Tweet
OPINION: U.S. COULD LEARN A THING OR TWO FROM TURKEY'S SOFT-POWER DIPLOMACY
By Trudy Rubin
San Jose Mercury News
October 16, 2008 Thursday
California
ANKARA, Turkey Americans who explore the wonders of Istanbul rarely
visit Turkey's capital, deep in the plains of Anatolia. Ankara
is known mainly for two things: a stunning museum that highlights
Turkey's ancient Anatolian past, and the vast hilltop mausoleum of
Ataturk, Turkey's founder, whose stern face is visible on huge banners
throughout the city.
But Ankara is becoming known for something else that's of great
strategic interest to Americans: an active foreign policy that may
help resolve conflicts in critical regions where the United States
has faltered. That includes the troubled Caucasus region, where Russia
just warred with Georgia, and the Middle East.
"If you list the key issues which Turkey and the United States pursue,
you'd be amazed by how many parallels there are," Turkey's president,
Abdullah Gul, Enhanced Coverage LinkingAbdullah Gul, -Search using:
Biographies Plus News News, Most Recent 60 Days told a small group
of visiting U.S. journalists and think-tank experts in an interview
in his office this week.
At the crossroads
Indeed, almost every foreign crisis on the U.S. agenda is also a
concern for Gul. Turkey sits at the crossroads of Asia and Europe,
bordering not only the European Union, but also Georgia, Iraq, Iran
and Syria. It has been adversely affected by growing Mideast chaos
since the Iraq war.
Turkey also sits at an energy crossroads. Efforts to build new oil
and gas pipelines from Central Asia and the Caucasus pipelines that
will circumvent Russia and make Europe less dependent on it all rely
on Turkey.
Instability in its environs has prompted Turkey to become more active
in conflict resolution. "In regional foreign policy, we had numerous
problems with our neighbors," Gul said. "They must be resolved,
or there cannot be peace."
Turkey's emphasis has been, for the most part, on soft power and
diplomacy. It is the only country with fair to good relations with
every country in neighboring regions: close ties to Israel as well
as to Arab states; good relations with Iran and carefully managed
relations with Russia; and close ties to Georgia.
Two of Turkey's many mediation efforts could have a positive impact on
key concerns of the United States. First is Turkey's recent overture
to Armenia. The two nations have deep disagreements over how 1 million
Armenians were killed in the early 20th century; Armenians call it
genocide, while Turkey insists it was the result of warfare.
In September, Gul became the first Turkish president in history to
visit Armenia. Gul had sent congratulations to Serge Sargsyan upon
his election as Armenia's president, and Gul in turn was invited
to attend a soccer match between the Turkish and Armenian teams in
Yerevan. Both leaders faced strong domestic opposition to the visit.
"Of course, I didn't just go to watch soccer," Gul said.
Conflict mediation
The goal is to work toward normalizing relations between Armenia and
Turkey and opening their border. Turkey also may be able to mediate
the poisonous split between Armenia and a third Caucasus country,
Azerbaijan.
Progress on resolving these conflicts could have a positive spillover
for the Russia-Georgia standoff and prospects for new pipelines.
A second example is Turkey's mediation of peace talks between Syria
and Israel. "We've worked hard to bring peace in the region," Gul
said. "Recently, that work became more visible."
At a time when the United States preferred to isolate Syria, Turkey
worked to get Syria and Israel back to the table. Four rounds of
private talks have taken place; they are now on hold as Israel forms
a new government.
A Syria-Israel peace would end the current alliance between Syria and
Iran and undercut Hezbollah, forcing Tehran to rethink its policies
in the region.
The bottom line: The next U.S. president should encourage Turkey's
mediation and take a cue from its soft-power efforts. Turkey's
diplomacy has opened up new possibilities for its U.S. ally.
Trudy Rubin is a columnist and member of the Philadelphia Inquirer"s
editorial board.
By Trudy Rubin
San Jose Mercury News
October 16, 2008 Thursday
California
ANKARA, Turkey Americans who explore the wonders of Istanbul rarely
visit Turkey's capital, deep in the plains of Anatolia. Ankara
is known mainly for two things: a stunning museum that highlights
Turkey's ancient Anatolian past, and the vast hilltop mausoleum of
Ataturk, Turkey's founder, whose stern face is visible on huge banners
throughout the city.
But Ankara is becoming known for something else that's of great
strategic interest to Americans: an active foreign policy that may
help resolve conflicts in critical regions where the United States
has faltered. That includes the troubled Caucasus region, where Russia
just warred with Georgia, and the Middle East.
"If you list the key issues which Turkey and the United States pursue,
you'd be amazed by how many parallels there are," Turkey's president,
Abdullah Gul, Enhanced Coverage LinkingAbdullah Gul, -Search using:
Biographies Plus News News, Most Recent 60 Days told a small group
of visiting U.S. journalists and think-tank experts in an interview
in his office this week.
At the crossroads
Indeed, almost every foreign crisis on the U.S. agenda is also a
concern for Gul. Turkey sits at the crossroads of Asia and Europe,
bordering not only the European Union, but also Georgia, Iraq, Iran
and Syria. It has been adversely affected by growing Mideast chaos
since the Iraq war.
Turkey also sits at an energy crossroads. Efforts to build new oil
and gas pipelines from Central Asia and the Caucasus pipelines that
will circumvent Russia and make Europe less dependent on it all rely
on Turkey.
Instability in its environs has prompted Turkey to become more active
in conflict resolution. "In regional foreign policy, we had numerous
problems with our neighbors," Gul said. "They must be resolved,
or there cannot be peace."
Turkey's emphasis has been, for the most part, on soft power and
diplomacy. It is the only country with fair to good relations with
every country in neighboring regions: close ties to Israel as well
as to Arab states; good relations with Iran and carefully managed
relations with Russia; and close ties to Georgia.
Two of Turkey's many mediation efforts could have a positive impact on
key concerns of the United States. First is Turkey's recent overture
to Armenia. The two nations have deep disagreements over how 1 million
Armenians were killed in the early 20th century; Armenians call it
genocide, while Turkey insists it was the result of warfare.
In September, Gul became the first Turkish president in history to
visit Armenia. Gul had sent congratulations to Serge Sargsyan upon
his election as Armenia's president, and Gul in turn was invited
to attend a soccer match between the Turkish and Armenian teams in
Yerevan. Both leaders faced strong domestic opposition to the visit.
"Of course, I didn't just go to watch soccer," Gul said.
Conflict mediation
The goal is to work toward normalizing relations between Armenia and
Turkey and opening their border. Turkey also may be able to mediate
the poisonous split between Armenia and a third Caucasus country,
Azerbaijan.
Progress on resolving these conflicts could have a positive spillover
for the Russia-Georgia standoff and prospects for new pipelines.
A second example is Turkey's mediation of peace talks between Syria
and Israel. "We've worked hard to bring peace in the region," Gul
said. "Recently, that work became more visible."
At a time when the United States preferred to isolate Syria, Turkey
worked to get Syria and Israel back to the table. Four rounds of
private talks have taken place; they are now on hold as Israel forms
a new government.
A Syria-Israel peace would end the current alliance between Syria and
Iran and undercut Hezbollah, forcing Tehran to rethink its policies
in the region.
The bottom line: The next U.S. president should encourage Turkey's
mediation and take a cue from its soft-power efforts. Turkey's
diplomacy has opened up new possibilities for its U.S. ally.
Trudy Rubin is a columnist and member of the Philadelphia Inquirer"s
editorial board.