Tweet
AN ARMENIAN TALE
Growing Bookworms.com
Review by Jen Robinson
http://jkrbooks.typepad.com/blog/2011/07/the-greedy-sparrow-an-armenian-tale-lucine-kasbarian.html
The Greedy Sparrow: An Armenian Tale: Lucine Kasbarian
Book: The Greedy Sparrow: An Armenian Tale (WorldCat)
Author: Lucine Kasbarian
Illustrator: Maria Zaikina
Pages: 32
Age Range: 4 to 8
The Greedy Sparrow is a retelling by Lucine Kasbarian of an Armenian
Folk Tale. Since my husband is Armenian, and Baby Bookworm is half
Armenian, this seemed like a book that we needed to have in our
collection. And we're happy to have it.
Like most folk tales, The Greedy Sparrow has an overt moral. But,
in Kasbarian's version, anyway, the reader is not bashed over the
head with the moral. Rather, we spend most of the book shaking our
heads at the antics of the greedy sparrow, and only see him get his
(relatively mild) comeuppance on the last page.
The sparrow starts out with a thorn in his foot. He asks a baker woman
to pull it out. She does, cheerfully, and throws the thorn into her
fire. Then the manipulative sparrow demands to have his thorn back.
When this is impossible, he guilts the woman into giving him a piece
of bread. He then repeats this behavior, trading up and up and up by
taking advantage of people's good nature, and in some cases their
own inability to resist things (e.g. he asks a hungry shepherd to
watch the bread, and then ends up with a sheep when the shepherd
eats the bread, etc.). Of course he faces a reversal at the end,
because that's how these stories work.
My favorite part of The Greedy Sparrow, having spent a lot of time with
Armenians, is when a groom, left to care for the sheep at his wedding,
wonders "what would happen if I slaughtered the sheep, grilled it,
and made shish kebab for all the guests?" (The Armenians that I know
eat a lot of shish kebab.) Of course this aspect of the book may not
be pleasing to everyone. (No worries - the pictures go straight from
worried sheep to skewers on the grill - no details.)
Another aspect of the book that I liked, but that non-Armenian readers
might find challenging, is that there are various Armenian place names
mentioned, like the Arax River, Mount Ararat, Lake Van, and Aghtamar.
A pronunciation guide, at least for the last location, might have
been useful, but isn't strictly necessary.
Maria Zaikina's illustrations are perfect for the story. The art
was created with layers of wax and oil paint, with layers then cut
away to reveal the colors underneath. The resulting illustrations
have bold colors and decisive lines, and a crayon-like texture. The
illustrations feel rustic, as befits a folk tale set in mostly rural
areas. The church, the wedding clothes, and the people's faces all
look, to my eyes, authentically Armenian. Even the greedy sparrow
has kind of a Middle Eastern look to him. The book's designer, Anahid
Hamparian, is apparently Armenian, and her attention to detail shows.
I also love the expressive face of the ill-favored sheep.
The Greedy Sparrow is a lovingly created rendition of a traditional
Armenian fable. It is authentic and entertaining, and conveys the
anti-greed message with a deft touch. The Greedy Sparrow is a welcome
addition to the ranks of multicultural picture books and folk tale
retellings. Recommended.
Publisher: Marshall Cavendish Children's Books (@MarshallCav)
Publication Date: April 1, 2011 Source of Book: Review copy from
the publisher
From: Baghdasarian
Growing Bookworms.com
Review by Jen Robinson
http://jkrbooks.typepad.com/blog/2011/07/the-greedy-sparrow-an-armenian-tale-lucine-kasbarian.html
The Greedy Sparrow: An Armenian Tale: Lucine Kasbarian
Book: The Greedy Sparrow: An Armenian Tale (WorldCat)
Author: Lucine Kasbarian
Illustrator: Maria Zaikina
Pages: 32
Age Range: 4 to 8
The Greedy Sparrow is a retelling by Lucine Kasbarian of an Armenian
Folk Tale. Since my husband is Armenian, and Baby Bookworm is half
Armenian, this seemed like a book that we needed to have in our
collection. And we're happy to have it.
Like most folk tales, The Greedy Sparrow has an overt moral. But,
in Kasbarian's version, anyway, the reader is not bashed over the
head with the moral. Rather, we spend most of the book shaking our
heads at the antics of the greedy sparrow, and only see him get his
(relatively mild) comeuppance on the last page.
The sparrow starts out with a thorn in his foot. He asks a baker woman
to pull it out. She does, cheerfully, and throws the thorn into her
fire. Then the manipulative sparrow demands to have his thorn back.
When this is impossible, he guilts the woman into giving him a piece
of bread. He then repeats this behavior, trading up and up and up by
taking advantage of people's good nature, and in some cases their
own inability to resist things (e.g. he asks a hungry shepherd to
watch the bread, and then ends up with a sheep when the shepherd
eats the bread, etc.). Of course he faces a reversal at the end,
because that's how these stories work.
My favorite part of The Greedy Sparrow, having spent a lot of time with
Armenians, is when a groom, left to care for the sheep at his wedding,
wonders "what would happen if I slaughtered the sheep, grilled it,
and made shish kebab for all the guests?" (The Armenians that I know
eat a lot of shish kebab.) Of course this aspect of the book may not
be pleasing to everyone. (No worries - the pictures go straight from
worried sheep to skewers on the grill - no details.)
Another aspect of the book that I liked, but that non-Armenian readers
might find challenging, is that there are various Armenian place names
mentioned, like the Arax River, Mount Ararat, Lake Van, and Aghtamar.
A pronunciation guide, at least for the last location, might have
been useful, but isn't strictly necessary.
Maria Zaikina's illustrations are perfect for the story. The art
was created with layers of wax and oil paint, with layers then cut
away to reveal the colors underneath. The resulting illustrations
have bold colors and decisive lines, and a crayon-like texture. The
illustrations feel rustic, as befits a folk tale set in mostly rural
areas. The church, the wedding clothes, and the people's faces all
look, to my eyes, authentically Armenian. Even the greedy sparrow
has kind of a Middle Eastern look to him. The book's designer, Anahid
Hamparian, is apparently Armenian, and her attention to detail shows.
I also love the expressive face of the ill-favored sheep.
The Greedy Sparrow is a lovingly created rendition of a traditional
Armenian fable. It is authentic and entertaining, and conveys the
anti-greed message with a deft touch. The Greedy Sparrow is a welcome
addition to the ranks of multicultural picture books and folk tale
retellings. Recommended.
Publisher: Marshall Cavendish Children's Books (@MarshallCav)
Publication Date: April 1, 2011 Source of Book: Review copy from
the publisher
From: Baghdasarian