Tweet
COMPARING GENOCIDE: JEWS AND OTTOMAN GREEKS
http://greek-genocide.net/index.php/overview/documentation/201-comparing-genocide-jews-and-ottoman-greeks
Greek men in Smyrna guarded by Turkish troops for deportation to the
interior (September 1922)
We are all familiar with the mass extermination of Jews during the
Second World War. But are we familiar with the extermination of 1.5
million Greeks during the period 1914-1923 in the Ottoman Empire
(today's Turkey)? How can one genocide be so well known, yet another
go virtually unnoticed? Genocide has a lasting effect, not only on
survivors, but also on their families. It is for that reason that
genocide should not go unpunished. Unfortunately for the genocide
of the Ottoman Greeks, it has received little recognition, let alone
coverage in media and inclusion in school curricula.
Certain cultures have done everything in their power to bring to light
the genocide of their people regardless of how long ago it occurred.
Take for example the Armenians who were co-victims in genocide along
with the Greeks in the Ottoman Empire during the period 1914-1923. The
Armenian Genocide is synonymous to many people. A plethora of books
are available in English on the Armenian Genocide and subsequently
it has been recognized by over 20 countries worldwide.
In Australia, we are all familiar with the legend of the ANZACS through
the education system. We've heard about those brave Aussie soldiers
who fought courageously alongside the New Zealanders on the Allies'
side against the Germans and Turks at Gallipoli. The name Gallipoli by
the way comes from the Greek 'Î~ZαÎ"Î"ίÏ~@οÎ"η' which means 'good
city'. It should be no surprise then, that Gallipoli was inhabited
by some 30,000 Greeks prior to the ANZACS landing in April 19151. But
when the ANZACS landed, those Greeks had already been eliminated. They
were given a few hours notice to vacate their homes.
They were placed in steamers and then sent to the interior, to Turkish
villages where they were given the choice of Islam or death. Their
men were conscripted into the notorious Labour Battalions where most
perished due to a lack of food and water. The Greek Genocide had
already begun.
But why is the Greek Genocide so unknown to most? Let's for one moment
compare it to the Jewish Holocaust, a genocide most are familiar with.
In doing so, we will be able to see that the genocide of the Greeks
of the former Ottoman Empire, had many similarities with the Jewish
Holocaust which was to happen some 20 years later (1933-1945).
There are at least 14 similarities between the two genocides in
question. It should be noted that in 2007, the Greek Genocide was
formally recognised by one of the foremost groups of genocide scholars,
the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS).
It is however unrecognised by nations worldwide, including Australia.
The following are the most obvious similarities between the Jewish
Holocaust and the Greek Genocide:
Timing: As mentioned above, both genocides occurred around the time
of a world war. This allowed the mass slaughter to happen while the
world's attention was focussed on the war itself. Both genocides
were perpetrated over several years; the Holocaust over 12 years
(1933-1945) and the Greek Genocide over 9 years (1914-1923).
Death Toll: The total number of Jews exterminated was 6 million,
out of a total of 9 million, which accounted to 66% of the Jewish
population in Europe at the time. If we look at the genocide of the
Greeks, 1.5 million were exterminated out of a total of 2.7 million
who were living in the Ottoman Empire, or 55%2. While four times the
number of Jews were exterminated, the percentage is comparable.
Co-victims: Many people believe that the Holocaust involved just the
mass slaughter of Jews. In fact the Nazis did not only exterminate
the Jews. They also exterminated the disabled, homosexuals, Romani
(Gypsies), Jehovah's witnesses and others. In the case of the genocide
in the Ottoman Empire, it wasn't only Greeks who were massacred.
Armenians, Assyrians, Yezidis, Jews and other groups were victims too.
Perpetrators/regimes: In the case of the Holocaust, the Nazis (or the
Nationalist Socialist German Worker's Party) came to power in 1933
and almost immediately set about in persecuting Jews and others. The
Committee of Union and Progress (C.U.P), otherwise known as the Young
Turks came to power in 1913 and immediately began implementing their
plan to eradicate Greeks and other minorities.
Leading figures: The leader of the Nazi party was Adolf Hitler. He was
to become one of the most ruthless dictators in the world. If we put
aside the triumvirate of the Young Turks (Enver, Djemal and Talaat)
who were in control of the C.U.P from 1913-1918, the man who rose to
power in what is referred to as the Kemalist phase of the genocide,
was Mustafa Kemal. He emerged in May 1919 to complete the genocide
his predecessors - the triumvirate - had initiated. The difference
being, that Mustafa Kemal was to remain a leader/dictator well after
the genocide was complete, hence his title 'Ataturk' (meaning father
of the Turks).
Paramilitary (Death squads): The main three paramilitary groups used
by the Nazi's to complete the Holocaust were the SA (Storm Troups),
the SS (Elite Echelon) and the Gestapo (Secret police). The SS,
also referred to as Hitler's 'Death's Head Unit' was responsible
for the mass murder of the Jews. The paramilitary unit which was
responsible for the genocide of Greeks was the TeÅ~_kilât-ı Mahsusa
otherwise known as the Special Organisation (S.O). This organisation
was made up of current and former convicts, religious order groups,
volunteer groups (Lazes and Kurds etc) as well as armed irregulars
(cetecelier/brigands)3.
Ideology: The ideology in both genocides was based on myth. The Nazis
were under the illusion that the Jews wanted to control the world,
hence they had to be exterminated (The Final Solution). The Nazis also
believed that the Aryans, a Nordic race who exhibited blonde hair and
blue eyes, were the first to live in Germany and therefore all others
were inferior. With the outbreak of WW1, the Turks believed that the
Greeks living within the empire were disloyal or were supplying the
enemy with goods. As a result, their ideology was to turn to one of
'Turkey for the Turks' and the eradication of all its 'non-Turkish'
citizens had to be carried out.
Boycotting: The Nazis seized power in January of 1933. Within
two months they carried out the first nationwide boycott of Jewish
businesses. Storm Troops were to stand outside Jewish businesses and
offices of professionals, and paint the Star of David across their
doorways with signs saying 'Don't buy from the Jews'. Comparably
the start of the Greek Genocide occurred on April 6, 1914 when the
Turks boycotted Greek businesses in Eastern Thrace and later along
the western shoreline of Asia Minor and the Black Sea. In both cases,
boycotting was the first sign the genocides had begun.
Hate speech: Hitler outwardly spoke of his hatred of Jews. He referred
to them as a plague, an epidemic, germ carriers, harmful bacillus,
a cancer and as maggots. With the outbreak of WW1 in the Ottoman
Empire, the Sultan issued a declaration of war effectively a Jihad
against the people of the countries who it was fighting against (ie
everyone except Germans and Austrians). A secret paper which was being
distributed, wrote: "The world of Islam sinks down and goes backward
and the Christian world goes forward and is more and more exalted.
Take them and kill them whenever you find them. He who kills even one
unbeliever of those who rule over us, whether he does it secretly or
openly, shall be rewarded by God."4
Disarming: Hitler was able to disarm the Jews by enacting the 1938
German Weapons Act which prohibited Jews from possessing any dangerous
weapon including guns. Jews were also forbidden from the manufacture
or dealing of firearms and ammunition. In comparison, at the outbreak
of WW1, the C.U.P was able to disarm the Greeks by forcing them into
Labour Battallions, or Amele Taburu as they were called. The death
toll in these battalions was as high as 90%, as men were sent into
the interior of Asia Minor and made to do back breaking work with
little food or water.5
Deportations/Death marches: The majority of deportations of Jews
occurred towards the end of WW2 when the allies were closing in
on the Nazis, and Jews were deported away from the extermination
camps and into the interior by train and by foot. The major method
of extermination of the Jews was by the use of gas chambers, so
deportation was not relied upon to exterminate them en masse. On the
other hand, the Turks deported Greeks from virtually every region
of Asia Minor and Eastern Thrace, usually to the interior, by foot,
without food and water, and in many cases during the peak of winter,
with intent to bring about their physical destruction without the
need for bullets or other means.
Jews in Brody, Ukraine detained by German Nazis and awaiting
deportation (circa 1942-1943).
Concentration Camps and Ghettos: While Jews had been living in ghettos
for centuries in Europe, the Nazis enforced a ghetto system for the
Jews in order to isolate them for the purpose of persecution. When the
'Final Solution' was to take effect in 1942, these ghettos were closed
and Jews were sent to concentration, labour and extermination camps.
In the Ottoman Empire, the Greeks were deported usually to
destinations in the interior. On the 21st of April 1916, a New York
Times article with the headline 'Turks Deporting Greeks' wrote:
"Civilian concentration camp victims attacked and despoiled. The
Turkish authorities on the Black Sea regions are acting toward the
Greeks in the same fashion as the Germans have done with regard to the
civil populations of the occupied portions of north-eastern France."
So not only were Greeks sent to concentration camps and attacked
and despoiled along the way, a German involvement also existed. It's
interesting to note that Germany who allied itself with the Ottoman
Empire was in control of the Ottoman military and was therefore
complicit in the Greek Genocide6.
Extermination methods: The major method of exterminating Jews was via
lethal gas in extermination camps. In these camps, several hundred
Jews at a time were locked into chambers and the lethal gas Zyclon-B
was released. Tens of thousands of Jews were exterminated each day in
this manner. While the Turks were not as advanced in their methods of
exterminating Greeks, they were nonetheless effective. As mentioned,
deportation was an effective way to exterminate the Greeks. Another
common method was locking hundreds of Greeks in churches and burning
them alive. Newspaper reports also point to lethal injections7 being
used, parboiling8, and dumping Greeks into the sea9 amongst others.
Resistance: Although the 1938 German Weapons Act prevented Jews from
owning guns, the Jews did offer some resistance during the Holocaust.
There were in fact over a hundred armed Jewish uprisings. One of the
most notable groups was the Bielski partisans who armed themselves
and spent more than two years living in the forests. They were to
save many lives. Most are familiar with the resistance of the Greeks
of the Pontus. By arming themselves, these Greeks were able to defend
themselves and in the process save thousands of Pontic Greeks from
extermination. Many however are not so familiar with the Greeks of
Nicomedia (today Izmit) who likewise offered armed resistance.
By comparing all the above, we can see that the Greek Genocide has
many parallels with that of the Jewish Holocaust, yet it remains
largely forgotten and unrecognised. The German state has officially
recognised the Holocaust and has to date paid some $90 billion in
compensation to the victims. On the other hand, Turkey has continued
to deny that the events of 1914-1923 were an act of genocide, instead
labelling them as the result of civil war.
The crime of genocide has no place in society. Genocides should be
punished regardless of when they occurred, in order to bring closure
and justice to all survivors and their families, and to also act as a
deterrent for those considering committing genocide in the future. The
Greek Genocide is one such genocide which awaits recognition.
References
1. John Williams, The ethnic cleansing of Greeks from Gallipoli,
April 1915. Quadrant online.
2. Haris Tsirkinidis, The concise history of the Greeks of Anatolia.
Kyriakides publishers, 2009. p199.
3. Racho Donef, The role of TeÅ~_kilât-ı Mahsusa. The Genocide of
the Ottoman Greeks. Caratzas, 2011. p187.
4. Henry Morgenthau Snr, Ambassador Morgenthau's story. Cosimo Inc,
2010. p114.
5. Efthimios N. Couzinos, Twenty-three years in Asia Minor.
Publishers' Graphics, LLC, IL. p54.
6. First hun held for atrocities, The evening independent, Mar 15,
1919.
7. Turkish atrocities, Western Mail, W.A. October 26, 1922.
8. Turks parboiled 250,000. New York Times, July 31, 1919.
9. 1,000,000 Greeks are put to death by Turco-Teuton forces in Asia
Minor. The Washington Post, January 1, 1918.
http://greek-genocide.net/index.php/overview/documentation/201-comparing-genocide-jews-and-ottoman-greeks
Greek men in Smyrna guarded by Turkish troops for deportation to the
interior (September 1922)
We are all familiar with the mass extermination of Jews during the
Second World War. But are we familiar with the extermination of 1.5
million Greeks during the period 1914-1923 in the Ottoman Empire
(today's Turkey)? How can one genocide be so well known, yet another
go virtually unnoticed? Genocide has a lasting effect, not only on
survivors, but also on their families. It is for that reason that
genocide should not go unpunished. Unfortunately for the genocide
of the Ottoman Greeks, it has received little recognition, let alone
coverage in media and inclusion in school curricula.
Certain cultures have done everything in their power to bring to light
the genocide of their people regardless of how long ago it occurred.
Take for example the Armenians who were co-victims in genocide along
with the Greeks in the Ottoman Empire during the period 1914-1923. The
Armenian Genocide is synonymous to many people. A plethora of books
are available in English on the Armenian Genocide and subsequently
it has been recognized by over 20 countries worldwide.
In Australia, we are all familiar with the legend of the ANZACS through
the education system. We've heard about those brave Aussie soldiers
who fought courageously alongside the New Zealanders on the Allies'
side against the Germans and Turks at Gallipoli. The name Gallipoli by
the way comes from the Greek 'Î~ZαÎ"Î"ίÏ~@οÎ"η' which means 'good
city'. It should be no surprise then, that Gallipoli was inhabited
by some 30,000 Greeks prior to the ANZACS landing in April 19151. But
when the ANZACS landed, those Greeks had already been eliminated. They
were given a few hours notice to vacate their homes.
They were placed in steamers and then sent to the interior, to Turkish
villages where they were given the choice of Islam or death. Their
men were conscripted into the notorious Labour Battalions where most
perished due to a lack of food and water. The Greek Genocide had
already begun.
But why is the Greek Genocide so unknown to most? Let's for one moment
compare it to the Jewish Holocaust, a genocide most are familiar with.
In doing so, we will be able to see that the genocide of the Greeks
of the former Ottoman Empire, had many similarities with the Jewish
Holocaust which was to happen some 20 years later (1933-1945).
There are at least 14 similarities between the two genocides in
question. It should be noted that in 2007, the Greek Genocide was
formally recognised by one of the foremost groups of genocide scholars,
the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS).
It is however unrecognised by nations worldwide, including Australia.
The following are the most obvious similarities between the Jewish
Holocaust and the Greek Genocide:
Timing: As mentioned above, both genocides occurred around the time
of a world war. This allowed the mass slaughter to happen while the
world's attention was focussed on the war itself. Both genocides
were perpetrated over several years; the Holocaust over 12 years
(1933-1945) and the Greek Genocide over 9 years (1914-1923).
Death Toll: The total number of Jews exterminated was 6 million,
out of a total of 9 million, which accounted to 66% of the Jewish
population in Europe at the time. If we look at the genocide of the
Greeks, 1.5 million were exterminated out of a total of 2.7 million
who were living in the Ottoman Empire, or 55%2. While four times the
number of Jews were exterminated, the percentage is comparable.
Co-victims: Many people believe that the Holocaust involved just the
mass slaughter of Jews. In fact the Nazis did not only exterminate
the Jews. They also exterminated the disabled, homosexuals, Romani
(Gypsies), Jehovah's witnesses and others. In the case of the genocide
in the Ottoman Empire, it wasn't only Greeks who were massacred.
Armenians, Assyrians, Yezidis, Jews and other groups were victims too.
Perpetrators/regimes: In the case of the Holocaust, the Nazis (or the
Nationalist Socialist German Worker's Party) came to power in 1933
and almost immediately set about in persecuting Jews and others. The
Committee of Union and Progress (C.U.P), otherwise known as the Young
Turks came to power in 1913 and immediately began implementing their
plan to eradicate Greeks and other minorities.
Leading figures: The leader of the Nazi party was Adolf Hitler. He was
to become one of the most ruthless dictators in the world. If we put
aside the triumvirate of the Young Turks (Enver, Djemal and Talaat)
who were in control of the C.U.P from 1913-1918, the man who rose to
power in what is referred to as the Kemalist phase of the genocide,
was Mustafa Kemal. He emerged in May 1919 to complete the genocide
his predecessors - the triumvirate - had initiated. The difference
being, that Mustafa Kemal was to remain a leader/dictator well after
the genocide was complete, hence his title 'Ataturk' (meaning father
of the Turks).
Paramilitary (Death squads): The main three paramilitary groups used
by the Nazi's to complete the Holocaust were the SA (Storm Troups),
the SS (Elite Echelon) and the Gestapo (Secret police). The SS,
also referred to as Hitler's 'Death's Head Unit' was responsible
for the mass murder of the Jews. The paramilitary unit which was
responsible for the genocide of Greeks was the TeÅ~_kilât-ı Mahsusa
otherwise known as the Special Organisation (S.O). This organisation
was made up of current and former convicts, religious order groups,
volunteer groups (Lazes and Kurds etc) as well as armed irregulars
(cetecelier/brigands)3.
Ideology: The ideology in both genocides was based on myth. The Nazis
were under the illusion that the Jews wanted to control the world,
hence they had to be exterminated (The Final Solution). The Nazis also
believed that the Aryans, a Nordic race who exhibited blonde hair and
blue eyes, were the first to live in Germany and therefore all others
were inferior. With the outbreak of WW1, the Turks believed that the
Greeks living within the empire were disloyal or were supplying the
enemy with goods. As a result, their ideology was to turn to one of
'Turkey for the Turks' and the eradication of all its 'non-Turkish'
citizens had to be carried out.
Boycotting: The Nazis seized power in January of 1933. Within
two months they carried out the first nationwide boycott of Jewish
businesses. Storm Troops were to stand outside Jewish businesses and
offices of professionals, and paint the Star of David across their
doorways with signs saying 'Don't buy from the Jews'. Comparably
the start of the Greek Genocide occurred on April 6, 1914 when the
Turks boycotted Greek businesses in Eastern Thrace and later along
the western shoreline of Asia Minor and the Black Sea. In both cases,
boycotting was the first sign the genocides had begun.
Hate speech: Hitler outwardly spoke of his hatred of Jews. He referred
to them as a plague, an epidemic, germ carriers, harmful bacillus,
a cancer and as maggots. With the outbreak of WW1 in the Ottoman
Empire, the Sultan issued a declaration of war effectively a Jihad
against the people of the countries who it was fighting against (ie
everyone except Germans and Austrians). A secret paper which was being
distributed, wrote: "The world of Islam sinks down and goes backward
and the Christian world goes forward and is more and more exalted.
Take them and kill them whenever you find them. He who kills even one
unbeliever of those who rule over us, whether he does it secretly or
openly, shall be rewarded by God."4
Disarming: Hitler was able to disarm the Jews by enacting the 1938
German Weapons Act which prohibited Jews from possessing any dangerous
weapon including guns. Jews were also forbidden from the manufacture
or dealing of firearms and ammunition. In comparison, at the outbreak
of WW1, the C.U.P was able to disarm the Greeks by forcing them into
Labour Battallions, or Amele Taburu as they were called. The death
toll in these battalions was as high as 90%, as men were sent into
the interior of Asia Minor and made to do back breaking work with
little food or water.5
Deportations/Death marches: The majority of deportations of Jews
occurred towards the end of WW2 when the allies were closing in
on the Nazis, and Jews were deported away from the extermination
camps and into the interior by train and by foot. The major method
of extermination of the Jews was by the use of gas chambers, so
deportation was not relied upon to exterminate them en masse. On the
other hand, the Turks deported Greeks from virtually every region
of Asia Minor and Eastern Thrace, usually to the interior, by foot,
without food and water, and in many cases during the peak of winter,
with intent to bring about their physical destruction without the
need for bullets or other means.
Jews in Brody, Ukraine detained by German Nazis and awaiting
deportation (circa 1942-1943).
Concentration Camps and Ghettos: While Jews had been living in ghettos
for centuries in Europe, the Nazis enforced a ghetto system for the
Jews in order to isolate them for the purpose of persecution. When the
'Final Solution' was to take effect in 1942, these ghettos were closed
and Jews were sent to concentration, labour and extermination camps.
In the Ottoman Empire, the Greeks were deported usually to
destinations in the interior. On the 21st of April 1916, a New York
Times article with the headline 'Turks Deporting Greeks' wrote:
"Civilian concentration camp victims attacked and despoiled. The
Turkish authorities on the Black Sea regions are acting toward the
Greeks in the same fashion as the Germans have done with regard to the
civil populations of the occupied portions of north-eastern France."
So not only were Greeks sent to concentration camps and attacked
and despoiled along the way, a German involvement also existed. It's
interesting to note that Germany who allied itself with the Ottoman
Empire was in control of the Ottoman military and was therefore
complicit in the Greek Genocide6.
Extermination methods: The major method of exterminating Jews was via
lethal gas in extermination camps. In these camps, several hundred
Jews at a time were locked into chambers and the lethal gas Zyclon-B
was released. Tens of thousands of Jews were exterminated each day in
this manner. While the Turks were not as advanced in their methods of
exterminating Greeks, they were nonetheless effective. As mentioned,
deportation was an effective way to exterminate the Greeks. Another
common method was locking hundreds of Greeks in churches and burning
them alive. Newspaper reports also point to lethal injections7 being
used, parboiling8, and dumping Greeks into the sea9 amongst others.
Resistance: Although the 1938 German Weapons Act prevented Jews from
owning guns, the Jews did offer some resistance during the Holocaust.
There were in fact over a hundred armed Jewish uprisings. One of the
most notable groups was the Bielski partisans who armed themselves
and spent more than two years living in the forests. They were to
save many lives. Most are familiar with the resistance of the Greeks
of the Pontus. By arming themselves, these Greeks were able to defend
themselves and in the process save thousands of Pontic Greeks from
extermination. Many however are not so familiar with the Greeks of
Nicomedia (today Izmit) who likewise offered armed resistance.
By comparing all the above, we can see that the Greek Genocide has
many parallels with that of the Jewish Holocaust, yet it remains
largely forgotten and unrecognised. The German state has officially
recognised the Holocaust and has to date paid some $90 billion in
compensation to the victims. On the other hand, Turkey has continued
to deny that the events of 1914-1923 were an act of genocide, instead
labelling them as the result of civil war.
The crime of genocide has no place in society. Genocides should be
punished regardless of when they occurred, in order to bring closure
and justice to all survivors and their families, and to also act as a
deterrent for those considering committing genocide in the future. The
Greek Genocide is one such genocide which awaits recognition.
References
1. John Williams, The ethnic cleansing of Greeks from Gallipoli,
April 1915. Quadrant online.
2. Haris Tsirkinidis, The concise history of the Greeks of Anatolia.
Kyriakides publishers, 2009. p199.
3. Racho Donef, The role of TeÅ~_kilât-ı Mahsusa. The Genocide of
the Ottoman Greeks. Caratzas, 2011. p187.
4. Henry Morgenthau Snr, Ambassador Morgenthau's story. Cosimo Inc,
2010. p114.
5. Efthimios N. Couzinos, Twenty-three years in Asia Minor.
Publishers' Graphics, LLC, IL. p54.
6. First hun held for atrocities, The evening independent, Mar 15,
1919.
7. Turkish atrocities, Western Mail, W.A. October 26, 1922.
8. Turks parboiled 250,000. New York Times, July 31, 1919.
9. 1,000,000 Greeks are put to death by Turco-Teuton forces in Asia
Minor. The Washington Post, January 1, 1918.