Tweet
The Moscow Times, Russia
Feb 18 2008
Karabakh Ponders Kosovo's Independence
By Karine Ohanyan
Special to The Moscow Times
Kosovar Albanians waving Albanian flags in the center of Kosovo's
capital, Pristina, on Sunday after the enclave declared its
independence from Serbia.
STEPANAKERT, Nagorno-Karabakh -- "What is Kosovo, and what do you eat
it with?" quipped Yuan Go, a Chinese cook living in Nagorno-Karabakh.
Yuan, who speaks the Karabakh dialect of the Armenian language
fluently and goes by the Armenian name of Gurgen, moved to this de
facto independent republic more than a year ago. He and two other
Chinese cooks work at a hotel restaurant.
Yuan, 25, cracked the joke when asked what Kosovo's declaration of
independence Sunday meant for Nagorno-Karabakh.
He and many other residents seem to have little idea what to expect,
but they are hoping that life stays calm in the enclave, which
Azerbaijan insists is part of its territory even though its Armenian
majority declared independence more than 16 years ago.
Unlike Kosovo, the self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic enjoys
no strong support from the European Union or the United States in its
bid for independence. But Karabakh Armenians, who, with the support
of Armenia, won a bloody war against the Azeris in the 1990s, are
seeing parallels with Kosovo and the long struggle of its Albanian
majority. For Karabakh's leaders, international recognition of
Kosovo's independence would set an important precedent.
"We are confident that the recognition of Kosovo by the international
community or by individual countries will strengthen our position in
negotiations to resolve the conflict with Azerbaijan," Georgy
Petrosyan, the foreign minister of the unrecognized republic, said in
an interview.
Azerbaijan has offered Nagorno-Karabakh broad autonomy within the
country during ongoing talks mediated by the Organization for
Cooperation and Security in Europe. But Nagorno-Karabakh's population
has insisted on independence. The enclave has a population of
137,737, 99.7 percent of whom are Armenian, according to the most
recent census, taken in 2005.
"It is important that Kosovo might become an example of a country's
independence being recognized against the will" of the country from
which it is seceding, Petrosyan said.
He said he believed that the solution for Kosovo in its conflict with
Serbia should also work for Karabakh in its conflict with Azerbaijan.
"A denial of this thesis would amount to a denial of the nature of
the precedent and its role in contemporary international relations,"
he said.
Ashot Gulyan, speaker of Karabakh's parliament, agreed. "The
situation around Kosovo cannot be perceived as a one-off case," he
added.
Karine Ohanyan / For MT
People walking down a street in Stepanakert, the main city in the
self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic.
The leaders do not seem discouraged by the fact that Russia,
Armenia's closest ally, has avoided mentioning Karabakh when listing
other self-styled republics in the former Soviet Union that might be
affected by Kosovo's independence bid. During his annual news
conference last week, President Vladimir Putin once again accused the
West of adopting double standards in insisting that Kosovo's case was
unique. He listed Georgia's republics of South Ossetia and Abkhazia
and Moldova's Transdnestr as territories that might seek to follow
Kosovo's lead. Putin, who has been trying to forge closer ties with
oil-rich Azerbaijan, did not name Karabakh.
Petrosyan said the omission might be an indication that Russia, which
is participating in the OSCE negotiations, "is avoiding statements
that would put its impartiality as a mediator in doubt." Russia,
however, has also been involved in similar talks between Georgia and
South Ossetia and Abkhazia.
The Karabakh war erupted after the parliaments of Armenia and
Nagorno-Karabakh held a joint session on Dec. 1, 1989, to declare the
unification of their territories. Azeri deputies from the
Nagorno-Karabakh parliament did not participate in the vote.
The first clashes along the Armenian-Azeri border broke out the next
year, and full-scale fighting started in 1991.
On Dec. 10, 1991, Nagorno-Karabakh's Armenian majority overwhelmingly
backed a referendum in support of independence for their homeland.
The enclave's newly elected parliament established the independent
Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh on Jan. 6, 1992.
The war ended in 1994, with Armenian forces driving Azeris out of the
enclave and seizing control of several neighboring Azeri districts,
forcing their population to flee. Armenian forces still control these
districts, while Azeris control the northern tip of Nagorno-Karabakh,
from which the Armenian population has fled. A conflict-resolution
proposal suggested by OSCE mediators calls for Karabakh to return the
districts to Azerbaijan in exchange for the right to hold a new
referendum on the enclave's status.
Many Karabakh residents do not appear hopeful that international
recognition of Kosovo's independence might mean a change for their
homeland.
"Such issues are resolved the way that world powers want them
resolved, even though our cause for independence is more just than
Kosovo's," said Juleyetta Arustamyan, a 44-year-old singer who lives
in the enclave's main city, Stepanakert.
Nune Khachatryan, the 35-year-old owner of a fashion store in
Stepanakert, said she is happy for Kosovo's Albanians but not
interested in politics. "Honestly speaking, I don't care whether
others recognize us or not," she said. "With or without recognition,
we will continue to live happily on our own land."
Feb 18 2008
Karabakh Ponders Kosovo's Independence
By Karine Ohanyan
Special to The Moscow Times
Kosovar Albanians waving Albanian flags in the center of Kosovo's
capital, Pristina, on Sunday after the enclave declared its
independence from Serbia.
STEPANAKERT, Nagorno-Karabakh -- "What is Kosovo, and what do you eat
it with?" quipped Yuan Go, a Chinese cook living in Nagorno-Karabakh.
Yuan, who speaks the Karabakh dialect of the Armenian language
fluently and goes by the Armenian name of Gurgen, moved to this de
facto independent republic more than a year ago. He and two other
Chinese cooks work at a hotel restaurant.
Yuan, 25, cracked the joke when asked what Kosovo's declaration of
independence Sunday meant for Nagorno-Karabakh.
He and many other residents seem to have little idea what to expect,
but they are hoping that life stays calm in the enclave, which
Azerbaijan insists is part of its territory even though its Armenian
majority declared independence more than 16 years ago.
Unlike Kosovo, the self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic enjoys
no strong support from the European Union or the United States in its
bid for independence. But Karabakh Armenians, who, with the support
of Armenia, won a bloody war against the Azeris in the 1990s, are
seeing parallels with Kosovo and the long struggle of its Albanian
majority. For Karabakh's leaders, international recognition of
Kosovo's independence would set an important precedent.
"We are confident that the recognition of Kosovo by the international
community or by individual countries will strengthen our position in
negotiations to resolve the conflict with Azerbaijan," Georgy
Petrosyan, the foreign minister of the unrecognized republic, said in
an interview.
Azerbaijan has offered Nagorno-Karabakh broad autonomy within the
country during ongoing talks mediated by the Organization for
Cooperation and Security in Europe. But Nagorno-Karabakh's population
has insisted on independence. The enclave has a population of
137,737, 99.7 percent of whom are Armenian, according to the most
recent census, taken in 2005.
"It is important that Kosovo might become an example of a country's
independence being recognized against the will" of the country from
which it is seceding, Petrosyan said.
He said he believed that the solution for Kosovo in its conflict with
Serbia should also work for Karabakh in its conflict with Azerbaijan.
"A denial of this thesis would amount to a denial of the nature of
the precedent and its role in contemporary international relations,"
he said.
Ashot Gulyan, speaker of Karabakh's parliament, agreed. "The
situation around Kosovo cannot be perceived as a one-off case," he
added.
Karine Ohanyan / For MT
People walking down a street in Stepanakert, the main city in the
self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic.
The leaders do not seem discouraged by the fact that Russia,
Armenia's closest ally, has avoided mentioning Karabakh when listing
other self-styled republics in the former Soviet Union that might be
affected by Kosovo's independence bid. During his annual news
conference last week, President Vladimir Putin once again accused the
West of adopting double standards in insisting that Kosovo's case was
unique. He listed Georgia's republics of South Ossetia and Abkhazia
and Moldova's Transdnestr as territories that might seek to follow
Kosovo's lead. Putin, who has been trying to forge closer ties with
oil-rich Azerbaijan, did not name Karabakh.
Petrosyan said the omission might be an indication that Russia, which
is participating in the OSCE negotiations, "is avoiding statements
that would put its impartiality as a mediator in doubt." Russia,
however, has also been involved in similar talks between Georgia and
South Ossetia and Abkhazia.
The Karabakh war erupted after the parliaments of Armenia and
Nagorno-Karabakh held a joint session on Dec. 1, 1989, to declare the
unification of their territories. Azeri deputies from the
Nagorno-Karabakh parliament did not participate in the vote.
The first clashes along the Armenian-Azeri border broke out the next
year, and full-scale fighting started in 1991.
On Dec. 10, 1991, Nagorno-Karabakh's Armenian majority overwhelmingly
backed a referendum in support of independence for their homeland.
The enclave's newly elected parliament established the independent
Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh on Jan. 6, 1992.
The war ended in 1994, with Armenian forces driving Azeris out of the
enclave and seizing control of several neighboring Azeri districts,
forcing their population to flee. Armenian forces still control these
districts, while Azeris control the northern tip of Nagorno-Karabakh,
from which the Armenian population has fled. A conflict-resolution
proposal suggested by OSCE mediators calls for Karabakh to return the
districts to Azerbaijan in exchange for the right to hold a new
referendum on the enclave's status.
Many Karabakh residents do not appear hopeful that international
recognition of Kosovo's independence might mean a change for their
homeland.
"Such issues are resolved the way that world powers want them
resolved, even though our cause for independence is more just than
Kosovo's," said Juleyetta Arustamyan, a 44-year-old singer who lives
in the enclave's main city, Stepanakert.
Nune Khachatryan, the 35-year-old owner of a fashion store in
Stepanakert, said she is happy for Kosovo's Albanians but not
interested in politics. "Honestly speaking, I don't care whether
others recognize us or not," she said. "With or without recognition,
we will continue to live happily on our own land."