Tweet
Aliyev father and son, different looks at the conflict
Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso
29 March 2013
By Giorgio Comai
In recent months, a number of incidents have taken tensions between
Armenia and Azerbaijan to very high levels. On the Azeri side, the
rhetoric is more and more explicitly anti-Armenian and warlike, as
clearly exemplified by the Safarov case and the story of writer Akram
Aylisli. Yet, things have not always been such.
As reminded by Arzu Geybullayeva in a recent article, Heydar Aliyev,
father of current president Ilham, used to welcome Armenian
journalists with overall benevolent words. Here is an excerpt of a
speech by Heydar Aliyev, pronounced in the presence of Armenian and
Georgian journalists on July 1st, 1999:
"Unfortunately, the conflict that took place in 1988 in the period of
Soviet Union caused difficulties and relations between Armenia and
Azerbaijan that have never existed before in the history. If we look
at the history we can see that there were conflicts between Armenians
and Azerbaijanis on different levels. They caused victims and
bloodshed, however, later on this conflict was solved and the peaceful
situation was restored. For example, let`s take the event of 1905 or
1918, some years later the relationships were resumed, people became
friends and the bad was forgotten. That is clear and natural. People
don`t want bad things, they want good ones. This is not the case of
only Armenia and Azerbaijan. Let`s recall how many countries were
engaged in the World War II and how severe was the war between Russia,
the Soviet Union and Germany. And now look how perfect relationships
they have now. One can say the same words about many European
countries that have been fighting for many decades. All this was left
in the past, now they have friendly relationships, the European Union
was even established in Europe, they keep integrating and
approaching. [...]"
"We adhere the peaceful settlement of the conflict. I think that we
will find the way of settlement of the conflict and it will be in
conformity with interests of both Armenia and Azerbaijan. I don`t
think that Armenia and Azerbaijan will always be in conflict
situation. I don`t think so. Because the history proves that it is not
possible. [...] However, not only Azerbaijan suffered losses, Armenia
had losses as well, there are handicapped people in Armenia
too. Therefore, it is necessary to establish the atmosphere of trust
in order to go towards peace and settle the conflict peacefully."
Heydar Aliyev continued by stating that the journalists of the two
countries could have a particularly important role in this process,
and saluted the encounter that had taken place on that occasion.
I quote now an excerpt from a recent speech by President Ilham Aliyev,
son of Heydar, on the occasion of the twentieth anniversary of the
founding of the Azeri ruling party, the New Azerbaijan Party (extended
passages of the speech were posted in a series of tweets on the Azeri
president's Twitter channel).
"The main focus of our foreign policy is the resolution of the
Armenian-Azerbaijani Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. We will continue our
efforts. I want to reiterate that our position is very firm, it is
based on international law, history, justice and on our growing
strength. We are conducting talks and at the same time building up our
military strength."
"The gap between Armenia and Azerbaijan is already very large and
keeps expanding day by day. Azerbaijan grows stronger and more
powerful by the year, while Armenia weakens and declines every
year. Evidence of this is the mass exodus of people from Armenia to
other countries."
"We will continue our efforts to isolate Armenia. This policy is
working. We see its results. We will continue to expose Armenia's
aggressive policy in all international organizations. The number of
our friends in the world is growing. A growing number of countries
want to cooperate with us. We have started to invest in various areas
in foreign countries. This is a new process. We will step it up. Thus,
our political and economic relations with all countries of the world
will become even stronger in the future. Three countries have already
officially recognized the Khojaly genocide as an act of genocide. This
process has already begun and will be continued. We must ensure that
as many countries as possible recognize Khojaly as an act of
genocide. So from a medium- and long-term perspective, the restoration
of Azerbaijan's territorial integrity is beyond doubt. Neither we nor
the mediators involved in the matter have any doubts about that. That
is why we believe that international mediators have been more active
in addressing the issue lately. Everyone knows that the growing
political, economic and military power of Azerbaijan will lead to a
complete resolution of the issue in favor of Azerbaijan."
"I want to reiterate that we are involved in negotiations. But along
with that, we take all other steps and are ready for all the other
options. I repeat that Azerbaijan has strong legal, historical and
political grounds. I have no doubt that Azerbaijan will restore its
territorial integrity. The solution to this problem is possible on the
basis of these principles. [...] There are such forces =80`
pro-Armenian, anti-Azerbaijani and Islamophobic forces which can't
come to terms with our success and development. [...]"
"Our main enemy is the Armenian lobby. I have often talked about it, I
want to say it again without fearing anyone - our enemy is the
Armenian lobby. Because Armenia as a country is of no value. It is
actually a colony, an outpost run from abroad, a territory
artificially created on ancient Azerbaijani lands."
Aliyev does not hide the fact that Azerbaijan is strengthening its
military power and trying to isolate Armenia, which he calls "a
country of no value", suggesting also that the territory of
contemporary Armenia is historically Azeri - a theme that Aliyev has
brought up also in a speech a few days ago: "the Armenian state was
established on lands that are historically Azeri. The Khanate of
Yerevan, Zangezur, and Geycha [Sevan] - these lands are all
historically ours".
No sign of the need for a reconciliation process, of an agreement that
satisfies both countries, of the inevitability of peace and friendship
between two neighbouring peoples that characterized the speech of
Aliyev father in 1999.
I quoted two excerpts from public speeches by Ilham and Heydar Aliyev,
separated by over 10 years. These are individual speeches in different
contexts that, as meaningful as they may be, certainly cannot reflect
the complexity of the Aliyevs' approach towards the Armenian-Azeri
conflict under their presidencies.
They do, however, signal that something has changed. The rhetoric of
Aliyev father seems remarkably conciliatory and pacific compared to
his son's. Between father and son, with regard to the approach to the
issue of Nagorno Karabakh, something really has changed.
Osservatorio Balcani e Caucaso
29 March 2013
By Giorgio Comai
In recent months, a number of incidents have taken tensions between
Armenia and Azerbaijan to very high levels. On the Azeri side, the
rhetoric is more and more explicitly anti-Armenian and warlike, as
clearly exemplified by the Safarov case and the story of writer Akram
Aylisli. Yet, things have not always been such.
As reminded by Arzu Geybullayeva in a recent article, Heydar Aliyev,
father of current president Ilham, used to welcome Armenian
journalists with overall benevolent words. Here is an excerpt of a
speech by Heydar Aliyev, pronounced in the presence of Armenian and
Georgian journalists on July 1st, 1999:
"Unfortunately, the conflict that took place in 1988 in the period of
Soviet Union caused difficulties and relations between Armenia and
Azerbaijan that have never existed before in the history. If we look
at the history we can see that there were conflicts between Armenians
and Azerbaijanis on different levels. They caused victims and
bloodshed, however, later on this conflict was solved and the peaceful
situation was restored. For example, let`s take the event of 1905 or
1918, some years later the relationships were resumed, people became
friends and the bad was forgotten. That is clear and natural. People
don`t want bad things, they want good ones. This is not the case of
only Armenia and Azerbaijan. Let`s recall how many countries were
engaged in the World War II and how severe was the war between Russia,
the Soviet Union and Germany. And now look how perfect relationships
they have now. One can say the same words about many European
countries that have been fighting for many decades. All this was left
in the past, now they have friendly relationships, the European Union
was even established in Europe, they keep integrating and
approaching. [...]"
"We adhere the peaceful settlement of the conflict. I think that we
will find the way of settlement of the conflict and it will be in
conformity with interests of both Armenia and Azerbaijan. I don`t
think that Armenia and Azerbaijan will always be in conflict
situation. I don`t think so. Because the history proves that it is not
possible. [...] However, not only Azerbaijan suffered losses, Armenia
had losses as well, there are handicapped people in Armenia
too. Therefore, it is necessary to establish the atmosphere of trust
in order to go towards peace and settle the conflict peacefully."
Heydar Aliyev continued by stating that the journalists of the two
countries could have a particularly important role in this process,
and saluted the encounter that had taken place on that occasion.
I quote now an excerpt from a recent speech by President Ilham Aliyev,
son of Heydar, on the occasion of the twentieth anniversary of the
founding of the Azeri ruling party, the New Azerbaijan Party (extended
passages of the speech were posted in a series of tweets on the Azeri
president's Twitter channel).
"The main focus of our foreign policy is the resolution of the
Armenian-Azerbaijani Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. We will continue our
efforts. I want to reiterate that our position is very firm, it is
based on international law, history, justice and on our growing
strength. We are conducting talks and at the same time building up our
military strength."
"The gap between Armenia and Azerbaijan is already very large and
keeps expanding day by day. Azerbaijan grows stronger and more
powerful by the year, while Armenia weakens and declines every
year. Evidence of this is the mass exodus of people from Armenia to
other countries."
"We will continue our efforts to isolate Armenia. This policy is
working. We see its results. We will continue to expose Armenia's
aggressive policy in all international organizations. The number of
our friends in the world is growing. A growing number of countries
want to cooperate with us. We have started to invest in various areas
in foreign countries. This is a new process. We will step it up. Thus,
our political and economic relations with all countries of the world
will become even stronger in the future. Three countries have already
officially recognized the Khojaly genocide as an act of genocide. This
process has already begun and will be continued. We must ensure that
as many countries as possible recognize Khojaly as an act of
genocide. So from a medium- and long-term perspective, the restoration
of Azerbaijan's territorial integrity is beyond doubt. Neither we nor
the mediators involved in the matter have any doubts about that. That
is why we believe that international mediators have been more active
in addressing the issue lately. Everyone knows that the growing
political, economic and military power of Azerbaijan will lead to a
complete resolution of the issue in favor of Azerbaijan."
"I want to reiterate that we are involved in negotiations. But along
with that, we take all other steps and are ready for all the other
options. I repeat that Azerbaijan has strong legal, historical and
political grounds. I have no doubt that Azerbaijan will restore its
territorial integrity. The solution to this problem is possible on the
basis of these principles. [...] There are such forces =80`
pro-Armenian, anti-Azerbaijani and Islamophobic forces which can't
come to terms with our success and development. [...]"
"Our main enemy is the Armenian lobby. I have often talked about it, I
want to say it again without fearing anyone - our enemy is the
Armenian lobby. Because Armenia as a country is of no value. It is
actually a colony, an outpost run from abroad, a territory
artificially created on ancient Azerbaijani lands."
Aliyev does not hide the fact that Azerbaijan is strengthening its
military power and trying to isolate Armenia, which he calls "a
country of no value", suggesting also that the territory of
contemporary Armenia is historically Azeri - a theme that Aliyev has
brought up also in a speech a few days ago: "the Armenian state was
established on lands that are historically Azeri. The Khanate of
Yerevan, Zangezur, and Geycha [Sevan] - these lands are all
historically ours".
No sign of the need for a reconciliation process, of an agreement that
satisfies both countries, of the inevitability of peace and friendship
between two neighbouring peoples that characterized the speech of
Aliyev father in 1999.
I quoted two excerpts from public speeches by Ilham and Heydar Aliyev,
separated by over 10 years. These are individual speeches in different
contexts that, as meaningful as they may be, certainly cannot reflect
the complexity of the Aliyevs' approach towards the Armenian-Azeri
conflict under their presidencies.
They do, however, signal that something has changed. The rhetoric of
Aliyev father seems remarkably conciliatory and pacific compared to
his son's. Between father and son, with regard to the approach to the
issue of Nagorno Karabakh, something really has changed.