Tweet
A CAUCASIAN PLATFORM
By Ismet Berkan
Turkish Press, MI
Aug 26 2008
RADIKAL- The impact of Russia `s recent attack on Georgia in the wake
of Georgia attacking South Ossetia is difficult to gauge. Turkey ,
one of two countries accused openly by Russia during the first days
of the conflict, wants to promote peace through active diplomacy. Of
course, Russia first halted its military operations and then stated
that it would withdraw to the border of Ossetia and Abkhazia (but it
still hasn`t withdrawn) without any intervention by the international
community. That`s why Turkey didn`t play a role in this.
Early in the conflict, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan reportedly
telephoned his Russian counterpart Dimitry Medvedev or Prime Minister
Vladimir Putin, but reports said they wouldn`t take his call. Erdogan
denied he had telephoned them, but he didn`t hide his wish to help end
the crisis, and then proposed a new Caucasus security and stability
platform. Erdogan later went to Moscow and spoke to Medvedev and
Putin. It seems they didn`t reject this proposal and even said it
might be useful. The next day Erdogan went to Tbilisi , where his
proposal was also welcomed.
Erdogan yesterday went to Azerbaijan to further promote the proposal,
and it seems he`ll do the same with Armenia . So what is this
platform? How seriously should we take it? First, the platform would
be a basis for bringing together five Caucasian countries - Russia ,
Turkey , Georgia , Azerbaijan and Armenia . The aim is to get them to
talk to each other. But you know that the Russians said they wouldn`t
speak to Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili anymore. Armenia is
still occupying 20% of Azerbaijani territory. And even if the two
countries sometimes speak to each other, they`ve been unable to reach
an agreement, perhaps because Russia doesn`t want one.
Turkey has no diplomatic relations with Armenia , but it recognizes
this country and sometimes talks with it, but there are serious
problems between the two countries. So this Caucasus platform might
be useful, and even talking about it might help. What`s more, Turkey
could benefit from it as well. But expecting success beyond this level
is for now just a pipe dream. As I said, it would be a success just to
get these five countries to sit down to a table and have dinner. If
they could do this, it would be very good. But unfortunately I don`t
expect even that much. I wouldn`t expect Russia to speak to anybody
about the places it considers its sphere of influence, particularly the
Caucasus and Central Asia . And if it speaks, I wouldn`t expect it to
say anything meaningful. If Russia decides to recognize the breakaway
Georgian regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia as independent,
things will get more complicated, and Russia will certainly reject
any solution to the Caucasus issue besides its own. We should keep
a close watch on the region and assess it carefully."
By Ismet Berkan
Turkish Press, MI
Aug 26 2008
RADIKAL- The impact of Russia `s recent attack on Georgia in the wake
of Georgia attacking South Ossetia is difficult to gauge. Turkey ,
one of two countries accused openly by Russia during the first days
of the conflict, wants to promote peace through active diplomacy. Of
course, Russia first halted its military operations and then stated
that it would withdraw to the border of Ossetia and Abkhazia (but it
still hasn`t withdrawn) without any intervention by the international
community. That`s why Turkey didn`t play a role in this.
Early in the conflict, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan reportedly
telephoned his Russian counterpart Dimitry Medvedev or Prime Minister
Vladimir Putin, but reports said they wouldn`t take his call. Erdogan
denied he had telephoned them, but he didn`t hide his wish to help end
the crisis, and then proposed a new Caucasus security and stability
platform. Erdogan later went to Moscow and spoke to Medvedev and
Putin. It seems they didn`t reject this proposal and even said it
might be useful. The next day Erdogan went to Tbilisi , where his
proposal was also welcomed.
Erdogan yesterday went to Azerbaijan to further promote the proposal,
and it seems he`ll do the same with Armenia . So what is this
platform? How seriously should we take it? First, the platform would
be a basis for bringing together five Caucasian countries - Russia ,
Turkey , Georgia , Azerbaijan and Armenia . The aim is to get them to
talk to each other. But you know that the Russians said they wouldn`t
speak to Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili anymore. Armenia is
still occupying 20% of Azerbaijani territory. And even if the two
countries sometimes speak to each other, they`ve been unable to reach
an agreement, perhaps because Russia doesn`t want one.
Turkey has no diplomatic relations with Armenia , but it recognizes
this country and sometimes talks with it, but there are serious
problems between the two countries. So this Caucasus platform might
be useful, and even talking about it might help. What`s more, Turkey
could benefit from it as well. But expecting success beyond this level
is for now just a pipe dream. As I said, it would be a success just to
get these five countries to sit down to a table and have dinner. If
they could do this, it would be very good. But unfortunately I don`t
expect even that much. I wouldn`t expect Russia to speak to anybody
about the places it considers its sphere of influence, particularly the
Caucasus and Central Asia . And if it speaks, I wouldn`t expect it to
say anything meaningful. If Russia decides to recognize the breakaway
Georgian regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia as independent,
things will get more complicated, and Russia will certainly reject
any solution to the Caucasus issue besides its own. We should keep
a close watch on the region and assess it carefully."