Tweet
ROBERT FISK: THE ARMENIAN HERO WHOM TURKEY WOULD PREFER TO FORGET
Sunday 12 May 2013
Sarkis Torossian, the Armenian-Turkish officer, was awarded medals
by Mustafa Kemal
"Torossian was personally awarded medals for his courage by Mustafa
Kemal"
Confronted by the chilling 100th anniversary of the genocide of
1.5 million Armenians at the hands of the Ottoman Turks in 1915,
Turkey's government is planning to swamp memories of the massacres
with ceremonies commemorating the Turkish victory over the Allies
at the battle of Gallipoli in the same year. Already, loyalist
academics have done their best to ignore the presence of thousands
of Arab troops among the Turkish armies at Gallipoli - and are even
branding an Armenian Turkish artillery officer who was decorated for
his bravery at Gallipoli as a liar who fabricated his own biography.
In fact, Captain Sarkis Torossian was personally awarded medals for his
courage by Mustafa Kemal, one of the Turkish heroes of Gallipoli who
later, as Ataturk, founded the modern Turkish state. But in view of the
desire of some of Turkey's most prominent historians to brand Torossian
a fraud, the word "modern" should perhaps be used in inverted commas.
Now these academics are even claiming that the Armenian army captain
invented his two medals from the future Ataturk. Yet one of the
most the outspoken Turkish historians to have fully acknowledged
the 1915 genocide, Taner Akcam, has tracked down Torossian's family
in America and inspected the two Ottoman medal records; one of them
bears Ataturk's original signature.
Turkey, as we all know, wants to join the EU. I also, by chance,
happen to think it should. How can we Europeans claim that the
Muslim world wishes to stay "apart" from our "values" when an entire
Muslim country wants to share our European society? We are hypocrites
indeed. Yet how can Turkey still hope to join when it still refuses
to acknowledge the truth of the Armenian genocide - and symbolises
this denial by a scandalous attack on a long-dead Ottoman officer?
Captain Torossian's memoirs, From Dardanelles to Palestine, were
first published in Boston in 1947. Ayhan Aktar, professor of social
sciences at Istanbul Bilgi University, first came across a copy of
the book 20 years ago and was amazed to learn that there were officers
of Armenian descent fighting for the Ottomans.
The eight-month battle for Gallipoli - an Allied landing dreamt up by
Churchill in the hope of capturing Constantinople and breaking the
deadlock on the Western Front - was a disaster for the British and
French, and the mass of Australian and New Zealand troops fighting
with them. They abandoned the beach-heads in January of 1916.
In his book, Torossian recounts the fighting at Gallipoli and other
battles in which he participated - until, towards the end of the Great
War, he found his sister among the Armenian refugees on the death
convoys to Syria and Palestine. He then turned himself over to the
Allies, meeting (but not liking) T E Lawrence and re-entering Turkey
with French forces. He eventually travelled to the US where he died.
The gutsy Professor Aktar, however - noticing his colleagues'
unwillingness to acknowledge that Arabs and Armenians fought in the
Ottoman Army - decided to publish Torossian's book in the Turkish
language. Initial reviews were favourable until two historians from
Sabanci University took exception. Dr Halil Berktay, for example,
wrote 13 newspaper columns in Taraf calling the entire book a fiction
and Torossian a liar.
Taner Akcam, the Turkish historian who discovered Torossian's family,
was stunned by the reaction to the Turkish edition of the book; one
critic, he says, even claimed Torossian did not exist. The Turkish
Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, spoke at Gallipoli two years ago
and gave a perfectly frank account of how Turkey planned to define
the Armenian genocide on its hundredth anniversary. "We are going to
make the year of 1915 known the whole world over," he said, "not as an
anniversary of a genocide as some people claimed and slandered (sic),
but we shall make it known as a glorious resistance of a nation -
in other wour defence of Gallipoli."
So Turkish nationalism is supposed to win out over history.
Descendants of those who died with the Anzac troops at Gallipoli,
however, might ask their Turkish hosts in 2015 why they do not honour
those brave Arabs and Armenians - including Captain Torossian -
who fought alongside the Ottoman Empire.
Comments have been closed for legal reasons
Sunday 12 May 2013
Sarkis Torossian, the Armenian-Turkish officer, was awarded medals
by Mustafa Kemal
"Torossian was personally awarded medals for his courage by Mustafa
Kemal"
Confronted by the chilling 100th anniversary of the genocide of
1.5 million Armenians at the hands of the Ottoman Turks in 1915,
Turkey's government is planning to swamp memories of the massacres
with ceremonies commemorating the Turkish victory over the Allies
at the battle of Gallipoli in the same year. Already, loyalist
academics have done their best to ignore the presence of thousands
of Arab troops among the Turkish armies at Gallipoli - and are even
branding an Armenian Turkish artillery officer who was decorated for
his bravery at Gallipoli as a liar who fabricated his own biography.
In fact, Captain Sarkis Torossian was personally awarded medals for his
courage by Mustafa Kemal, one of the Turkish heroes of Gallipoli who
later, as Ataturk, founded the modern Turkish state. But in view of the
desire of some of Turkey's most prominent historians to brand Torossian
a fraud, the word "modern" should perhaps be used in inverted commas.
Now these academics are even claiming that the Armenian army captain
invented his two medals from the future Ataturk. Yet one of the
most the outspoken Turkish historians to have fully acknowledged
the 1915 genocide, Taner Akcam, has tracked down Torossian's family
in America and inspected the two Ottoman medal records; one of them
bears Ataturk's original signature.
Turkey, as we all know, wants to join the EU. I also, by chance,
happen to think it should. How can we Europeans claim that the
Muslim world wishes to stay "apart" from our "values" when an entire
Muslim country wants to share our European society? We are hypocrites
indeed. Yet how can Turkey still hope to join when it still refuses
to acknowledge the truth of the Armenian genocide - and symbolises
this denial by a scandalous attack on a long-dead Ottoman officer?
Captain Torossian's memoirs, From Dardanelles to Palestine, were
first published in Boston in 1947. Ayhan Aktar, professor of social
sciences at Istanbul Bilgi University, first came across a copy of
the book 20 years ago and was amazed to learn that there were officers
of Armenian descent fighting for the Ottomans.
The eight-month battle for Gallipoli - an Allied landing dreamt up by
Churchill in the hope of capturing Constantinople and breaking the
deadlock on the Western Front - was a disaster for the British and
French, and the mass of Australian and New Zealand troops fighting
with them. They abandoned the beach-heads in January of 1916.
In his book, Torossian recounts the fighting at Gallipoli and other
battles in which he participated - until, towards the end of the Great
War, he found his sister among the Armenian refugees on the death
convoys to Syria and Palestine. He then turned himself over to the
Allies, meeting (but not liking) T E Lawrence and re-entering Turkey
with French forces. He eventually travelled to the US where he died.
The gutsy Professor Aktar, however - noticing his colleagues'
unwillingness to acknowledge that Arabs and Armenians fought in the
Ottoman Army - decided to publish Torossian's book in the Turkish
language. Initial reviews were favourable until two historians from
Sabanci University took exception. Dr Halil Berktay, for example,
wrote 13 newspaper columns in Taraf calling the entire book a fiction
and Torossian a liar.
Taner Akcam, the Turkish historian who discovered Torossian's family,
was stunned by the reaction to the Turkish edition of the book; one
critic, he says, even claimed Torossian did not exist. The Turkish
Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, spoke at Gallipoli two years ago
and gave a perfectly frank account of how Turkey planned to define
the Armenian genocide on its hundredth anniversary. "We are going to
make the year of 1915 known the whole world over," he said, "not as an
anniversary of a genocide as some people claimed and slandered (sic),
but we shall make it known as a glorious resistance of a nation -
in other wour defence of Gallipoli."
So Turkish nationalism is supposed to win out over history.
Descendants of those who died with the Anzac troops at Gallipoli,
however, might ask their Turkish hosts in 2015 why they do not honour
those brave Arabs and Armenians - including Captain Torossian -
who fought alongside the Ottoman Empire.
Comments have been closed for legal reasons