Tweet
Institute for War and Peace Reporting, UK
May 8 2008
Armenia: Opposition Sets Talks Terms
Two months after Yerevan bloodshed, Armenian opposition lays out
conditions for dialogue.
By Gayane Abrahamian in Yerevan (CRS No. 443 07-May-08)
Former president Levon Ter-Petrosian was met by hundreds of his
supporters with applause and shouts of `Levon ` president', outside
the government building where the Armenian opposition held a congress
on May 2.
Some made the comparison with Ter-Petrosian's return to Yerevan after
six months in prison in Moscow in 1989, following his arrest as a
nationalist dissident leader.
The meeting was a chance for Ter-Petrosian, who has been restricted
from appearing in public since the March 1 violence in Yerevan, in
which ten people died, to address his supporters and set out his
strategy.
The congress, which unites 23 parties under the name Movement
Heralding National Awakening, opened with a minute's silence for those
who died on March 1.
Ter-Petrosian called the events of that day a `massacre' and accused
the former president Robert Kocharian of responsibility. He went on to
say that the incoming president Serzh Sarkisian ` whose legitimacy the
opposition disputes ` should have stopped the killings, but his level
of culpability will depend on whether he sanctions an unbiased
investigation into the March 1 bloodshed.
`There is no more convenient and useful way to prove his innocence
than to agree to holding an international independent investigation,'
said Ter-Petrosian
The former president proposed that a new `Armenian National Congress'
should be formed, which would develop into a party that could play a
`decisive role' in Armenian politics and put forward candidates in
elections.
`It is quite possible that in the future this `congress' will turn
into a centrist party with a strong structure,' he said.
Some analysts are sceptical, however, about how feasible it is for the
opposition to unite.
`It looks as though he is just playing for time and this is just a
step to keep his supporters in the game,' said political analyst
Eduard Antinian. `I am sure that at least two key parties of the 20
that are forming the movement ` the Heritage and Social Democratic
parties ` will definitely not become centrist.'
Vardan Khachatrian, a Heritage member of parliament, the only
opposition party represented there, was cautious about the idea of a
united party.
`Further events will make things clear,' said Khachatrian. `At the
moment, we are standing alongside the national movement but we simply
see no need in a merger. Today it's more important for us to be in
dialogue on equal terms.'
The key question currently in Armenia is whether a dialogue is
possible between the opposition, led by Ter-Petrosian and the new
administration of Serzh Sarkisian, and on what terms.
`If no dialogue between the authorities and the opposition takes place
in the next six months, then the parliamentary opposition will
collapse,' said former presidential candidate Arman Melikian.
Ter-Petrosian said that he does not recognise the `legitimacy of the
administration that has seized power' but agrees that they should be
engaged.
His main demand is that the government carries out a resolution
adopted by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, on
April 17, which calls for an immediate `independent, transparent and
credible inquiry into the events of 1 March and the circumstances that
led to them, including the alleged excessive use of force by the
police and violence by the protesters'.
It also demanded that people in custody on `seemingly artificial and
politically motivated charges' should be released and amendments to
legislation restricting public meetings should be revoked.
The resolution warns that if these changes are not carried out, `the
credibility of Armenia as a member of the Council of Europe is put
into doubt' and the Armenian delegation risks losing its voting rights
in the parliamentary assembly.
The authorities called the resolution `tough' and Tigran Torosian,
speaker of the Armenian parliament, said it `does not fully correspond
to the picture of the events' that took place.
US-born former foreign minister Raffi Hovhannissian, leader of
Heritage, has called for a dialogue between government and opposition
on the basis of the resolution.
`The country is in a state of crisis and I see the way out from it as
being real, radical and genuine reforms, which are possible through
dialogue,' said Hovhannissian.
In the meantime, a commission was formed in parliament to study the
Council of Europe resolution, of which Hovhannissian is not a member.
`This is one more step designed to isolate the opposition,' said
Heritage member Anahit Bakhshian. She said that Hovhannissian is
currently out of the country and that the commission will not accept
other members of his party.
`The commission includes people who have damaged and compromised our
country by their actions and incorrect decisions,' complained
Bakhshian, naming Grigor Amalian and Aleksan Harutiunian, two
unpopular figures at the head of state television. `Entrusting the
demands of the resolution to this commission is like entrusting wolves
with lambs.'
Some analysts say that dialogue may be impossible, especially as,
according to the prosecutor's office, 58 opposition activists are
still in jail.
`This is a vicious circle as the authorities won't release the
prisoners so easily as many of them have criminal charges laid against
them and in that case the former president will not engage in
dialogue,' said political analyst Levon Shirinian.
Both sides are very suspicious of the other. Eduard Sharmazanov,
spokesman for the governing Republican Party, accused the opposition
of bad faith, saying, `The leaders of the opposition are presenting
ultimatums in stead of dialogue.'
Gayane Abrahamian is a reporter for Armenianow.com in Yerevan
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
May 8 2008
Armenia: Opposition Sets Talks Terms
Two months after Yerevan bloodshed, Armenian opposition lays out
conditions for dialogue.
By Gayane Abrahamian in Yerevan (CRS No. 443 07-May-08)
Former president Levon Ter-Petrosian was met by hundreds of his
supporters with applause and shouts of `Levon ` president', outside
the government building where the Armenian opposition held a congress
on May 2.
Some made the comparison with Ter-Petrosian's return to Yerevan after
six months in prison in Moscow in 1989, following his arrest as a
nationalist dissident leader.
The meeting was a chance for Ter-Petrosian, who has been restricted
from appearing in public since the March 1 violence in Yerevan, in
which ten people died, to address his supporters and set out his
strategy.
The congress, which unites 23 parties under the name Movement
Heralding National Awakening, opened with a minute's silence for those
who died on March 1.
Ter-Petrosian called the events of that day a `massacre' and accused
the former president Robert Kocharian of responsibility. He went on to
say that the incoming president Serzh Sarkisian ` whose legitimacy the
opposition disputes ` should have stopped the killings, but his level
of culpability will depend on whether he sanctions an unbiased
investigation into the March 1 bloodshed.
`There is no more convenient and useful way to prove his innocence
than to agree to holding an international independent investigation,'
said Ter-Petrosian
The former president proposed that a new `Armenian National Congress'
should be formed, which would develop into a party that could play a
`decisive role' in Armenian politics and put forward candidates in
elections.
`It is quite possible that in the future this `congress' will turn
into a centrist party with a strong structure,' he said.
Some analysts are sceptical, however, about how feasible it is for the
opposition to unite.
`It looks as though he is just playing for time and this is just a
step to keep his supporters in the game,' said political analyst
Eduard Antinian. `I am sure that at least two key parties of the 20
that are forming the movement ` the Heritage and Social Democratic
parties ` will definitely not become centrist.'
Vardan Khachatrian, a Heritage member of parliament, the only
opposition party represented there, was cautious about the idea of a
united party.
`Further events will make things clear,' said Khachatrian. `At the
moment, we are standing alongside the national movement but we simply
see no need in a merger. Today it's more important for us to be in
dialogue on equal terms.'
The key question currently in Armenia is whether a dialogue is
possible between the opposition, led by Ter-Petrosian and the new
administration of Serzh Sarkisian, and on what terms.
`If no dialogue between the authorities and the opposition takes place
in the next six months, then the parliamentary opposition will
collapse,' said former presidential candidate Arman Melikian.
Ter-Petrosian said that he does not recognise the `legitimacy of the
administration that has seized power' but agrees that they should be
engaged.
His main demand is that the government carries out a resolution
adopted by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, on
April 17, which calls for an immediate `independent, transparent and
credible inquiry into the events of 1 March and the circumstances that
led to them, including the alleged excessive use of force by the
police and violence by the protesters'.
It also demanded that people in custody on `seemingly artificial and
politically motivated charges' should be released and amendments to
legislation restricting public meetings should be revoked.
The resolution warns that if these changes are not carried out, `the
credibility of Armenia as a member of the Council of Europe is put
into doubt' and the Armenian delegation risks losing its voting rights
in the parliamentary assembly.
The authorities called the resolution `tough' and Tigran Torosian,
speaker of the Armenian parliament, said it `does not fully correspond
to the picture of the events' that took place.
US-born former foreign minister Raffi Hovhannissian, leader of
Heritage, has called for a dialogue between government and opposition
on the basis of the resolution.
`The country is in a state of crisis and I see the way out from it as
being real, radical and genuine reforms, which are possible through
dialogue,' said Hovhannissian.
In the meantime, a commission was formed in parliament to study the
Council of Europe resolution, of which Hovhannissian is not a member.
`This is one more step designed to isolate the opposition,' said
Heritage member Anahit Bakhshian. She said that Hovhannissian is
currently out of the country and that the commission will not accept
other members of his party.
`The commission includes people who have damaged and compromised our
country by their actions and incorrect decisions,' complained
Bakhshian, naming Grigor Amalian and Aleksan Harutiunian, two
unpopular figures at the head of state television. `Entrusting the
demands of the resolution to this commission is like entrusting wolves
with lambs.'
Some analysts say that dialogue may be impossible, especially as,
according to the prosecutor's office, 58 opposition activists are
still in jail.
`This is a vicious circle as the authorities won't release the
prisoners so easily as many of them have criminal charges laid against
them and in that case the former president will not engage in
dialogue,' said political analyst Levon Shirinian.
Both sides are very suspicious of the other. Eduard Sharmazanov,
spokesman for the governing Republican Party, accused the opposition
of bad faith, saying, `The leaders of the opposition are presenting
ultimatums in stead of dialogue.'
Gayane Abrahamian is a reporter for Armenianow.com in Yerevan
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress