Tweet
JUDGE REFUSES TO TOSS ARMENIAN CHURCH BIBLE SUIT
Albany Democrat Herald
http://democratherald.com/news/national/article_eca68d42-3101-5499-8500-f41fc702b0e3.html
Nov 4 2011
The J. Paul Getty Museum on Thursday lost its bid for dismissal of
the Armenian church lawsuit demanding the return of pages ripped from
a sacred handwritten Armenian Bible dating back to 1256.
Superior Court Judge Abraham Khan denied Getty's motion to dismiss the
claim and ordered four months of mediation in an attempt to resolve
the dispute between the museum and the Western Prelacy of the Armenian
Apostolic Church of America, which filed suit in June 2010 on behalf
its mother church, the Lebanon-based Holy See of Cilicia.
The suit accuses Getty of harboring stolen illuminated medieval
manuscripts, saying they are spiritually and historically sacred
church masterpieces.
The lawsuit claims the church had the Bible authenticated in 1947 or
1948 and it was returned with more than a half-dozen pages missing.
The pages of painted parchment once formed the front pages of a larger
work called the Zeyt'un Gospels.
The church wants to send them to an Armenian museum in Yerevan so
they can be reunited with the rest of the Bible.
Getty officials say the more than half-dozen pages were legally
acquired in 1994 for $950,000 from an anonymous private collector.
The Los Angeles Times ( http://lat.ms/vQW5zV) said museum attorneys
argued during Thursday's brief hearing that the lawsuit filing deadline
expired decades ago.
But the judge said he was unclear on the statute of limitations issue.
Khan ordered mediation and another hearing on March 2 if the case
isn't settled.
Under California law, lawsuits to recover allegedly stolen artworks
from a museum or art dealer must be filed no later than six years
after the owner learns of their whereabouts.
"We are confident that we hold legal title," the Getty Museum said
in a statement after the ruling.
Church attorney Lee Boyd said afterward that the museum failed to
investigate the ownership history of the pages when it bought them
from Armenian American heirs of a man the church says stole the pages
in 1916.
The Zeyt'un Gospels had briefly fallen into his hands when Turks
expelled the Armenian community from Cilicia, then a region of the
Ottoman Empire and now part of Turkey, during and after the World
War I-era that Armenians term a genocide.
Albany Democrat Herald
http://democratherald.com/news/national/article_eca68d42-3101-5499-8500-f41fc702b0e3.html
Nov 4 2011
The J. Paul Getty Museum on Thursday lost its bid for dismissal of
the Armenian church lawsuit demanding the return of pages ripped from
a sacred handwritten Armenian Bible dating back to 1256.
Superior Court Judge Abraham Khan denied Getty's motion to dismiss the
claim and ordered four months of mediation in an attempt to resolve
the dispute between the museum and the Western Prelacy of the Armenian
Apostolic Church of America, which filed suit in June 2010 on behalf
its mother church, the Lebanon-based Holy See of Cilicia.
The suit accuses Getty of harboring stolen illuminated medieval
manuscripts, saying they are spiritually and historically sacred
church masterpieces.
The lawsuit claims the church had the Bible authenticated in 1947 or
1948 and it was returned with more than a half-dozen pages missing.
The pages of painted parchment once formed the front pages of a larger
work called the Zeyt'un Gospels.
The church wants to send them to an Armenian museum in Yerevan so
they can be reunited with the rest of the Bible.
Getty officials say the more than half-dozen pages were legally
acquired in 1994 for $950,000 from an anonymous private collector.
The Los Angeles Times ( http://lat.ms/vQW5zV) said museum attorneys
argued during Thursday's brief hearing that the lawsuit filing deadline
expired decades ago.
But the judge said he was unclear on the statute of limitations issue.
Khan ordered mediation and another hearing on March 2 if the case
isn't settled.
Under California law, lawsuits to recover allegedly stolen artworks
from a museum or art dealer must be filed no later than six years
after the owner learns of their whereabouts.
"We are confident that we hold legal title," the Getty Museum said
in a statement after the ruling.
Church attorney Lee Boyd said afterward that the museum failed to
investigate the ownership history of the pages when it bought them
from Armenian American heirs of a man the church says stole the pages
in 1916.
The Zeyt'un Gospels had briefly fallen into his hands when Turks
expelled the Armenian community from Cilicia, then a region of the
Ottoman Empire and now part of Turkey, during and after the World
War I-era that Armenians term a genocide.