Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Mystery Of The Heroic Battles Of 1918

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Mystery Of The Heroic Battles Of 1918

    THE MYSTERY OF THE HEROIC BATTLES OF 1918
    Gevorg Khoudinyan Doctor Of History

    Hayots Ashkhar Daily
    Published on May 20, 2008
    Armenia

    1. 1918-1928: The Contemporary Nature of Historical Parallels

    Whether consciously or automatically, we confess at moments of
    self-flagellation that we, Armenians, are a nation with a "rich
    experience" of suffering the collapse of empires.

    First, during the 1917 Russian Revolution and then, in the period of
    signing the Belovest Agreement, a document declaring the collapse of
    the Soviet Union, we were left alone, face-to-face with the external
    enemy, and despite the bitterness for the defeats and the enthusiasm
    for the victories, we had, after all, to learn certain lessons from
    history.

    Let's bear in mind that at the end of 1917 and during the first
    months of 1918 we were unable to defend Western Armenia due to our
    disorganization and lack of courage because, after the withdrawal of
    the Russian Army, we had an unlimited storage of arms and ammunition
    together with the invincible castles of Kars and Erzrum.

    And only at the very end, when the worst had come to the worst and the
    danger of losing Western Armenia was real, did we manage to impede the
    enemy's progress in the unexampled battles of Sardarapat, Bash-Aparan
    and Gharakilisa, as the enemy had to put up, at least temporarily,
    with the existence of the First Republic of Armenia proclaimed on
    May 28, 1918.

    In 1991, the empire collapsed again, and the Soviet-Russian Army again
    withdrew our region; instead of the liberation of western Armenia,
    we were facing the Karabakh problem which we had inherited from the
    First Republic era.

    This time, however, we had managed to learn something from history,
    at least a little. Left alone, we were neither dispirited nor weakened;
    we realized that in order to live it was necessary to win, forgetting
    about the advantages of the rival and the mercy of the world which was
    indifferent. We should confess, however, that in 1991 the collapse
    of the empire was slower and more controllable, and this enabled us
    to simultaneously solve the problem of establishing an independent
    state and confronting the external enemy. And we were no longer scared
    people who had just survived the massacres, but rather, a nation that
    perceived the recollections of the Genocide as an instructive lesson.

    Ninety years after the 1918 heroic battles and the formation of the
    First Republic of Armenia and 20 years after the start of the Karabakh
    Movement - one of the incentives for the collapse of the Soviet Union,
    we all are, some way or another, tormented by the following question:
    whether all that happened 90 or 20 years ago is just history with its
    raw and sometimes unattractive facts and figures, and whether the world
    has changed so much that we can feel secure even in the environment
    which surrounded us in the past and still surrounds at present?

    Or, perhaps, the instinct of self-preservation has weakened,
    giving way to the hedonistic psychology of temporary pleasures
    and enjoyments? After all, we, as a nation and state, have not yet
    become powerful enough to allow for temporary stupor while being
    in the neighborhood of a bellicose country like Azerbaijan, with a
    population of 8 million, and Turkey, with a population of 70 million.

    In case of viewing the 1918 heroic battles against such a vast
    background, we arrive at the conclusion that the bitter though
    heroic fate that fell to the lot of our past generations as a result
    of the collapse of empires was a direct expression of simple and
    repeated regularities rather than a repetition of historical facts
    and events. And the causes giving rise to such regularities were not
    only preserved in the course of the recent years, but also remind
    about their existence more and more at present.

    While the disaster that fell to the lot of Russia in October 1917 was
    one of the biggest mysteries of the world history, and the collapse
    of the USSR, one of the most powerful empires of the world - just an
    evidence of its repetition, the current developments taking place on
    the international arena are forewarnings of the possibility of the
    same processes on a new - global level. The conclusions are obvious:

    First: if there are no chances for the Karabakh issue to be settled
    purely on the bilateral level, i.e. through Armenian-Azerbaijani talks,

    Second: if it is beyond dispute that the post-Cold War fragile balance
    of the international forces cannot, during the coming years, ensure
    guarantees for the establishment of final peace in our region,

    Third: if the South Caucasus is now the world's leader in terms of its
    current armament race, then any serious collapse on the global level
    and radical change of the ratio of forces will result in resuming
    the military operations in our region.

    This time, we must ready not only for the collapse of a separate
    empire but rather, for the instability and collapse of the world
    economy and hence - the temporary collapse of the "disturbed"
    regions. And to resist all that, it is not enough to have economic or
    military-technical resources. What is no less important is to learn
    the lessons of history fixed in our memory - the moments of history
    when the ill fate left us alone with the enemy which surpassed us in
    terms of its potentials and resources.

    It is in this respect that the lessons of the 1918 heroic battles are
    instructive because in the course of millennia, the Armenians had never
    been so weak and tormented as they were after the 1915 Genocide. And
    neither the history of the Armenian people nor the history of the
    world have seen a nation that has just survived genocide find itself
    alone with yesterday's butcher thereafter.

    Therefore, in 1918 the Armenian nation proved to the whole world
    that it is even possible to win one's destiny. And in order to rule
    out the slightest possibility of repeating the past, the present-day
    generation of Armenians should thoroughly study the chronology of
    the 1918 battles - the most difficult and at the same time, the most
    heroic page of their own history.

    To be continued
Working...
X