Tweet
SUU STUDENTS MEET IRANIAN LEADERS IN BIG APPLE
Dennis Busch
SUU Journal Online
10/1/09
Members of the Iranian Parliament and delegation to the United
Nations meet in New York City where a group of SUU students traveled
to meet them.
This last week I had a unique opportunity with 11 other students
from SUU and the Michael O. Leavitt Center for Politics & Public
Service to travel to New York City to meet with Mahmoud Ahmadinejad,
the controversial figure and President of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
The week's events, which were organized with the Foundation for
Interreligious Diplomacy, allowed us to engage Iranian leaders on
a myriad of topics from foreign policy, nuclear development, human
rights violations and even the holocaust.
The meeting with Ahmadinejad on Sept. 23 was probably the most secure
event I have attended in my life, with so many Secret Service agents
you would have thought Lady Bird Johnson was coming.
Soon after we all got through security and inside The Barclay, the
street in front of this ornate hotel was filled with impassioned
protestors waving signs and chanting about their dissatisfaction with
Ahmadinejad's regime and with us for meeting with him.
While waiting in a reception room before being allowed to enter the
ballroom, we were presented with literature about the tourism industry
of Iran, the successes of Ahmadinejad and a ridiculous brochure about
the evils of Zionist states - a must-read for every anti-Semite.
As we were finally led into the ballroom, we were informed that
because delays at the U.N., we would have to wait even longer for
the president to take our questions.
Former Iranian Vice President, Parviz Davoodi, filled this long gap
by talking about the amazing things Iran and its people have done,
lacing his talk with all the flair and excitement of a Harry Reid
filibuster speech.
Whe nd the first question was about the mistreatment and imprisonment
of Afghan refugees.
Ahmadinejad replied that information was incorrect and that the UN
High Commissioner on refugees had commended Iran on their treatment
of refugees.
However, he then instructed the Iranian state television, the only
press covering the event, not to broadcast the answer to the question
stating that it would "make their Afghani brothers sad to hear."
The state press selectively did not record several of the president's
answers, including his anything-but-brief response on a question about
the Holocaust, and his questioning of some of the facts surrounding
the Jewish genocide.
One of the last questions asked to Ahmadinejad was what he would do
in response to President Barack Obama's assertions that as a neighbor
of Afghanistan, Iran should play a role in stabilizing the area.
The president claimed that since the NATO forces entered Afghanistan,
drug production has increased, and the area has become unstable. He
went on to assert that any country is wrong if they think that military
force will bring about stability.
In total, he answered about 20 questions and talked with us for almost
three hours.
In addition to UVU and Westminster College, the other schools
in attendance included Columbia, Rutgers, NYU and Yale, and not
surprising, Utah students held their own amongst the Ivy Leaguers.
On Friday, we had the additional opportunity to meet and ask
questions with four religious minority members of the Parliament
of Iran representing Assyrian Christians, Armenian Christians,
Zoroastrians and Jews.
Ciamak Moresadegh, the Jewish MP essentially said Ahmadinejad is wrong
about the Holocaust, and that it is a scientific fact that affected
all Jews of the world.
These religious minorities, which are recognized by the constitution,
also stressed that Baha', the largest non-Islamic faith in Iran,
is not a religion at all, and thus does not receive support nor
protection from the government.
While there were questions about nuclear cilities and foreign policy,
they were largely centered on religious freedom, and at one point,
a representative of the Iranian Ambassador to the United Nations said
in regards to the peaceful nature of Iran, "If Joseph Smith had been
amongst Muslims, he would have been safe."
Overall, the event appeared to be a political stunt, aimed at
making the president look like he was reaching out for diplomacy and
supporting his people.
Many reports prior to the event indicated that the religious minority
MPs were strongly urged to attend in an effort to make the Ahmadinejad
regime look better on issues of religious freedom.
Our meeting with human rights groups beforehand only further
underscored that the meeting would be a public relations stunt, and
that we should show our solidarity with the reformers in the country
as much as possible, including wearing green.
Regardless of what the implications are of our attendance, I am glad
we went. I personally learned so much. Even if I end up on some no fly
list, I think my first hand experience with diplomacy has been worth
it. And even more, SUU students were participating in an event that
made national news, and is the ultimate path to peace in the region -
interfaith and intercultural dialogue.
Dennis Busch is the Opinion editor of the University Journal and
member of the Michael O. Leavitt Institute for Public Policy.
Dennis Busch
SUU Journal Online
10/1/09
Members of the Iranian Parliament and delegation to the United
Nations meet in New York City where a group of SUU students traveled
to meet them.
This last week I had a unique opportunity with 11 other students
from SUU and the Michael O. Leavitt Center for Politics & Public
Service to travel to New York City to meet with Mahmoud Ahmadinejad,
the controversial figure and President of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
The week's events, which were organized with the Foundation for
Interreligious Diplomacy, allowed us to engage Iranian leaders on
a myriad of topics from foreign policy, nuclear development, human
rights violations and even the holocaust.
The meeting with Ahmadinejad on Sept. 23 was probably the most secure
event I have attended in my life, with so many Secret Service agents
you would have thought Lady Bird Johnson was coming.
Soon after we all got through security and inside The Barclay, the
street in front of this ornate hotel was filled with impassioned
protestors waving signs and chanting about their dissatisfaction with
Ahmadinejad's regime and with us for meeting with him.
While waiting in a reception room before being allowed to enter the
ballroom, we were presented with literature about the tourism industry
of Iran, the successes of Ahmadinejad and a ridiculous brochure about
the evils of Zionist states - a must-read for every anti-Semite.
As we were finally led into the ballroom, we were informed that
because delays at the U.N., we would have to wait even longer for
the president to take our questions.
Former Iranian Vice President, Parviz Davoodi, filled this long gap
by talking about the amazing things Iran and its people have done,
lacing his talk with all the flair and excitement of a Harry Reid
filibuster speech.
Whe nd the first question was about the mistreatment and imprisonment
of Afghan refugees.
Ahmadinejad replied that information was incorrect and that the UN
High Commissioner on refugees had commended Iran on their treatment
of refugees.
However, he then instructed the Iranian state television, the only
press covering the event, not to broadcast the answer to the question
stating that it would "make their Afghani brothers sad to hear."
The state press selectively did not record several of the president's
answers, including his anything-but-brief response on a question about
the Holocaust, and his questioning of some of the facts surrounding
the Jewish genocide.
One of the last questions asked to Ahmadinejad was what he would do
in response to President Barack Obama's assertions that as a neighbor
of Afghanistan, Iran should play a role in stabilizing the area.
The president claimed that since the NATO forces entered Afghanistan,
drug production has increased, and the area has become unstable. He
went on to assert that any country is wrong if they think that military
force will bring about stability.
In total, he answered about 20 questions and talked with us for almost
three hours.
In addition to UVU and Westminster College, the other schools
in attendance included Columbia, Rutgers, NYU and Yale, and not
surprising, Utah students held their own amongst the Ivy Leaguers.
On Friday, we had the additional opportunity to meet and ask
questions with four religious minority members of the Parliament
of Iran representing Assyrian Christians, Armenian Christians,
Zoroastrians and Jews.
Ciamak Moresadegh, the Jewish MP essentially said Ahmadinejad is wrong
about the Holocaust, and that it is a scientific fact that affected
all Jews of the world.
These religious minorities, which are recognized by the constitution,
also stressed that Baha', the largest non-Islamic faith in Iran,
is not a religion at all, and thus does not receive support nor
protection from the government.
While there were questions about nuclear cilities and foreign policy,
they were largely centered on religious freedom, and at one point,
a representative of the Iranian Ambassador to the United Nations said
in regards to the peaceful nature of Iran, "If Joseph Smith had been
amongst Muslims, he would have been safe."
Overall, the event appeared to be a political stunt, aimed at
making the president look like he was reaching out for diplomacy and
supporting his people.
Many reports prior to the event indicated that the religious minority
MPs were strongly urged to attend in an effort to make the Ahmadinejad
regime look better on issues of religious freedom.
Our meeting with human rights groups beforehand only further
underscored that the meeting would be a public relations stunt, and
that we should show our solidarity with the reformers in the country
as much as possible, including wearing green.
Regardless of what the implications are of our attendance, I am glad
we went. I personally learned so much. Even if I end up on some no fly
list, I think my first hand experience with diplomacy has been worth
it. And even more, SUU students were participating in an event that
made national news, and is the ultimate path to peace in the region -
interfaith and intercultural dialogue.
Dennis Busch is the Opinion editor of the University Journal and
member of the Michael O. Leavitt Institute for Public Policy.