Tweet
Ha'aretz, Israel
May 1 2005
Analysis / Turkey: a friend for trade
By Zvi Bar'el
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan waited three months after
his foreign minister returned from Israel before calling Prime
Minister Ariel Sharon and setting the time for his visit here.
Erdogan arrives today, and it can be expected that Israel and Turkey
will continue to maintain ties on two different tracks - economic and
military on the one hand and political-diplomatic on the other hand.
>From the economic-military perspective, life appears rosy as usual.
The trade between the two states totals some $1.4 billion; Turkey is
about to purchase some $183 million worth of Israeli drones; Turkish
Defense Minister Vecdi Gonul, who is arriving with Erdogan, intends
to discuss purchasing Popeye and Arrow missiles.
Israeli tourists continue to flood Turkey, which would also like to
see Russian gas for Israel being piped through it.
But, as far as Erdogan's Middle Eastern policy is concerned, Israel
is seen as an external force at best and a hindrance at worst. Turkey
and Syria are cooperating in economic security affairs - in mid-April
the Turkish president visited Damascus in defiance of American
pressure to cancel the visit. Turkey's relations with Iran are
warming up due to joint interests regarding Iraq's future.
Turkish public opinion vis-a-vis the United States is not merely
critical but at times hostile. Turkey does not consider its
friendship with Israel as capable of influencing Turkey's acceptance
process into the European Union. However, Turkey sees no
contradiction between its strong economic-military ties with Israel
and its sometimes blatant criticism of Israel (Erdogan called
Israel's policy in the territories "state terrorism").
Turkey is trying to keep all its options open. For example, it is
willing to cooperate with the U.S. in the defense force against
Russia in the Caspian Sea region while at the same time purchasing
from Russia a strategic product like gas. It wants to be a member of
the European Union but refuses to yield to the demand to recognize
the Armenian massacre in 1915 as genocide. Turkey needs American
support to continue receiving World Bank assistance, but it slams
American policy in Iraq and in the Middle East.
"Turkey still believes it is a power, at least a regional one," a
Turkish official tells Haaretz. "But it keeps discovering that it is
not desirable as a broker in regional conflicts, and finds other
powers doing as they will in `Turkish' areas." Israel's relations
with Turkey should be seen in this perspective, he says, noting that
"Turkey is not expected to change its policy of keeping its options
open following this visit."
May 1 2005
Analysis / Turkey: a friend for trade
By Zvi Bar'el
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan waited three months after
his foreign minister returned from Israel before calling Prime
Minister Ariel Sharon and setting the time for his visit here.
Erdogan arrives today, and it can be expected that Israel and Turkey
will continue to maintain ties on two different tracks - economic and
military on the one hand and political-diplomatic on the other hand.
>From the economic-military perspective, life appears rosy as usual.
The trade between the two states totals some $1.4 billion; Turkey is
about to purchase some $183 million worth of Israeli drones; Turkish
Defense Minister Vecdi Gonul, who is arriving with Erdogan, intends
to discuss purchasing Popeye and Arrow missiles.
Israeli tourists continue to flood Turkey, which would also like to
see Russian gas for Israel being piped through it.
But, as far as Erdogan's Middle Eastern policy is concerned, Israel
is seen as an external force at best and a hindrance at worst. Turkey
and Syria are cooperating in economic security affairs - in mid-April
the Turkish president visited Damascus in defiance of American
pressure to cancel the visit. Turkey's relations with Iran are
warming up due to joint interests regarding Iraq's future.
Turkish public opinion vis-a-vis the United States is not merely
critical but at times hostile. Turkey does not consider its
friendship with Israel as capable of influencing Turkey's acceptance
process into the European Union. However, Turkey sees no
contradiction between its strong economic-military ties with Israel
and its sometimes blatant criticism of Israel (Erdogan called
Israel's policy in the territories "state terrorism").
Turkey is trying to keep all its options open. For example, it is
willing to cooperate with the U.S. in the defense force against
Russia in the Caspian Sea region while at the same time purchasing
from Russia a strategic product like gas. It wants to be a member of
the European Union but refuses to yield to the demand to recognize
the Armenian massacre in 1915 as genocide. Turkey needs American
support to continue receiving World Bank assistance, but it slams
American policy in Iraq and in the Middle East.
"Turkey still believes it is a power, at least a regional one," a
Turkish official tells Haaretz. "But it keeps discovering that it is
not desirable as a broker in regional conflicts, and finds other
powers doing as they will in `Turkish' areas." Israel's relations
with Turkey should be seen in this perspective, he says, noting that
"Turkey is not expected to change its policy of keeping its options
open following this visit."