Tweet
Hurriyet, Turkey
March 5 2010
US committee's vote on 'genocide' marks end of protocols, official says
Friday, March 5, 2010
SERKAN DEMÄ°RTAÅ?/Analysis
ANKARA ` Hürriyet Daily News
Turkey recalled its ambassador to the U.S., Namık Tan, after the panel vote.
The approval of the Armenia `genocide' resolution by a U.S. House
committee is perhaps not `the end of the world' but surely is the `end
of the historic protocols' signed between Turkey and Armenia,
according to a top official.
`No one should expect Turkish Parliament to proceed with the protocols
at least until April 24,' a senior foreign ministry official told a
limited group of journalists Friday. April 24 is the commemoration day
of the alleged killings of Armenians at the hands of the Ottoman
Empire in 1915. Many Armenians would like the U.S. president to use
the word `genocide' in the annual written statement to mark the date.
Turkey and Armenia signed two protocols last year to establish
diplomatic ties and open the border after decades of hostility between
the two neighboring countries. The protocols, however, are yet to be
ratified by either parliament. The resolution came at a moment when
Turkey and Armenia were engaged in a diplomatic process to resolve
problems that are blocking the ratifications.
`Turkey has internal dynamics, too. The Parliament cannot make any
step with regard to the protocols. There is a very important
reaction,' the official told journalists. However, the hurdles before
the reconciliation process are not limited to the House panel's
approval. The lack of any development in the peace talks between
Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed Nagorno-Karabahk problem
stands as an additional problem for Turkey, which promised its ally
Azerbaijan not to proceed with the protocols unless Yerevan withdraws
its troops from occupied Azeri lands.
For the Foreign Ministry official, `There was no positive development
on this issue to make Turkey hopeful of concluding the reconciliation
process with Armenia.' Turkey dispatched two of its top diplomats
Friday to Russia, a key country in solving the problem, to ensure
Moscow's full backing and provide further developments, the official
said. Feridun SinirlioÄ?lu, the undersecretary of the Foreign Ministry,
and Ã`nal Ã?eviköz, his deputy, departed for Moscow on Friday.
`In order not to be misunderstood we should put it straight: It was
Turkey who has fully endorsed this process with Armenia since 2005.
And we are still committed to it. However, there are so many
developments that have slowed down the pace of talks, including the
Armenian Constitutional Court's ruling on the protocols,' he said.
In January, the court approved the protocols' compatibility with
Armenia's constitution but said they should not violate the principle
set by the country's Declaration of Independence, which refers to
Turkey's eastern provinces as West Armenia and that the `genocide'
cannot be disputed.
`We are still seeking a written assurance from Armenia. Everyone is
focused only on the opening of the border. What would happen if they
would give up establishing the independent commission expected to be
tasked with investigating the 1915 incidents?' the diplomat asked.
Ankara expects official mediator Switzerland to step in and give
written assurance to this end.
The mood between the two neighbors has dramatically changed in the
last few months, making the completion of the protocols more
difficult.
Messages to Turkey
According to the Turkish Foreign Ministry, some circles in the U.S.
administration think the resolution can be used as leverage against
Ankara for swift ratification of the protocols. `We know who they are
and what they are planning. They should know such an attempt will
never be responded to by Turkey,' the diplomat noted.
`They perhaps wanted to give a message to Turkey to urge that, in the
case of the failure of the process, they are ready with their sticks
in hand.'
The same source also touched on the role of the Israeli lobby during
this process. `Our ambassador to Washington met with all prominent
representatives of the Israeli lobby. They promised to give support,
but when compared to the past, their support was minimal. Perhaps they
also wanted to give a message to Turkey to show the damage in ties
between Ankara and Tel Aviv,' added the diplomat.
Passage not likely
Though the House panel's move disturbed Ankara a lot, Turkish
diplomats are still hopeful the resolution will not be endorsed by the
full House of Representatives. `We are surly going to continue to
press administration on this issue. Furthermore, we will do our best
to stop the use of that word [genocide] by the U.S. President Barack
Obama [in his April 24 statement],' the diplomat noted.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip ErdoÄ?an is expected to go to the U.S. in
mid-April to attend an international summit on nuclear energy. He
could have a bilateral meeting with Obama, diplomats said, though
there was not a meeting set between the two leaders.
The only concern for Turkey is the decrease of Obama's influence over
the congressmen before November's elections. `We think he did not want
to spend all his bullets. He obviously saves them for issues he
considers more important for him,' the diplomat said.
No sanctions planned
Despite the great disturbance due to the approval of the resolution,
the diplomat emphasized that Turkey was not planning to apply
sanctions on the United States, such as canceling weapon deals or
other economic ties at this stage. `The withdrawal of our ambassador
is enough for the moment. If the resolution reaches the full House and
is endorsed there, of course we will evaluate the issue and our
bilateral ties once again,' the diplomat said.
`Turkish-American relations are interdependent. As they have
expectations from us, we also have expectations from them,' added the
diplomat.
Turkey and the United States cooperate on many important international
issues including the Middle East, Iran's nuclear row, Afghanistan and
pipeline diplomacy.
March 5 2010
US committee's vote on 'genocide' marks end of protocols, official says
Friday, March 5, 2010
SERKAN DEMÄ°RTAÅ?/Analysis
ANKARA ` Hürriyet Daily News
Turkey recalled its ambassador to the U.S., Namık Tan, after the panel vote.
The approval of the Armenia `genocide' resolution by a U.S. House
committee is perhaps not `the end of the world' but surely is the `end
of the historic protocols' signed between Turkey and Armenia,
according to a top official.
`No one should expect Turkish Parliament to proceed with the protocols
at least until April 24,' a senior foreign ministry official told a
limited group of journalists Friday. April 24 is the commemoration day
of the alleged killings of Armenians at the hands of the Ottoman
Empire in 1915. Many Armenians would like the U.S. president to use
the word `genocide' in the annual written statement to mark the date.
Turkey and Armenia signed two protocols last year to establish
diplomatic ties and open the border after decades of hostility between
the two neighboring countries. The protocols, however, are yet to be
ratified by either parliament. The resolution came at a moment when
Turkey and Armenia were engaged in a diplomatic process to resolve
problems that are blocking the ratifications.
`Turkey has internal dynamics, too. The Parliament cannot make any
step with regard to the protocols. There is a very important
reaction,' the official told journalists. However, the hurdles before
the reconciliation process are not limited to the House panel's
approval. The lack of any development in the peace talks between
Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed Nagorno-Karabahk problem
stands as an additional problem for Turkey, which promised its ally
Azerbaijan not to proceed with the protocols unless Yerevan withdraws
its troops from occupied Azeri lands.
For the Foreign Ministry official, `There was no positive development
on this issue to make Turkey hopeful of concluding the reconciliation
process with Armenia.' Turkey dispatched two of its top diplomats
Friday to Russia, a key country in solving the problem, to ensure
Moscow's full backing and provide further developments, the official
said. Feridun SinirlioÄ?lu, the undersecretary of the Foreign Ministry,
and Ã`nal Ã?eviköz, his deputy, departed for Moscow on Friday.
`In order not to be misunderstood we should put it straight: It was
Turkey who has fully endorsed this process with Armenia since 2005.
And we are still committed to it. However, there are so many
developments that have slowed down the pace of talks, including the
Armenian Constitutional Court's ruling on the protocols,' he said.
In January, the court approved the protocols' compatibility with
Armenia's constitution but said they should not violate the principle
set by the country's Declaration of Independence, which refers to
Turkey's eastern provinces as West Armenia and that the `genocide'
cannot be disputed.
`We are still seeking a written assurance from Armenia. Everyone is
focused only on the opening of the border. What would happen if they
would give up establishing the independent commission expected to be
tasked with investigating the 1915 incidents?' the diplomat asked.
Ankara expects official mediator Switzerland to step in and give
written assurance to this end.
The mood between the two neighbors has dramatically changed in the
last few months, making the completion of the protocols more
difficult.
Messages to Turkey
According to the Turkish Foreign Ministry, some circles in the U.S.
administration think the resolution can be used as leverage against
Ankara for swift ratification of the protocols. `We know who they are
and what they are planning. They should know such an attempt will
never be responded to by Turkey,' the diplomat noted.
`They perhaps wanted to give a message to Turkey to urge that, in the
case of the failure of the process, they are ready with their sticks
in hand.'
The same source also touched on the role of the Israeli lobby during
this process. `Our ambassador to Washington met with all prominent
representatives of the Israeli lobby. They promised to give support,
but when compared to the past, their support was minimal. Perhaps they
also wanted to give a message to Turkey to show the damage in ties
between Ankara and Tel Aviv,' added the diplomat.
Passage not likely
Though the House panel's move disturbed Ankara a lot, Turkish
diplomats are still hopeful the resolution will not be endorsed by the
full House of Representatives. `We are surly going to continue to
press administration on this issue. Furthermore, we will do our best
to stop the use of that word [genocide] by the U.S. President Barack
Obama [in his April 24 statement],' the diplomat noted.
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip ErdoÄ?an is expected to go to the U.S. in
mid-April to attend an international summit on nuclear energy. He
could have a bilateral meeting with Obama, diplomats said, though
there was not a meeting set between the two leaders.
The only concern for Turkey is the decrease of Obama's influence over
the congressmen before November's elections. `We think he did not want
to spend all his bullets. He obviously saves them for issues he
considers more important for him,' the diplomat said.
No sanctions planned
Despite the great disturbance due to the approval of the resolution,
the diplomat emphasized that Turkey was not planning to apply
sanctions on the United States, such as canceling weapon deals or
other economic ties at this stage. `The withdrawal of our ambassador
is enough for the moment. If the resolution reaches the full House and
is endorsed there, of course we will evaluate the issue and our
bilateral ties once again,' the diplomat said.
`Turkish-American relations are interdependent. As they have
expectations from us, we also have expectations from them,' added the
diplomat.
Turkey and the United States cooperate on many important international
issues including the Middle East, Iran's nuclear row, Afghanistan and
pipeline diplomacy.