Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

When Silence Is Betrayal: Being Silent Against Injustice Is A Crime

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • When Silence Is Betrayal: Being Silent Against Injustice Is A Crime

    WHEN SILENCE IS BETRAYAL: BEING SILENT AGAINST INJUSTICE IS A CRIME ITSELF
    By Aland Mizell

    Kurdish Media, UK
    Nov 3 2006

    The collapse of the Soviet Union opened the door of opportunity
    for Turkey. Private companies and the Turkish government quickly
    implemented special policies to develop their presence in Central
    Asia. Because many Turks believed that their ancestors come from
    Central Asia, many Turkish people called Central Asians "Ata yurd,"
    meaning fatherland. In their view, the Soviet Union was a divided
    Turkic nation for more than seventy years. After the fall of the
    Communist regime in this area, Turks were happy to go back to their
    ancestral land. Turkish nationalists like the Grey Wolves and religious
    sects like the Gulen community seized this opportunity, especially
    the Gulen movement's leader with his businessmen, teachers, students,
    and supporters to go to Ata yurd. Gulen and the Turkish government,
    with ex-president Ozal leading the charge, undertook a twelve-day
    trip to Central Asia to establish economic and cultural networks
    between the Gulen movement and other social networks.

    Gulen opened schools all over Central Asian countries. Turkish
    delegates visited these countries getting emotional, saying that
    after such a long time Turks were able once again to visit their
    fatherland. They invited Uzbek, Kazakh, Turkmen and Kyrgyz officials
    to Turkey to rebuild the broken bridge. It was a huge economic
    opportunity for Turkish markets to explore Central Asian countries,
    and for Turkey to take advantage of its history, culture, religion,
    and background to use the Central Asian rich resources and to invest
    heavily there. Turkish nationalists even wrote a song about how
    they missed their fatherland. The Gulen movement took advantage
    of this same historical, cultural, and religious background and
    helped their brothers and sisters in Central Asia. When the people
    of Central Asia asked them why they helped with schools and free
    education, they replied that they did so because brothers should
    help brothers. Not only that, but also they explained that Central
    Asia is their fatherland, so they should help one another. This was
    a very valid point because, yes, Turkey should help their brothers
    and sisters in Central Asia; and, yes, they should take advantage
    of the rich economic resources and eliminate the poverty to end the
    suffering of poor. Since that time, Turkish businessmen have invested
    multi-million dollars in Central Asian countries.

    Shared resources among brothers would be mutually beneficial. Why
    can the Kurdish people in Iraq not share the rich oil resources with
    their other Kurdish brothers in the north? Why can the Kurds not
    reestablish their economic, social, educational, and political bonds?

    Kurds who live in the south of their region have much more Kurdish
    educational experience than the Kurdish people who live in the north,
    because the Turkish regime forbids Kurdish education in public;
    the regional government in northern Iraq does provide Kurdish schools.

    Therefore, it makes sense for the Kurdish people who want to learn
    the true history of their ancestors to study in southern Kurdish
    universities. When Turkish religion groups and nationalist groups
    opened universities in Central Asia, and the Turkish government spent
    so much money opening universities in Turkistan just to teach Turkish
    history and to rebuild brotherhood, why can the Kurds not do it?

    Political barriers prevent such policies. When the mayor of the
    Diyarbakir wanted to invite Kurdish leaders from Iraq to participate in
    the Kurdish Nevroz holiday, the Turkish government radically opposed
    the invitation and accused the Kurds of racism and separatism.

    Powerful Muslim leaders like Gulen always talk about peace, justice,
    and equality. Many people believe in his word. But if Gulen is so
    sincere in what he is saying, why then is he so silent about Kurdish
    injustice? Why did he never publicly denounce the Turkish government's
    prejudiced policy toward the Kurdish people? Today Gulen and others
    accuse America of being oil thirsty and claim that this is the reason
    that America is in the Middle East. Well, then Mr. Gulen, why did you
    open schools in the southern Kurdish region? Why did you open schools
    in Central Asia, Russia, China, Cambodia, the Philippines, Colombia,
    Japan, America, Australia, and Germany as well as in many other
    countries? When you open schools in all those country, you teach the
    Turkish language and Turkish culture, and you open Turkish businesses
    as well. You criticize America for being in the Middle East because
    of national interests, which is true, but you also have national
    interests. At least America does not have a plan to conquer the whole
    world as you do in setting up a pan-Islamic global state. At least
    America saved the Muslims from the Serbs while other Muslims could not
    do anything. In front of your eyes, Saddam gassed thousands of Kurds.

    Why were you so silent? Saddam's helicopter chased Kurds, Kurds running
    to find a safe place to hide from his slaughter, and Turkish soldiers
    sent them back. Why were you silent? Isn't silence against injustice
    a crime?

    It is acceptance of injustice. Now that the Americans and the British
    have taken power from Saddam, you are bothered because the Kurds
    will have a decent life. Without justice peace is nothing but a nice
    sounding word.

    Courage has no value unless joined by justice. Thirty minutes of
    justice is worth your years of prayers.

    After Gulf War I, the world was shocked by the status of the
    Kurds, especially Saddam's 'genocide against the Kurds and Turkey's
    oppression policy toward the Kurds. Kurds do not have a friend but
    their destiny. The world was silent, when Saddam gassed thousands
    of Kurds and when Turkish soldiers and especially its police forces
    kidnapped, murdered, tortured, raped, and denied their basic God-given
    rights. God supposedly created every human being equal, and none can
    take and individual's rights way.

    Also God created every creature in His image, so the human tragedy is
    awful in itself, but the silence of those who should be concerned by
    virtue of their ties with humanity is worse. The spiritual leaders who
    preach human values such as morality, God's love, equality, those in
    the Christian and as well as Muslim communities, make the silence more
    terrible. While the world was silent, the devil was murdering Kurdish
    men, women, and children. Genocide against the Kurds happened in 1988,
    but nobody knew until the Gulf War. Or did the people know but just
    were silent? Where were the principles of God's love for humanity,
    equality, and moral values? Why was God's love suddenly turned to
    God's hatred if judged by these spiritual leaders' response? Does
    God not like the Kurds?

    Where is God's justice that many Muslim leaders talk about? Why were
    fellow Muslims so silent while many Kurdish mothers cried for their
    love ones? Why were they forgotten? After the second Gulf War, the
    Turkish government officially expressed their concern over the fate
    of 300 thousand Turkmen living in Iraq, but we have not heard the
    same concern from the Muslim leaders about millions of Kurds living
    in the same region.

    The Turkish government and religion leaders for all their concern made
    sure that the Turkmen were safe and sound and that harm did not come to
    any of them. Was this concern because the blood of Turkmen has a high
    value compared to that of other ethnicities? Was it because God created
    Turks superior to the Kurds? For more than thirty million Kurds, their
    dignity is daily taken away; their rights have been denied to them
    before the eyes of the corrupt religion leaders, elite politicians,
    media, and even society itself. Every day we see houses of Kurds being
    burned by the military, we see the Kurdish people being humiliated,
    we see the Kurdish people suffering, and we see Kurds disappearing. We
    even learn that the Turkish government put a bomb in a bookstore,
    trying to terrorize the region. On our television screen everyday
    international news bulletins document that the military is trying to
    make a veritable hell of their lives.

    Not only has that Gulen been silent against injustice, but also he is
    denying that anything happened in Turkey, "Therefore in our country
    there is no deprivation due to discrimination in general terms, so
    some current events cannot be considered the last drop overflowing
    the glass. Everybody can become soldiers in Turkey. Every group can
    have one of their people be generals or even president. Look for
    example, our second president from Malatya was Kurdish, and so was
    Turgut Ozal, the eighth president." Does his statement declare that
    nobody in Turkey is being deprived of the benefaction of democracy?

    He further argues, "Sometimes the state's protection has been
    perceived as oppression by some. Whether the state did actually
    oppress anyone, I can't say. That would be lack of respect for
    my state. But the impression was created by the propaganda that
    provoked the people." Denial may be the stepsister of silence. How
    many journalists working on articles related to Kurdish issues has
    the government killed?

    How many Kurdish intellectuals have been kidnapped or assassinated,
    or how many newspapers offices and magazines have been raided.

    Interestingly, none of those who have committed crimes against Kurds
    have been caught.

    Why were Muslims absent in such a bewildering manner when many
    Kurds suffered from genocide? Why does Gulen remain silent about
    the tragedies of millions of Kurds while he is concerned about the
    fate of the three hundred thousand Turkmen in Iraq? Is the blood of
    the Kurdish people cheaper than Turcoman blood? Why do Muslims and
    other religious leaders still keep silent in the face of injustice;
    being silent in the face of injustice is in itself is injustice. If
    Kurds are not now being angry, when will they be angry? Why was not
    their voice heard or action seen in angry protest? When Israel bombed
    Lebanon, millions of Muslims went to streets to protest against the
    U.S. in Lebanon. Who bombed the bookstore in Semdinli province? Was
    the government creating terror by first burning houses and villages,
    and then by forcing them to leave their home, by making them homeless,
    and now by bombing public spaces? Are these actions for protection of
    the people or destruction of the people? It is true that there is no
    problem in Turkey about being a beneficiary of democracy or getting
    moved up to a good position unless you have to be Turk to do so.

    However, when you say, "I am a Kurd," those observations do not
    apply; instead, you are automatically labeled a terrorist. In other
    word, there is not a problem as long as you say, "I am a Turk in
    Turkey." Also Gulen says Ozal was a Kurd as well, but how many times
    did Ozal go on television and say, "I am a Kurd"? Is it very sad for
    Kurds that many Kurds who are successful businessmen, intellectuals,
    or young intelligent students believe what Gulen is saying and are
    being indoctrinated.

    Why then should Kurds trust the Turkish government? When Tayyip Erdogan
    gave a historical speech in the main Kurdish city of Diyarbakir,
    for the first time he pointed out that "the great states are those
    who learn from their mistakes." He hinted that the long policy of
    suppression against the Kurdish minority had been the greatest error,
    but did Erdogan keep his promise? Did Erdogan compensate the Kurds
    for the houses that had been destroyed by the military? Did Erdogan
    build new schools, roads, and clinics? Did Erdogan create jobs and
    opportunities to eliminate unemployment? What he did was increase
    the size of the military in southeastern Turkey and based the biggest
    battalion around Diyarbakir.

    When Diyarbakir's mayor Baydemir explained that southeastern resources
    should not be going to the west for processing, he explained that
    Batman's oil is going to western Turkey for processing. Why should
    it not be processed in eastern Turkey, so that it will create the
    jobs for the Kurdish people? Again many Turks accuse Mayor Baydemir
    of being racist and charge him with wanting to divide Turkey and to
    establish an independent Kurdistan. Why do Turkish government officials
    create such paranoia? What Baydemir was saying is that the petroleum
    belongs to the east, the east is suffering high unemployment, and,
    consequently, why can the oil not be processed in eastern Turkey;
    in that way the policy will create some jobs for the Kurds.

    Who bombed the bookstore in Semdinli province? Was the government
    creating terror by first burning houses and villages, and then by
    forcing them to leave their home, by making them homeless, and now by
    bombing public spaces? Are these actions for protection of the people
    or destruction of the people? It is true that there is no problem
    in Turkey about being a beneficiary of democracy or getting moved
    up to a good position unless you have to be Turk to do so. However,
    when you say, "I am a Kurd," those observations do not apply; instead,
    you are automatically labeled a terrorist. In other word, there is not
    a problem as long as you say, "I am a Turk in Turkey." Also Gulen says
    Ozal was a Kurd as well, but how many times did Ozal go on television
    and say, "I am a Kurd"? Is it very sad for Kurds that many Kurds
    who are successful businessmen, intellectuals, or young intelligent
    students believe what Gulen is saying and are being indoctrinated.

    In 1963, Dr. Martin Luther King, in his letter from a prison cell
    wrote, "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." When the
    writer Orhan Pamuk stood against injustice and broke the silence saying
    that "one million Armenians and 30,000 Kurds were killed in those lands
    and nobody but me will talk about it," he was charged with denigrating
    the Turkish national identity and insulting Turkishness. Thanks
    to the European Union Turkey could not put him in prison. Now many
    Turkish religious groups, newspapers, and nationalists are attacking
    Mr. Pamuk and questioning his intellectual capability. What Mr. Pamuk
    did show was that a human being cannot sit in his home and not be
    concerned about what is happening in southeastern Turkey, because for
    Mr. Pamuk and us, we are inescapably and mutually tied in a single
    destiny, and whatever happens to one directly affects all, at least
    indirectly. Injustice anywhere in Turkey is a threat to all people
    living in Turkey. It is the business of God fearing, peace loving
    people to speak up against injustice.

    Like sociologist Ismail Besikci wrote that one of the most tragic
    events in the history of the Middles East and in the world in our
    time was the implementation of an interstate system of colonialism
    in Kurdistan. Even though Besikci himself was a Turk speaking against
    injustice, he served years in prison for not being silent. The colonial
    system in Kurdistan can be easily described as a human tragedy because
    of the suffering of millions of Kurds. History has been determined;
    millions are dead and their family property has been divided. Silence
    reaps grave consequences. Religious leaders in other countries remained
    silent in the face of racism. When Hitler operated the vast factory
    of death where the Nazis tortured, shot, gassed, starved, raped, six
    million innocent human beings -- Jews, the handicapped, and dissidents,
    the world failed to confront it. Now Germany is speaking out, but the
    victims are dead. Seemingly then as now even God was silent, perhaps
    waiting for one of his creations to speak out against injustice.

    Aland Mizell, a Kurdish legal expert, is with the University of Texas
    at Dallas school of Social Science and a regular KurdishMedia.com
    writer.

    http://www.kurdmedia.com /news.asp?id=13522
Working...
X