Tweet
YEREVAN PRESS CLUB WEEKLY NEWSLETTER
JANUARY 24-30, 2014
HIGHLIGHTS:
YPC WEEKLY NEWSLETTER CHANGES FORMAT
MEDIA ETHICS OBSERVATORY CONSIDERED THE COMPLAINT OF AUDIO-VISUAL REPORTERS
ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT AGAINST ATV
A JOURNALISTIC TRICK TAKES A REPORTER TO NATIONAL SECURITY SERVICE
CRIMINAL CASE AGAINST ARMENIA TODAY'S COORDINATOR SENT TO COURT
ANOTHER STUDY OF THE COMMITTEE TO PROTECT FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION ABOUT
INFORMATION TRANSPARENCY OF STATE AGENCIES
YPC WEEKLY NEWSLETTER CHANGES FORMAT
Dear readers,
This is the last 576th issue of Yerevan Press Club Weekly Newsletter in the
current format. In fact, this issue stands out from all the others,
published since December 2000, by this feature only.
The cessation the YPC Weekly Newsletter issuance in this format that has
been used for 13 years is conditioned by the changes in the package of our
organization's information products.
>From now on you can find news on the developments in the Armenian media on
the YPC website and on the website of EaP
Media Freedom Watch which YPC
contributes to jointly with colleagues from five other Eastern Partnership
countries.
Elina POGHOSBEKIAN
YPC Weekly Newsletter Editor
MEDIA ETHICS OBSERVATORY CONSIDERED THE COMPLAINT OF AUDIO-VISUAL REPORTERS
ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT AGAINST ATV
On January 25, the Media Ethics
Observatory (MEO) considered the complaint of Arzuman Harutyunian, President
of Audio-Visual Reporters Association, on "Affectionate Torture" program
(from "Half-Open Windows" cycle), broadcast by ATV TV channel on December 9,
2013.
The program told the story of the creation and collapse of a family, also
touching upon trafficking. The President of Audio-Visual Reporters
Association believes that when covering this topic the authors of the
program violated both legal and professional ethical norms: in particular,
they publicized private information about the victims of trafficking. On
December 19, Arzuman Harutyunian sent a letter to the administration of the
TV channel with a thorough description of all the violations that had taken
place in the program. A reply, dated January 14 and signed by ATV General
Director Vahagn Khachatrian, noted that the TV company disagreed with the
comments made by Association and was planning to broadcast "Affectionate
Torture"-2.
On January 21, Arzuman Harutyunian turned to the Media Ethics Observatory.
Regardless of the invitation, the representatives of ATV did not take part
in the session. Considering the complaint, the members of the MEO came to
the conclusion that the program contained violations of both ethical norms
and international conventions on trafficking. (The MEO expert judgment will
be published soon at http://www.ypc.am/self_regul/ln/en).
A JOURNALISTIC TRICK TAKES A REPORTER TO NATIONAL SECURITY SERVICE
On January 30, the RA National Security Service (NSS) sent out a press
release, explaining the reasons of inviting Avetis Babajanian, "168 Zham"
newspaper reporter, to the NSS.
In its January 28-29, 2014 issue, "168 Zham" published an article by Avetis
Babajanian "Chechens Plan a
Terroristic Act in Armenia", starting out with the following lines: "Our
sources, standing close to authorities, inform that terroristic acts may
target Russian objects in Armenia during the Winter Olympics in Sochi."
The press release presents the written clarification, provided by Avetis
Babajanian to the security agency, of his expression "our sources, standing
close to authorities, inform that (...)". "I used this word combination as a
journalistic trick in order to make the story sound more intriguing. With
full responsibility do I note that no source has ever provided me with any
information on the topic presented in the article", Avetis Babajanian
explained.
Further the NSS press release states: "This explanation makes it clear that
Babajanian's "article" is a forgery; moreover, it is the result of lack of
serious journalistic approach and basic accountability. It is simply an
unconscious composition of ungrounded suppositions. The journalist did not
bother to think of those who would read his ominous thoughts. By the way,
the editor of the newspaper did not bother either."
CRIMINAL CASE AGAINST ARMENIA TODAY'S COORDINATOR SENT TO COURT
According to ARMENIA
Today agency, the RA Special
Investigative Service sent the criminal case against
ARMENIA Today coordinator Argishti Kivirian to court. The action was
initiated in connection with the August 24, 2013 incident between the
journalist and police officers. Argishti Kivirian has been charged by
Article 316 of the RA Criminal Code ("Violence against a representative of
the authorities").
As we have reported, Argishti Kivirian was detained on August 24, 2013,
during the public protests against the construction of a residential
building in the vicinity of 5 Komitas Avenue in Yerevan. According to the
journalist, the law-enforcers beat him in the police car, he was summoned to
the Yerevan Arabkir Police Department with injuries and bruises on his face,
from where the ambulance transferred him to "Erebuni" medical center. On
August 25, the police instituted criminal proceedings against him on charges
of Article 316 of the Criminal Code. In his turn, Argishti Kivirian
addressed the police with a statement about the use of force during his
detention. All materials related to the incident were sent to the Special
Investigative Service that initially accused the journalist by Article 316
as well as Article 333 ("False denunciation") of the Criminal Code. Later
the investigative body acquitted him of the false denunciation charge and
offered to grant the journalist an amnesty. However, Argishti Kivirian
refused the amnesty and demanded that all the offenders involved in illegal
actions against him should be called to account (see details in YPC Weekly
Newsletter, January 17-23, 2014 ).
ANOTHER STUDY OF THE COMMITTEE TO PROTECT FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION ABOUT
INFORMATION TRANSPARENCY OF STATE AGENCIES
On January 30, the Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression (CPFE)
published the results of its "Access to Official Information and Open
Governance" study. The monitoring of the RA state agency websites has been
implemented for three years, aiming to identify the level of information
transparency of these bodies. At a meeting with journalists the CPFE
presented the data for 2013. This study is published as a separate booklet
(in Armenian, English and Russian) and has also been posted at
http://khosq.am/.
When reprinting or using the information above, reference to the Yerevan
Press Club is required.
You are welcome to send any comment and feedback about the Newsletter to:
[email protected]
Subscription for the Newsletter is free. To subscribe or unsubscribe from
this mailing list, please send a message to: [email protected]
Editor of YPC Newsletter - Elina POGHOSBEKIAN
____________________________________________
Yerevan Press Club
9B, Ghazar Parpetsi str.
0002, Yerevan, Armenia
Tel.: (+ 374 10) 53 00 67; 53 35 41; 53 76 62
Fax: (+374 10) 53 56 61
E-mail: [email protected]
Web Site: www.ypc.am
JANUARY 24-30, 2014
HIGHLIGHTS:
YPC WEEKLY NEWSLETTER CHANGES FORMAT
MEDIA ETHICS OBSERVATORY CONSIDERED THE COMPLAINT OF AUDIO-VISUAL REPORTERS
ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT AGAINST ATV
A JOURNALISTIC TRICK TAKES A REPORTER TO NATIONAL SECURITY SERVICE
CRIMINAL CASE AGAINST ARMENIA TODAY'S COORDINATOR SENT TO COURT
ANOTHER STUDY OF THE COMMITTEE TO PROTECT FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION ABOUT
INFORMATION TRANSPARENCY OF STATE AGENCIES
YPC WEEKLY NEWSLETTER CHANGES FORMAT
Dear readers,
This is the last 576th issue of Yerevan Press Club Weekly Newsletter in the
current format. In fact, this issue stands out from all the others,
published since December 2000, by this feature only.
The cessation the YPC Weekly Newsletter issuance in this format that has
been used for 13 years is conditioned by the changes in the package of our
organization's information products.
>From now on you can find news on the developments in the Armenian media on
the YPC website and on the website of EaP
Media Freedom Watch which YPC
contributes to jointly with colleagues from five other Eastern Partnership
countries.
Elina POGHOSBEKIAN
YPC Weekly Newsletter Editor
MEDIA ETHICS OBSERVATORY CONSIDERED THE COMPLAINT OF AUDIO-VISUAL REPORTERS
ASSOCIATION PRESIDENT AGAINST ATV
On January 25, the Media Ethics
Observatory (MEO) considered the complaint of Arzuman Harutyunian, President
of Audio-Visual Reporters Association, on "Affectionate Torture" program
(from "Half-Open Windows" cycle), broadcast by ATV TV channel on December 9,
2013.
The program told the story of the creation and collapse of a family, also
touching upon trafficking. The President of Audio-Visual Reporters
Association believes that when covering this topic the authors of the
program violated both legal and professional ethical norms: in particular,
they publicized private information about the victims of trafficking. On
December 19, Arzuman Harutyunian sent a letter to the administration of the
TV channel with a thorough description of all the violations that had taken
place in the program. A reply, dated January 14 and signed by ATV General
Director Vahagn Khachatrian, noted that the TV company disagreed with the
comments made by Association and was planning to broadcast "Affectionate
Torture"-2.
On January 21, Arzuman Harutyunian turned to the Media Ethics Observatory.
Regardless of the invitation, the representatives of ATV did not take part
in the session. Considering the complaint, the members of the MEO came to
the conclusion that the program contained violations of both ethical norms
and international conventions on trafficking. (The MEO expert judgment will
be published soon at http://www.ypc.am/self_regul/ln/en).
A JOURNALISTIC TRICK TAKES A REPORTER TO NATIONAL SECURITY SERVICE
On January 30, the RA National Security Service (NSS) sent out a press
release, explaining the reasons of inviting Avetis Babajanian, "168 Zham"
newspaper reporter, to the NSS.
In its January 28-29, 2014 issue, "168 Zham" published an article by Avetis
Babajanian "Chechens Plan a
Terroristic Act in Armenia", starting out with the following lines: "Our
sources, standing close to authorities, inform that terroristic acts may
target Russian objects in Armenia during the Winter Olympics in Sochi."
The press release presents the written clarification, provided by Avetis
Babajanian to the security agency, of his expression "our sources, standing
close to authorities, inform that (...)". "I used this word combination as a
journalistic trick in order to make the story sound more intriguing. With
full responsibility do I note that no source has ever provided me with any
information on the topic presented in the article", Avetis Babajanian
explained.
Further the NSS press release states: "This explanation makes it clear that
Babajanian's "article" is a forgery; moreover, it is the result of lack of
serious journalistic approach and basic accountability. It is simply an
unconscious composition of ungrounded suppositions. The journalist did not
bother to think of those who would read his ominous thoughts. By the way,
the editor of the newspaper did not bother either."
CRIMINAL CASE AGAINST ARMENIA TODAY'S COORDINATOR SENT TO COURT
According to ARMENIA
Today agency, the RA Special
Investigative Service sent the criminal case against
ARMENIA Today coordinator Argishti Kivirian to court. The action was
initiated in connection with the August 24, 2013 incident between the
journalist and police officers. Argishti Kivirian has been charged by
Article 316 of the RA Criminal Code ("Violence against a representative of
the authorities").
As we have reported, Argishti Kivirian was detained on August 24, 2013,
during the public protests against the construction of a residential
building in the vicinity of 5 Komitas Avenue in Yerevan. According to the
journalist, the law-enforcers beat him in the police car, he was summoned to
the Yerevan Arabkir Police Department with injuries and bruises on his face,
from where the ambulance transferred him to "Erebuni" medical center. On
August 25, the police instituted criminal proceedings against him on charges
of Article 316 of the Criminal Code. In his turn, Argishti Kivirian
addressed the police with a statement about the use of force during his
detention. All materials related to the incident were sent to the Special
Investigative Service that initially accused the journalist by Article 316
as well as Article 333 ("False denunciation") of the Criminal Code. Later
the investigative body acquitted him of the false denunciation charge and
offered to grant the journalist an amnesty. However, Argishti Kivirian
refused the amnesty and demanded that all the offenders involved in illegal
actions against him should be called to account (see details in YPC Weekly
Newsletter, January 17-23, 2014 ).
ANOTHER STUDY OF THE COMMITTEE TO PROTECT FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION ABOUT
INFORMATION TRANSPARENCY OF STATE AGENCIES
On January 30, the Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression (CPFE)
published the results of its "Access to Official Information and Open
Governance" study. The monitoring of the RA state agency websites has been
implemented for three years, aiming to identify the level of information
transparency of these bodies. At a meeting with journalists the CPFE
presented the data for 2013. This study is published as a separate booklet
(in Armenian, English and Russian) and has also been posted at
http://khosq.am/.
When reprinting or using the information above, reference to the Yerevan
Press Club is required.
You are welcome to send any comment and feedback about the Newsletter to:
[email protected]
Subscription for the Newsletter is free. To subscribe or unsubscribe from
this mailing list, please send a message to: [email protected]
Editor of YPC Newsletter - Elina POGHOSBEKIAN
____________________________________________
Yerevan Press Club
9B, Ghazar Parpetsi str.
0002, Yerevan, Armenia
Tel.: (+ 374 10) 53 00 67; 53 35 41; 53 76 62
Fax: (+374 10) 53 56 61
E-mail: [email protected]
Web Site: www.ypc.am