Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Commentary: Just Who Is An Armenian?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Commentary: Just Who Is An Armenian?

    COMMENTARY: JUST WHO IS AN ARMENIAN?

    http://hetq.am/en/diaspora/armenian-3/#more-42286
    2010/11/01 | 11:59

    Feature Stories diaspora

    The old refrain, who qualifies to be called an Armenian, came crashing
    through in real life terms just a few days ago.

    At a football match here in Hamburg, Germany, some Armenian guys from
    Armenia called some Armenian guys from Istanbul "Turks" because
    they were speaking Turkish, not Armenian.

    Similar cultural clashes have happened in the past; it's not a
    new occurrence.

    Armenians from different regions had met up in Germany to play some
    "friendly" football matches. Things got out of hand and punches
    were thrown along with some choice invectives.

    A local Armenian yahoo forum in Germany has been besieged with
    comments; most accusatory in nature of one or another side. Each
    commentator believes he or she knows what the correct definition of
    an Armenian is.

    Let's put the question on the table - who exactly is an Armenian?

    Are the 18,000 Armenians now in Los Angeles jails Armenian? What about
    the recently arrested Armenian mafia types who scammed millions in a
    U.S. Medicare system fraud? What do you call the Armenians responsible
    for the death of young men serving in the Artsakh Army? Can Armenians
    who rip off their fellow Armenians or those who plunder the resources
    of Armenia, be called Armenian? What about the thousands who leave
    Armenia and those who force them to leave?

    Naturally, the simple answer is that they are all Armenians. That's
    to say, the way we approach the issue is incorrect. It appears
    that whether or not one feels a member of the Armenian nation is
    irrelevant. The litmus test is whether one speaks the language or not
    or, as many see it, whether one belongs to the Armenian Apostolic
    Church. These people don't even consider Armenian Evangelicals or
    Catholics "real" Armenians.

    Aren't some of these same Armenian-speaking, Armenian Apostolic
    Church members, in the short-sightedness, allowing for the
    gradual disappearance of the language in Armenia by permitting
    the establishment of foreign language schools? Are these Armenians
    actually "Turks" in disguise? Of course not; but they are Armenians
    of a different stripe.

    Why can't we just accept the fact that Armenians are simply a people
    just like any other? Not better or worse; a mix of good and bad,
    with its share of faults and foibles.

    Why can't we accept the Armenian reality that exists, even though
    sometimes it may leave a bitter taste in our mouths? We must realize
    that to change this reality we need to understand one another, to help
    one another, and not criticize or insult. The principle of "teaching
    and being taught" must be a key component of the equation.

    Defining a nation and its traits, of course, is different from an
    individual's national belonging and his/her emotions. A nation has a
    unique make-up - history, language, culture, religion and, of course,
    the native homeland on which it lives, survives, creates and develops
    its culture, language and literature.

    Naturally, it would be ideal if the traits of an individual feeling
    a sense of belonging to a nation correspond to the general traits of
    that nation - ideal, yes, but not mandatory.

    It is enough that a person feels a part of the nation as a whole;
    for the individual to be considered a member of the national family.

    Rather than abusing and stereotyping others, we should respect their
    feelings. We need to help and show them the way, as it were, so that
    they too can fully display our national traits.

    Yervand Khosrovyan European Congress of Armenians October 26, 2010




    From: A. Papazian
Working...
X