Tweet
TURKEY CHARGES ACCLAIMED AUTHOR
Karl Vick
Kurdistan Regional Government, Iraq
Sept 1 2005
ISTANBUL, Aug. 31 -- An acclaimed Turkish novelist, Orhan Pamuk,
has been charged with the "public denigrating of Turkish identity"
and faces a possible prison sentence of three years, his publisher
said Wednesday.
The charge stems from an interview that Pamuk gave to a Swiss newspaper
in February in which he said certain topics were regarded as off-limits
in Turkey. As examples, he listed the massacre of Armenians in 1915
and the ongoing war between Turkish security forces and Kurdish
guerrillas as examples.
"Thirty-thousand Kurds were killed here, 1 million Armenians as
well. And almost no one talks about it," Pamuk told the newspaper,
Tages-Anzeiger. "Therefore, I do."
Turkey considers the Armenian deaths a consequence of war, with severe
casualties on both sides, while Armenians say the deaths constitute
a genocide. Under Turkish law, people can be jailed for differing
with the government's line on the deaths, as well as on the presence
of Turkish troops in Cyprus, which Turkey invaded in 1974, and other
"fundamental national interests."
Turkey's penal code was revised this year in hopes of bringing laws on
freedom of expression closer to international standards, as demanded
by the European Union, which Turkey wants to join. Organizations
representing writers and journalists say more changes are needed.
Pamuk was "just trying to point out that first you have to face it --
a tragedy or a dispute or a problem, at least," said Tugrul Pasaoglu,
Pamuk's publisher and an editor at Iletisim Yayinlari, a publishing
house in Istanbul. "If you don't talk about it, then you can't find
a solution."
Pamuk, 53, is the most acclaimed novelist to emerge from Turkey
in at least a generation. His books, including "My Name Is Red,"
have been translated into more than 20 languages. His latest novel,
"Snow," explores the tensions between Turkey's rigorously secular
military establishment and political Islam by stranding a lovesick
poet in a snowbound eastern Turkish city during a coup.
In Turkey, however, Pamuk's international success has been
overshadowed by his comments in Tages-Anzeiger. The remarks incensed
ultranationalists, a powerful force in a country that opinion polls
show may be the world's most patriotic.
"There is nothing that constitutes a crime in this interview," said
Nazan Senol, an attorney representing Pamuk, whose court date was
set for Dec. 16. She noted that another state prosecutor's office
also investigated the allegations and decided against filing charges.
Turgay Evsen, the prosecutor who went forward with the case, earlier
this year filed the same charge against a Turkish journalist of
Armenian heritage, Hrant Dink. Evsen declined to comment on the
Pamuk case.
Karl Vick
Kurdistan Regional Government, Iraq
Sept 1 2005
ISTANBUL, Aug. 31 -- An acclaimed Turkish novelist, Orhan Pamuk,
has been charged with the "public denigrating of Turkish identity"
and faces a possible prison sentence of three years, his publisher
said Wednesday.
The charge stems from an interview that Pamuk gave to a Swiss newspaper
in February in which he said certain topics were regarded as off-limits
in Turkey. As examples, he listed the massacre of Armenians in 1915
and the ongoing war between Turkish security forces and Kurdish
guerrillas as examples.
"Thirty-thousand Kurds were killed here, 1 million Armenians as
well. And almost no one talks about it," Pamuk told the newspaper,
Tages-Anzeiger. "Therefore, I do."
Turkey considers the Armenian deaths a consequence of war, with severe
casualties on both sides, while Armenians say the deaths constitute
a genocide. Under Turkish law, people can be jailed for differing
with the government's line on the deaths, as well as on the presence
of Turkish troops in Cyprus, which Turkey invaded in 1974, and other
"fundamental national interests."
Turkey's penal code was revised this year in hopes of bringing laws on
freedom of expression closer to international standards, as demanded
by the European Union, which Turkey wants to join. Organizations
representing writers and journalists say more changes are needed.
Pamuk was "just trying to point out that first you have to face it --
a tragedy or a dispute or a problem, at least," said Tugrul Pasaoglu,
Pamuk's publisher and an editor at Iletisim Yayinlari, a publishing
house in Istanbul. "If you don't talk about it, then you can't find
a solution."
Pamuk, 53, is the most acclaimed novelist to emerge from Turkey
in at least a generation. His books, including "My Name Is Red,"
have been translated into more than 20 languages. His latest novel,
"Snow," explores the tensions between Turkey's rigorously secular
military establishment and political Islam by stranding a lovesick
poet in a snowbound eastern Turkish city during a coup.
In Turkey, however, Pamuk's international success has been
overshadowed by his comments in Tages-Anzeiger. The remarks incensed
ultranationalists, a powerful force in a country that opinion polls
show may be the world's most patriotic.
"There is nothing that constitutes a crime in this interview," said
Nazan Senol, an attorney representing Pamuk, whose court date was
set for Dec. 16. She noted that another state prosecutor's office
also investigated the allegations and decided against filing charges.
Turgay Evsen, the prosecutor who went forward with the case, earlier
this year filed the same charge against a Turkish journalist of
Armenian heritage, Hrant Dink. Evsen declined to comment on the
Pamuk case.