Tweet
CROSSING THE TURKISH-ARMENIAN DIVIDE
Los Angeles Times
November 30, 2014 Sunday
Home Edition
BOOK REVIEW;
review by: Lorraine Ali
There Was and There Was Not A Journey Through Hate and Possibility
in Turkey, Armenia, and Beyond Meline Toumani Metropolitan: 304 pp.
At the Armenian American camp Meline Toumani attended each summer in
Massachusetts, she and her fellow campers knew exactly what bonded
them as a people. And no, it wasn't just their adult-sized noses,
at least one of which elicited the nickname "Gonzo" back at school.
It was the need for recognition -- from Turkey and the world --
that the Armenian genocide had indeed happened. Even by grade school,
Toumani knew certain truths that others denied or were oblivious to:
One and a half million Armenians were killed under Ottoman Turkish
rule in 1915. Others were driven out, scattering around the globe in
a huge diaspora.
Toumani, a New York Times reporter who was born in Iran after her
family fled Armenia and raised in New Jersey, spends the first half
of her memoir establishing how central the fight for recognition is
to her people -- and how much it shaped her early life.
But as she reaches adulthood, the Turks Are Evil refrain has grown
tired. Toumani writes that she "could no longer stand to attend
any Armenian gathering, because it seemed that whether it was a
poetry reading, a concert, or even a sporting match, it was always,
ultimately, about the genocide."
So Toumani decides to move to Istanbul as part of a "project"
(this book) in which she'll try to view the Turks as people rather
than the monsters she'd been told about. The cast of characters she
meets includes Turkish scholars, laymen, snobs and journalists. Some
entirely ignore her when they discover her ethnicity, others become
allies, a few struggle to find something nice to say: Armenians are
good cooks! Above all, they prove to be surprisingly human, with
varying degrees of empathy and denial.
Her impressive reporting and research skills add context as she
takes us through old Armenian ruins and new interpretations of
Turkish history.
At the Museum of Anatolian Civilizations in Ankara, she describes
a timeline that marks the "shift and jolts" of 3,000 years' worth
of civilizations. Aegean migrations, the divide of the Roman Empire
and the rise of Byzantium. Then it suddenly skips from 330 to 1071,
to the Seljuk Turks.
"In other words," she writes, "the hundreds of years that comprised
the height of Armenian civilization in Anatolia -- the rise and fall
of several Armenian dynasties and kingdoms -- were left out of the
time line all together."
It's one of Toumani's many examples of the country's seemingly official
stance on Armenians: They don't exist.
A flood of history, politics and too many characters confuses
Toumani's goal of a "soft reconciliation," as she puts it. But it
also dilutes the emotional impact of this book at points. The fiber
needed to bind this together is Toumani herself -- and rather than
convey the personal thrill of discovery, she sometimes gets lost in
academic interludes. When this happens, "There Was and There Was Not"
does resemble more of a "project" than a personal journey.
After all, some of the book's best moments are its least assuming. In
one chapter, Toumani sketches a scene at the Istanbul airport when she
can't seem to find the designated gate for her flight to Armenia. Then
she spots a familiar crowd of people who "less resemble passengers
in a check-in line than practiced Soviets jockeying for the last loaf
of bread." Armenians.
Older women with "puffs of blue-black and purple-gray hair," who wore
"calf-length skirts and smooth blouses, armored bras aiming their
hefty bosoms at ninety degrees, challenging anybody to dare block
their path," she writes. "There were also a few slender Armenian
girls in skintight jeans, amply rouged, with silky long hair, wearing
stiletto heels and tank tops, fake breasts distorting fake logos. . .
. Yes, here they were, my people."
Toumani's final analysis about her experience/experiment in Turkey
is sure to spur arguments on both sides. But with this book, she
gives her people a bit of what they are asking for -- recognition --
while considering that there is always another side to the story.
Los Angeles Times
November 30, 2014 Sunday
Home Edition
BOOK REVIEW;
review by: Lorraine Ali
There Was and There Was Not A Journey Through Hate and Possibility
in Turkey, Armenia, and Beyond Meline Toumani Metropolitan: 304 pp.
At the Armenian American camp Meline Toumani attended each summer in
Massachusetts, she and her fellow campers knew exactly what bonded
them as a people. And no, it wasn't just their adult-sized noses,
at least one of which elicited the nickname "Gonzo" back at school.
It was the need for recognition -- from Turkey and the world --
that the Armenian genocide had indeed happened. Even by grade school,
Toumani knew certain truths that others denied or were oblivious to:
One and a half million Armenians were killed under Ottoman Turkish
rule in 1915. Others were driven out, scattering around the globe in
a huge diaspora.
Toumani, a New York Times reporter who was born in Iran after her
family fled Armenia and raised in New Jersey, spends the first half
of her memoir establishing how central the fight for recognition is
to her people -- and how much it shaped her early life.
But as she reaches adulthood, the Turks Are Evil refrain has grown
tired. Toumani writes that she "could no longer stand to attend
any Armenian gathering, because it seemed that whether it was a
poetry reading, a concert, or even a sporting match, it was always,
ultimately, about the genocide."
So Toumani decides to move to Istanbul as part of a "project"
(this book) in which she'll try to view the Turks as people rather
than the monsters she'd been told about. The cast of characters she
meets includes Turkish scholars, laymen, snobs and journalists. Some
entirely ignore her when they discover her ethnicity, others become
allies, a few struggle to find something nice to say: Armenians are
good cooks! Above all, they prove to be surprisingly human, with
varying degrees of empathy and denial.
Her impressive reporting and research skills add context as she
takes us through old Armenian ruins and new interpretations of
Turkish history.
At the Museum of Anatolian Civilizations in Ankara, she describes
a timeline that marks the "shift and jolts" of 3,000 years' worth
of civilizations. Aegean migrations, the divide of the Roman Empire
and the rise of Byzantium. Then it suddenly skips from 330 to 1071,
to the Seljuk Turks.
"In other words," she writes, "the hundreds of years that comprised
the height of Armenian civilization in Anatolia -- the rise and fall
of several Armenian dynasties and kingdoms -- were left out of the
time line all together."
It's one of Toumani's many examples of the country's seemingly official
stance on Armenians: They don't exist.
A flood of history, politics and too many characters confuses
Toumani's goal of a "soft reconciliation," as she puts it. But it
also dilutes the emotional impact of this book at points. The fiber
needed to bind this together is Toumani herself -- and rather than
convey the personal thrill of discovery, she sometimes gets lost in
academic interludes. When this happens, "There Was and There Was Not"
does resemble more of a "project" than a personal journey.
After all, some of the book's best moments are its least assuming. In
one chapter, Toumani sketches a scene at the Istanbul airport when she
can't seem to find the designated gate for her flight to Armenia. Then
she spots a familiar crowd of people who "less resemble passengers
in a check-in line than practiced Soviets jockeying for the last loaf
of bread." Armenians.
Older women with "puffs of blue-black and purple-gray hair," who wore
"calf-length skirts and smooth blouses, armored bras aiming their
hefty bosoms at ninety degrees, challenging anybody to dare block
their path," she writes. "There were also a few slender Armenian
girls in skintight jeans, amply rouged, with silky long hair, wearing
stiletto heels and tank tops, fake breasts distorting fake logos. . .
. Yes, here they were, my people."
Toumani's final analysis about her experience/experiment in Turkey
is sure to spur arguments on both sides. But with this book, she
gives her people a bit of what they are asking for -- recognition --
while considering that there is always another side to the story.