Tweet
SAMVEL KARAPETYAN ANSWERS READER QUESTIONS
Sona Avagyan
http://hetq.am/en/society/samvel-karapety an-3/
2009/10/12 | 18:02
This year the RoA Prime Minister visited your office, an individual
who is at least cognizant of the issues you have raised regarding the
flawed renovation of monuments and the lack of attention paid to their
overall plight, etc. Did your meeting have any positive results? Did
you come to any understanding of what needs to be done? Can you call
him up when necessary and say that this needs to be done or that
certain changes need to be made?
I must confess that the Prime Minister's visit on January 30 was
a very much welcomed and encouraging sign for all of us. But many
months have since passed.
The Prime Minister promised to finance our activities and especially
the issue of where to house our operations. This issue of finding a
suitable space for the organization is a pressing one indeed. We have
been situated in our present location as of 2000. We took advantage of
the generous gift made by the late Levon Hakhverdyan, Director of the
Art Institute at the time, to take up residence in the Institute's
hall and two rooms. We will soon mark our tenth year here but the
Institute is sorely in need of the space we now occupy. Right now,
however, we have no other alternative.
Recently, I was a guest on Shant T.V. and took advantage of the
opportunity to present our plight to the public. I received many
phone calls soon afterwards. The principal of a school called and
offered us space in his school building.
Of course, I wish to thank all those who made such similar generous
offers of assistance. The fact remains that we have a very large
archive of materials and if we were to relocate it would have to be
to a permanent site. Otherwise it wouldn't make sense to move the
entire archive to some school room for just a few months.
It would just take a month to sort everything out again and get the
system and computers back up and running properly.
We pointed this out to the PM when he visited. A reporter asked the
PM whether the government would also take care of providing is with
a new, permanent space. He replied that, "We will take care of all
the organization's problems."
Sadly, months have passed since those pledges were made. This year
was the first since 2004 that we weren't able to travel to western
Armenia. It wasn't merely due to a lack of funds that we couldn't go,
but because we faced big problems with maintain the archival library.
I should note that Minister of Culture Hasmik Poghosyan visited us just
two weeks after the PM on his directive. I laid out the situation we
faced in detail and the minister seemed impressed with the work we
were doing.
By the end of March, I was forced to follow-up these visits with
phone calls and letters since I hadn't heard back from any government
agencies. This inaction was puzzling since at the time the Prime
Minister had made several T.V. appearances during which he praised
the importance of the work our organization was carrying out. I even
remember his exact words which were, "I am amazed and moved by the
work conducted by these sons and daughter of our nation." Important
praise indeed coming from the PM.
To my surprise, when I wrote to the PM, I received a response from
his chief of staff the same day saying that they were working on the
matter. Later that week, the same official phoned and told me that
our letter had been passed on to the Ministry of Finance by the PM
himself. Subsequently, I received a call from the Minister of Culture
who told me that they had just received a notice from the Ministry
of Finance stating that there were no more reserve funds available
for projects not included in the budget.
All I can say in response is that we knew that the economy would
take an 18% dip this year. But we are talking about a mere trickle of
funds to keep this organization on its feet. It is my firm belief that
the problem, at least in our case, wasn't economic. In other words,
the crisis we face is one of national consciousness, not economic.
I can't come to terms with all this. How long can we expect to ensure
our existence, given the national challenges we face and surrounded
by super-nationalist states as we are, by our present passive and
denationalized policies? This is what I don't understand. Is it that
our authorities cannot comprehend this basic issue?
I asked one very pointed question to the Minister of Culture when she
visited us - "Assume for a moment that I am your Turkish counterpart,
the Minister of Culture, and I ask you what proofs do you have when
you speak about western Armenia or that a genocide of Armenian culture
took place. How can you talk of such things when we have renovated
Aghtamar and plan to so the same with Ani?" What would be the response
of Armenia's Minister of Culture to all this?
In other words, shouldn't we have details of the present condition of
each and every Armenian monument that still stands? Shouldn't we have
photographic proof to compare the present with what was captured on
camera, even it is was one photo taken back at the beginning of the
20th century or the end of the 19th century? Shouldn't we have all
this information at our fingertips? The Minister replied that "Of
course you are doing important work that is vital to our nation". It
seems we've never been at a loss for words to praise such work but
taking concrete action is another matter.
To be continued
Sona Avagyan
http://hetq.am/en/society/samvel-karapety an-3/
2009/10/12 | 18:02
This year the RoA Prime Minister visited your office, an individual
who is at least cognizant of the issues you have raised regarding the
flawed renovation of monuments and the lack of attention paid to their
overall plight, etc. Did your meeting have any positive results? Did
you come to any understanding of what needs to be done? Can you call
him up when necessary and say that this needs to be done or that
certain changes need to be made?
I must confess that the Prime Minister's visit on January 30 was
a very much welcomed and encouraging sign for all of us. But many
months have since passed.
The Prime Minister promised to finance our activities and especially
the issue of where to house our operations. This issue of finding a
suitable space for the organization is a pressing one indeed. We have
been situated in our present location as of 2000. We took advantage of
the generous gift made by the late Levon Hakhverdyan, Director of the
Art Institute at the time, to take up residence in the Institute's
hall and two rooms. We will soon mark our tenth year here but the
Institute is sorely in need of the space we now occupy. Right now,
however, we have no other alternative.
Recently, I was a guest on Shant T.V. and took advantage of the
opportunity to present our plight to the public. I received many
phone calls soon afterwards. The principal of a school called and
offered us space in his school building.
Of course, I wish to thank all those who made such similar generous
offers of assistance. The fact remains that we have a very large
archive of materials and if we were to relocate it would have to be
to a permanent site. Otherwise it wouldn't make sense to move the
entire archive to some school room for just a few months.
It would just take a month to sort everything out again and get the
system and computers back up and running properly.
We pointed this out to the PM when he visited. A reporter asked the
PM whether the government would also take care of providing is with
a new, permanent space. He replied that, "We will take care of all
the organization's problems."
Sadly, months have passed since those pledges were made. This year
was the first since 2004 that we weren't able to travel to western
Armenia. It wasn't merely due to a lack of funds that we couldn't go,
but because we faced big problems with maintain the archival library.
I should note that Minister of Culture Hasmik Poghosyan visited us just
two weeks after the PM on his directive. I laid out the situation we
faced in detail and the minister seemed impressed with the work we
were doing.
By the end of March, I was forced to follow-up these visits with
phone calls and letters since I hadn't heard back from any government
agencies. This inaction was puzzling since at the time the Prime
Minister had made several T.V. appearances during which he praised
the importance of the work our organization was carrying out. I even
remember his exact words which were, "I am amazed and moved by the
work conducted by these sons and daughter of our nation." Important
praise indeed coming from the PM.
To my surprise, when I wrote to the PM, I received a response from
his chief of staff the same day saying that they were working on the
matter. Later that week, the same official phoned and told me that
our letter had been passed on to the Ministry of Finance by the PM
himself. Subsequently, I received a call from the Minister of Culture
who told me that they had just received a notice from the Ministry
of Finance stating that there were no more reserve funds available
for projects not included in the budget.
All I can say in response is that we knew that the economy would
take an 18% dip this year. But we are talking about a mere trickle of
funds to keep this organization on its feet. It is my firm belief that
the problem, at least in our case, wasn't economic. In other words,
the crisis we face is one of national consciousness, not economic.
I can't come to terms with all this. How long can we expect to ensure
our existence, given the national challenges we face and surrounded
by super-nationalist states as we are, by our present passive and
denationalized policies? This is what I don't understand. Is it that
our authorities cannot comprehend this basic issue?
I asked one very pointed question to the Minister of Culture when she
visited us - "Assume for a moment that I am your Turkish counterpart,
the Minister of Culture, and I ask you what proofs do you have when
you speak about western Armenia or that a genocide of Armenian culture
took place. How can you talk of such things when we have renovated
Aghtamar and plan to so the same with Ani?" What would be the response
of Armenia's Minister of Culture to all this?
In other words, shouldn't we have details of the present condition of
each and every Armenian monument that still stands? Shouldn't we have
photographic proof to compare the present with what was captured on
camera, even it is was one photo taken back at the beginning of the
20th century or the end of the 19th century? Shouldn't we have all
this information at our fingertips? The Minister replied that "Of
course you are doing important work that is vital to our nation". It
seems we've never been at a loss for words to praise such work but
taking concrete action is another matter.
To be continued