Tweet
ARMENIA: YEREVAN IN UPROAR OVER PROTOCOL SIGNING DATE WITH TURKEY
Marianna Grigoryan
http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/i nsightb/articles/eav092809b.shtml
9/28/09
EURASIA INSIGHT
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's announcement that
Turkey and Armenia on October 10 will sign protocols on diplomatic
normalization ties is having an unsettling effect on domestic politics
in Yerevan. Some Armenian opposition politicians are complaining
that the signing-date announcement makes a mockery of a parliamentary
debate on the issue, scheduled to take place on October 1.
Prime Minister Erdogan's statement went no further than to set a
signing date for the protocols, according to media reports. Further
steps remain. Under the terms of the agreement, the signed
protocols would require ratification by the Turkish and Armenian
parliaments. Both sides have pledged to open their border, closed
since 1993, within two months of the protocols' ratification. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive].
The Armenian Foreign Ministry has not commented on Erdogan's
announcement. The spokesperson for Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan's
Republican Party of Armenia (RPA), however, stated that the decision
in no way diminishes the significance of the planned parliamentary
debate. [For details, see the Eurasia Insight archive.]
"The discussions go on, but they are not aimed at changing
the authorities' views; these are public hearings," said Eduard
Sharmazanov. "Authorities would never sign a document contradicting
our national interests, nor would they [normalize] relations with
pre-conditions," he said, referring to Turkish calls for Armenia to
withdraw troops from territories surrounding Nagorno-Karabakh. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive].
Back on September 1, Turkish and Armenian leaders announced that six
weeks of "political consultations" would take place before the signing
of the two protocols. [For details, see the Eurasia Insight archive.]
On September 17, President Sargsyan held a round-table discussion with
leading Armenian politicians. The president at that time pledged that
he would take personal responsibility for sorting out any lingering
causes of concern for Armenian politicians. "I am going to solve
issues," Sargsyan was quoted as saying. "If in order to solve a
certain issue, we have closed a certain door, please, show me."
The parliamentary debates were expected to broaden that
discussion. Even so, some important opposition groups, especially
former president Levon Ter-Petrosian's Armenian National Congress
(ANC), continue to shun government-sponsored discussions. The ANC
insists the government has already made up its mind.
ANC coordinator Levon Zurabian suggested that Sargsyan is not
interested in hearing the opinions of his political opponents. The
supposed political dialogue in Armenia is a sham, Zurabian contended,
held "in order to get support from the international community."
On October 1, President Sargsyan is scheduled to embark on a week-long
"listening tour" that will take him to Paris, New York, Los Angeles,
Beirut and Rostov-on-Don. In each city, he is scheduled to meet with
representatives of local Armenian communities and get their input on
the protocols.
One senior ANC member who supports the protocols calls the trip a
further sign that the government has not "moved a finger to make the
people a participant" in the reconciliation process with Turkey. "It's
very insulting when, instead of substantiating his policy within his
own society, Serzh Sargsyan is trying to do it abroad," said Suren
Surenyants, a board member for the Republic Party, a member of the ANC.
The RPA spokesperson, Sharmazanov, countered that the listening tour
demonstrated Sargsyan's desire to take all opinions into account. "This
step of the president shows that he is a supporter of unity, the
all-Armenian leader," argued Sharmazanov. "Armenians abroad have
serious concerns [about this issue]. He's going to explain and to
present everything soberly."
The director of the Yerevan office of one influential Diaspora
organization, the Armenian Assembly of America, agrees that Sargsyan's
trip is critical. "Diaspora Armenians feel that [Armenia] is their
motherland, and we have an important role to play here," Arpi
Vardanian said.
Now that Turkey and Armenia seem set to sign the reconciliation
protocols, at least one Armenian political party is vowing to
fight ratification. "We hope something can still be changed,"
commented Artashes Shahbazian, parliamentary faction secretary for the
nationalist Armenian Revolutionary Federation-Dashnaktsutiun. For the
past 13 days, the party has been staging protests throughout Yerevan,
as well as a hunger strike in front of government offices in Republic
Square. "We'll continue our fight and protests for the benefit of
our country," Shahbazian said.
Editor's Note: Marianna Grigoryan is a freelance reporter based
in Yerevan.
Marianna Grigoryan
http://www.eurasianet.org/departments/i nsightb/articles/eav092809b.shtml
9/28/09
EURASIA INSIGHT
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's announcement that
Turkey and Armenia on October 10 will sign protocols on diplomatic
normalization ties is having an unsettling effect on domestic politics
in Yerevan. Some Armenian opposition politicians are complaining
that the signing-date announcement makes a mockery of a parliamentary
debate on the issue, scheduled to take place on October 1.
Prime Minister Erdogan's statement went no further than to set a
signing date for the protocols, according to media reports. Further
steps remain. Under the terms of the agreement, the signed
protocols would require ratification by the Turkish and Armenian
parliaments. Both sides have pledged to open their border, closed
since 1993, within two months of the protocols' ratification. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive].
The Armenian Foreign Ministry has not commented on Erdogan's
announcement. The spokesperson for Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan's
Republican Party of Armenia (RPA), however, stated that the decision
in no way diminishes the significance of the planned parliamentary
debate. [For details, see the Eurasia Insight archive.]
"The discussions go on, but they are not aimed at changing
the authorities' views; these are public hearings," said Eduard
Sharmazanov. "Authorities would never sign a document contradicting
our national interests, nor would they [normalize] relations with
pre-conditions," he said, referring to Turkish calls for Armenia to
withdraw troops from territories surrounding Nagorno-Karabakh. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive].
Back on September 1, Turkish and Armenian leaders announced that six
weeks of "political consultations" would take place before the signing
of the two protocols. [For details, see the Eurasia Insight archive.]
On September 17, President Sargsyan held a round-table discussion with
leading Armenian politicians. The president at that time pledged that
he would take personal responsibility for sorting out any lingering
causes of concern for Armenian politicians. "I am going to solve
issues," Sargsyan was quoted as saying. "If in order to solve a
certain issue, we have closed a certain door, please, show me."
The parliamentary debates were expected to broaden that
discussion. Even so, some important opposition groups, especially
former president Levon Ter-Petrosian's Armenian National Congress
(ANC), continue to shun government-sponsored discussions. The ANC
insists the government has already made up its mind.
ANC coordinator Levon Zurabian suggested that Sargsyan is not
interested in hearing the opinions of his political opponents. The
supposed political dialogue in Armenia is a sham, Zurabian contended,
held "in order to get support from the international community."
On October 1, President Sargsyan is scheduled to embark on a week-long
"listening tour" that will take him to Paris, New York, Los Angeles,
Beirut and Rostov-on-Don. In each city, he is scheduled to meet with
representatives of local Armenian communities and get their input on
the protocols.
One senior ANC member who supports the protocols calls the trip a
further sign that the government has not "moved a finger to make the
people a participant" in the reconciliation process with Turkey. "It's
very insulting when, instead of substantiating his policy within his
own society, Serzh Sargsyan is trying to do it abroad," said Suren
Surenyants, a board member for the Republic Party, a member of the ANC.
The RPA spokesperson, Sharmazanov, countered that the listening tour
demonstrated Sargsyan's desire to take all opinions into account. "This
step of the president shows that he is a supporter of unity, the
all-Armenian leader," argued Sharmazanov. "Armenians abroad have
serious concerns [about this issue]. He's going to explain and to
present everything soberly."
The director of the Yerevan office of one influential Diaspora
organization, the Armenian Assembly of America, agrees that Sargsyan's
trip is critical. "Diaspora Armenians feel that [Armenia] is their
motherland, and we have an important role to play here," Arpi
Vardanian said.
Now that Turkey and Armenia seem set to sign the reconciliation
protocols, at least one Armenian political party is vowing to
fight ratification. "We hope something can still be changed,"
commented Artashes Shahbazian, parliamentary faction secretary for the
nationalist Armenian Revolutionary Federation-Dashnaktsutiun. For the
past 13 days, the party has been staging protests throughout Yerevan,
as well as a hunger strike in front of government offices in Republic
Square. "We'll continue our fight and protests for the benefit of
our country," Shahbazian said.
Editor's Note: Marianna Grigoryan is a freelance reporter based
in Yerevan.