Eastern peace
process, but it also explicitly accuses Israel of "state terrorism."
This position brings Turkey head to head with US foreign policy.
The magic of the diplomatic profession becomes apparent during
difficult times like these.
Turkey should continue its relations with the US on good terms and
also maintain balance in the rest of the world. Although policies
based on continuous tension straighten out over time, scars usually
remain. Diplomatic foresight allows intervention before tension
peaks.
Last week, I had the opportunity to chat with people in many places,
in particular at The Washington Post. Being in Washington was a big
advantage for a journalist just days before US Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice was scheduled to visit Turkey. Almost everyone was
busy making preparations; almost everyone had questions; almost
everyone had their own interpretation regarding the visit.
Apparently, the US wants to get rid of its negative image that was
created during the Iraqi war and is therefore looking for solutions.
It is also clear that they want to have a closer relationship with
other countries in the world (particularly with Europe) during Bush's
new term in presidency. The worldwide spread of anti-Americanism is
cause for tremendous concern. Anti-Americanism in Turkey has reached
80 percent according to a British Broadcast Company's (BBC) public
survey. This finding also concerns the US.
It is hard to believe that this public survey is correct. The Turkish
public is not an enemy to the US, but it is clear that there is
concern about US policies in the Middle East. The Turkish public has
not forgotten the cooperation of Muslims and Americans in Bosnia,
Kosovo, and Somalia, the US help in the seizure of PKK leader
Abdullah Ocalan, the direct US support for European Union (EU)
membership, etc. The chain of incidents that began with the March 1
motion, however, keep tensions running high. Being on scathing terms
sometimes strengthens conspiracy theories as well. As in the famous
sack incident [when US soldiers put bags over the heads of Turkish
soldiers in Iraq], there are other incidents such as being unable to
do anything about the PKK in Northern Iraq that ferment
misunderstanding and anger.
To be honest, US-Turkey relations may face a more difficult period in
the upcoming months. For instance, the "Armenian genocide bill,"
which may ward off a final attack at any minute, might harm Turkey. A
Turkish deputy's description of US activity in Iraq as "genocide" was
discussed and passed over by Turkish interest groups. That the US
feels unbelievable discomfort is clear enough. A deputy's remarks are
not, in fact, binding to the Turkish government, but since relations
are built on tension, a new crisis could emerge from almost any
issue.
There are critical issues that both countries have put in the deep
freeze. These issues should be dealt with using clear minds and
diplomatic courtesy. Of course, various possibilities could bring
some opportunities to Turkey, but Turkey cannot give up its role as
America's "strategic partner." Turkish diplomacy has solved many
crises skillfully, and it should solve this, too. I hope Rice's visit
to Turkey becomes a significant step toward normalized relations.
--Boundary_(ID_AtEjL18vvyiGA5r5nYt4gw)--
By EKREM DUMANLI
Zaman, Turkey
Feb 10 2005
One cannot deny the long-term crisis in Turkish-American relations.
The tension, which began with the objection to the March 1
deployment, deepens a bit at every opportunity.
Turkey has many concerns about the developments in Northern Iraq.
Turkey's expectation of an operation against the Kurdistan Workers'
Party (PKK) has turned into disappointment. Kurdish leaders make
provocative statements on the Kerkuk (Kirkuk) issue and the US
usually foots the bill. The idea that Iran will benefit the most from
a new Iraqi state with a Shiite majority is cause for concern…
The problem is not just limited to Iraq. The US position and Turkey's
official discourse conflict with one another on the ecumenical
debate. Turkey wants to play a role in the Middle Eastern peace
process, but it also explicitly accuses Israel of "state terrorism."
This position brings Turkey head to head with US foreign policy.
The magic of the diplomatic profession becomes apparent during
difficult times like these.
Turkey should continue its relations with the US on good terms and
also maintain balance in the rest of the world. Although policies
based on continuous tension straighten out over time, scars usually
remain. Diplomatic foresight allows intervention before tension
peaks.
Last week, I had the opportunity to chat with people in many places,
in particular at The Washington Post. Being in Washington was a big
advantage for a journalist just days before US Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice was scheduled to visit Turkey. Almost everyone was
busy making preparations; almost everyone had questions; almost
everyone had their own interpretation regarding the visit.
Apparently, the US wants to get rid of its negative image that was
created during the Iraqi war and is therefore looking for solutions.
It is also clear that they want to have a closer relationship with
other countries in the world (particularly with Europe) during Bush's
new term in presidency. The worldwide spread of anti-Americanism is
cause for tremendous concern. Anti-Americanism in Turkey has reached
80 percent according to a British Broadcast Company's (BBC) public
survey. This finding also concerns the US.
It is hard to believe that this public survey is correct. The Turkish
public is not an enemy to the US, but it is clear that there is
concern about US policies in the Middle East. The Turkish public has
not forgotten the cooperation of Muslims and Americans in Bosnia,
Kosovo, and Somalia, the US help in the seizure of PKK leader
Abdullah Ocalan, the direct US support for European Union (EU)
membership, etc. The chain of incidents that began with the March 1
motion, however, keep tensions running high. Being on scathing terms
sometimes strengthens conspiracy theories as well. As in the famous
sack incident [when US soldiers put bags over the heads of Turkish
soldiers in Iraq], there are other incidents such as being unable to
do anything about the PKK in Northern Iraq that ferment
misunderstanding and anger.
To be honest, US-Turkey relations may face a more difficult period in
the upcoming months. For instance, the "Armenian genocide bill,"
which may ward off a final attack at any minute, might harm Turkey. A
Turkish deputy's description of US activity in Iraq as "genocide" was
discussed and passed over by Turkish interest groups. That the US
feels unbelievable discomfort is clear enough. A deputy's remarks are
not, in fact, binding to the Turkish government, but since relations
are built on tension, a new crisis could emerge from almost any
issue.
There are critical issues that both countries have put in the deep
freeze. These issues should be dealt with using clear minds and
diplomatic courtesy. Of course, various possibilities could bring
some opportunities to Turkey, but Turkey cannot give up its role as
America's "strategic partner." Turkish diplomacy has solved many
crises skillfully, and it should solve this, too. I hope Rice's visit
to Turkey becomes a significant step toward normalized relations.
--Boundary_(ID_AtEjL18vvyiGA5r5nYt4gw)--