Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

ISTANBUL: Turkey Prefers Fistfight To Legal Battle With France

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • ISTANBUL: Turkey Prefers Fistfight To Legal Battle With France

    TURKEY PREFERS FISTFIGHT TO LEGAL BATTLE WITH FRANCE

    Hurriyet Daily News
    Jan 24 2012
    Turkey

    I cannot recall any other example in the recent past of Turkish foreign
    relations in which relations with a certain country are connected to
    such a degree to just one person.

    Turkey's ties with France have now taken a unique character. Even
    if by some miracle the law criminalizing the denial of Armenians'
    genocide claims fails to pass the Senate, it has become apparent
    that as long as Nicolas Sarkozy remains French President, it will be
    difficult to put Turkish-French relations back on track.

    Sadly, not only relations with France, but also the fate of Turkey's
    EU relations are tied to the presidential elections in France. An
    electoral victory for Sarkozy will strengthen the hands of those in
    Turkey that favor a drastic review of relations with the EU. Even if
    those who are favoring a break up with the EU fail to get the upper
    hand in Turkey, we will definitely see hibernation in Turkish-EU
    ties if Sarkozy's electoral victory is followed by that of German
    Chancellor Angela Merkel next autumn.

    So a "war of attrition" with Sarkozy will probably take its toll on
    Turkey's relations with the EU as well.

    And indeed, signs coming from Ankara indicate that yesterday's vote was
    more important in terms of the consequences it will have on relations
    with France than the damage it might inflict on Turkey's international
    position with regard to claims of genocide. The government is inclined
    to see this initiative as a hostile act towards Turkey. Ankara believes
    Turkey has become an expandable country in the eyes of Sarkozy. "We
    are not going to let France bully Turkey like that," a high level
    foreign ministry official told me. His rhetoric reminded me of the
    atmosphere that followed the flotilla crisis with Israel.

    In the case of Israel, in addition to sanctions, Turkey sought to
    confront Israel on international platforms, despite the legal risks
    of challenging the Gaza blockade.

    In the French case, Turkey's hand seems to be much stronger legally.

    French experts have told Ankara that the law would be considered
    unconstitutional by France's constitutional court.

    There is also the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Turkish
    citizen Dogu Perincek filed a lawsuit with the ECHR against
    Switzerland, as he was sentenced in 2007 for having denied genocide
    claims. There is a high likelihood that the ECHR will decide against
    the Swiss, arguing that the Swiss court verdict is against freedom
    of expression. Ankara fears, however, that in its verdict the Court
    might, for instance, say that there is general recognition that the
    1915 events amount to genocide, which in turn might strengthen the
    hands of Armenians.

    There is also the Taner Akcam case. The ECHR has already found Turkey
    guilty of launching an investigation into Akcam for having said that
    there was Armenian genocide. The verdict does not carry any judgment
    on the validity of genocide claims, as the court limited itself to
    the issue of freedom of expression. The Turkish Justice Ministry,
    however, wants to appeal that decision, saying the investigation was
    later dropped and that there was no conviction anyway. The Foreign
    Ministry wants to leave it at that, fearing that there might be a
    "road accident" along the way.

    Such risks are making Turkey hesitant in resorting to legal means.

    Ankara prefers to present the case with France as an act of hostility,
    preferring fistfights to legal battles.

Working...
X