Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Questions Surround French President's Visit

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Questions Surround French President's Visit

    QUESTIONS SURROUND FRENCH PRESIDENT'S VISIT

    Eurasianet, NY
    October 11, 2006

    Opinions are divided about the purpose of French President Jacques
    Chirac's recent state visit to Armenia, with some observers contending
    that the mission had more to do with Turkey's candidacy for European
    Union membership than with the South Caucasus state itself.

    Armenian officials presented the September 29-October 1 visit as
    a sign of the country's growing regional importance; the country
    was the second Commonwealth of Independent States member visited by
    Chirac after Russia. "I believe that the visit of President Chirac was
    ... a result of the fact that today Armenia is a factor of stability,
    a reliable partner in the region for France and [other] big countries,"
    Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian was quoted by the Azg daily newspaper
    as telling reporters.

    However, many experts did not share this outlook. Some have charged
    that opposition to Turkey's membership bid for the European Union
    prompted the French leader's visit. By visiting Armenia and discussing
    the Ottoman Empire's 1915 massacre of thousands of ethnic Armenians,
    Chirac was, in effect, reiterating long-standing European skepticism
    about Turkey's human rights record, a potential barrier to European
    Union (EU) membership.

    "Judging by the deeds and the words of Jacques Chirac [during the
    visit], his thoughts were in neighboring Turkey rather than in
    Armenia," commented former Armenian Foreign Minister Aleksander
    Arzumanian in an October 6 interview with the Russian newspaper
    Izvestia. "And this is understandable, as now serious problems have
    emerged between united Europe and Turkey."

    Chirac could not avoid addressing the topic of the 1915 massacre, which
    France recognized officially as genocide in 2001. European media showed
    Chirac during a Yerevan press conference exhorting Turkey to recognize
    the massacre as genocide in the same way that Germany has recognized
    the Holocaust. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive]. "I
    believe every country becomes greater when it recognizes its errors
    and crimes of the past," Chirac said when questioned if Turkey needed
    to acknowledge the Ottoman genocide in order to gain EU membership.

    Chirac's comments produced a sharply negative reaction from Turkey,
    including threats to expel the 70,000 Armenian citizens now reportedly
    living in the country. The backlash prompted a renewed discussion in
    Armenia about whether its call for the 1915 events to be universally
    recognized as genocide suits the country's interests.

    In an October 4 editorial, the Haykakan Zhamanak independent daily
    wrote that France is keeping the Armenian genocide issue as a "moral
    excuse" for not granting Turkey EU membership if political reasons
    do not work. Even if Turkey recognizes the massacre as genocide, the
    paper continued, Armenian President Robert Kocharian's administration
    has affirmed that only the descendants of the victims, most of whom
    are Diaspora Armenians, could present material claims against Turkey.

    "It turns out that the policy of the Armenian authorities serves,
    first of all, the interests of the citizens of France, whereas Armenian
    citizens [must] develop with blocked communication routes [with Turkey]
    for one more century, for the sake of the happiness of United Europe,"
    the editorial read.

    While Chirac's comments may have stirred controversy among Armenians,
    the French leader made clear his support for the government's refusal
    to transfer negotiations with Azerbaijan over the breakaway region
    of Nagorno-Karabakh to the United Nations General Assembly or the
    Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, as Azerbaijan has
    proposed. Talks currently take place within the framework of the
    Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe's Minsk Group,
    a tripartite body headed by France, the United States and Russia.

    According to news reports citing Azerbaijan's foreign ministry,
    Chirac is expected to visit Azerbaijan in early 2007, following a
    January state visit to Paris by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev.

    Other analysts see regional issues as motivating the French president's
    trip. A desire to compete with Russia and, maybe, the United States
    for influence in the South Caucasus could be one explanation,
    said David Hovhannisian, a political scientist and former Armenian
    ambassador to Syria. Chirac is also interested in Iran, Armenia's
    southern neighbor and a longtime ally, with an eye to participation
    in infrastructure and non-military nuclear projects, Hovhannisian
    added. Armenian Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian told reporters after
    Chirac left that the French president "was very interested to learn"
    President Kocharian's opinion about Iran's nuclear capabilities.

    Richard Giragossian, a Washington-based political scientist, however,
    argued during a public lecture in Yerevan on October 5 that France's
    influential Armenian community rather than any geopolitical factors
    prompted the trip. This opinion was partly shared by the 168 Zham
    daily, which said that the visit had acted as "triple PR" -- for Chirac
    himself, for Kocharian, and for Armenia, which used the opportunity
    to tout the country as a foreign investment destination.

    The trip included a concert for 100,000 in downtown Yerevan by French
    crooner Charles Aznavour, the son of Armenian immigrants.

    NOTES: Haroutiun Khachatrian is a Yerevan-based writer specializing
    in economic and political affairs.

    From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Working...
X