Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Turkey leads the world in jailing journalists

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Turkey leads the world in jailing journalists

    St. Paul Pioneer Press (Minnesota)
    May 19, 2013 Sunday


    Deloire, Simon: Turkey leads the world in jailing journalists

    By Christophe Deloire and Joel Simon


    President Barack Obama has consistently lavished praise on Recep
    Tayyip Erdogan, describing the Turkish prime minister as an
    "outstanding partner and an outstanding friend" and lauding his "great
    leadership" in promoting democracy in the Middle East. Erdogan has
    even won plaudits from the U.S. president for his "courageous steps"
    toward normalizing Turkish-Armenian relations and toward integrating
    minorities into the democratic process.

    But Obama also needs to deliver a different message: Turkey's failure
    to address its press freedom crisis is undermining the country
    strategic relationship with the United States and hindering its
    regional aspirations.

    Turkey's record on press freedom is deeply troubling. With 47
    journalists imprisoned for their work, the country is the world's
    leading jailer of journalists -- ahead of Iran and China. Most of
    those imprisoned were employed by media outlets that support Kurdish
    autonomy; others are accused of supporting an ultra-nationalist
    conspiracy to topple the government. Thousands more journalists are
    battling punitive lawsuits for reporting on a wide range of sensitive
    issues, exposing corruption or simply criticizing the ruling Justice
    and Development Party (AKP).

    Erdogan has continuously lashed out at the media, forcing top
    reporters and editors from their jobs. After columnist and television
    host Nuray Mert challenged the government's treatment of the Kurdish
    minority, for example, Erdogan implied that she was a traitor,
    prompting her politically sensitive employers to cancel her television
    show and newspaper column. A similar fate befell Hasan Cemal, a
    columnist at the daily Milliyet, after he published the minutes from a
    secret government meeting with jailed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK)
    leader Abdullah Ocalan.

    Despite regular promises that reform is just over the horizon, Erdogan
    appears to believe in the necessity of his heavy-handed tactics. When
    U.S. Ambassador Francis Ricciardone expressed concern about Turkey's
    press freedom record, for example, Erdogan dismissed the 35-year
    veteran of the U.S. Foreign Service as a "rookie." In response to our
    defense of Turkish journalists, Erdogan has accused Reporters Without
    Borders and the Committee to Protect Journalists of "supporting
    terrorism."

    Obama is right to recognize the strategic importance of Turkey's
    relationship with the United States. Turkey is a NATO member and an
    economic engine for the Middle East. It is also a key partner in
    addressing the conflict in Syria, as well as the nuclear standoff with
    Iran. But Turkey's strategic value also depends on its appeal as a
    model -- a moderate Muslim democracy that has managed to cultivate
    deep trade ties with Europe -- for the newly democratizing states of
    the Middle East. Turkey's poor record on press freedom undermines its
    credibility as a model and blunts its soft power.

    It also works against Turkey's own diplomatic ambitions. Erdogan's
    push to join the European Union, for example, has stalled for a
    variety of reasons, including Europe's economic downturn, resistance
    by member states to further EU expansion, and an unfortunate
    anti-Muslim bent within some European political circles. But a key
    stumbling block is also Turkey's record on press freedom, which has
    been the focus of hearings in the European Parliament and critical
    reports from the European Commission.
    Addressing Turkey's press freedom deficit is also critical for ending
    the country's three decade-long conflict with the PKK, which has waged
    a brutal campaign for Kurdish autonomy. In order for the current
    negotiations to succeed, Turkey must make space for the country's
    Kurdish minority to express its grievances fully and publicly. While
    the Kurdish media in Turkey is vibrant, it is also under constant
    assault -- the victim of frequent police raids, prosecutions, and
    politically motivated arrests. In 2011, for example, authorities
    arrested nine journalists at the pro-Kurdish daily cczgc 1/4r Gc
    1/4ndem for alleged links to the PKK, but furnished no evidence other
    than the journalists' own work.

    These concerns should be front and center during Obama's meeting with
    Erdogan this week. The U.S. president should also express concern
    about the way Turkey's terror laws are being used to suppress the
    media. A majority of the journalists currently in jail in Turkey are
    being prosecuted under the country's sweeping anti-terror law, passed
    in 1991 and updated in 2006 under Erdogan. Most have not been
    convicted of crimes, but are still being held for extended periods in
    pre-trial detention.

    While Obama and European leaders -- including German Chancellor Angela
    Merkel and French President Francois Hollande -- should continue to
    push for reform, a renewed commitment in Turkey to press freedom,
    human rights and democracy will ultimately hinge on Ankara's appraisal
    of its own interests.

    In fact, Turkey's move toward democracy in the last two decades has
    been as much the result of its own civil society's mobilization as a
    desire to appease Western critics. Journalists, press freedom
    advocates, progressive lawyers and free-thinking academics have taken
    risks and pushed for reform because they see a bright future for
    Turkey -- one that is built on a commitment to democracy and human
    rights.

    In the coming years, Turkey is bound to play a more active role in the
    global economy and on the international stage. The strengthening of
    democracy and respect for human rights should be seen in Ankara as
    assets, not liabilities. Authoritarian tendencies will only reduce
    Turkey's attractiveness and harm its hard-power interests.

    While Erdogan will certainly give his good friend Obama a fair
    hearing, it is unlikely that he'll give in to outside pressure. If
    Turkey's reforms are to be real and lasting, the country's leadership
    must perceive them to be in the national interest.

    Christophe Deloire is director general of Reporters Without Borders.
    Joel Simon is executive director of the Committee to Protect
    Journalists.

Working...
X