Tweet
Panorama.am
21/01/2015
CHRISTINA MARANCI: SAVE MREN CATHEDRAL FROM COLLAPSING - CALL FOR ACTION
Mren Cathedral (in Kars region of Western Armenia), which is considered a
Masterpiece of world art and the product of the Golden Age of Armenian
Architecture, is still on the verge of collapse. Mren is included in the World
Monuments Fund Watch List and needs urgent action to be saved. Panorama.am
has conducted an interview on this issue with Dr. Christina Maranci=80`
Arthur H. Dadian and Ara T. Ozetemel Associate Professor of Armenian Art at
Tufts University and one of the world's authorities on the Cathedral of
Mren.
Nvard Chalikyan: Dr. Maranci, in 2013 you issued a call to save the 7th
century Mren Cathedral in the Kars region of Western Armenia (present-day
Turkey). You have warned that the Cathedral, which is referred to as =80=9Ca
masterpiece of world art and the product of the Golden Age of Armenian
Architecture', is on the verge of collapse. What is the main significance
of Mren Cathedral both as an architectural and religious monument?
Christina Maranci: Mren is important as the largest surviving domed
basilica of seventh-century Armenia, and one of the largest (Ani Cathedral
is actually slightly shorter in length). It is a particularly refined
example of the domed basilica - with carefully moulded piers articulating
and emphasizing the soaring verticality of the central domed bay. It is
rightly called one of the masterpieces of the `Golden Age'
of Armenian
architecture for these reasons. It also preserves, as I have shown
recently, the most extensive fresco program of seventh-century Armenia, and
the earliest Armenophone biblical inscription (preserving Psalm 92/93:5),
located in the triumphal arch. Scholars have also called attention to the
church as a critical monument of the eastern frontier and the Byzantine
consolidation of this region by the emperor Heraclius (610-641)-he
is named
in a precious inscription on the west façade of the church, and may be
represented in the bas-relief on the north portal lintel, returning the
True Cross to Jerusalem. The west façade portal is also sculpted with
images of Christ, angels, saints, clerics, and princes, making this church
of great value for its architecture, epigraphy, and sculpture.
N.C.: What is currently the condition of Mren?
Christina Maranci: Very bad. The south wall collapsed, as is known, in
the early twentieth century. What was a large hole in the southwest corner
of the church in the 1990s gradually became larger, and now the façade,
along with its corpus of medieval inscriptions, is on the ground. There is
also now a crack running along the northwest corner of the church. The dome
piers have been undermined and damaged, as have the remaining facades, and
so there is little to support the superstructure, and the dome is not
sufficiently or symmetrically supported. The famous lintel showing
Heraclius (most likely) is also not supported on its left side, but simply
hangs in the air.
N.C.: What is the approach of the Turkish authorities to the fate of this
cathedral?
Christina Maranci: For many years, there was no possibility of doing
anything to this site, in part because of the fact that Mren lies in a
military zone. But I have just learned that the Ministry of Culture has
authorized a project there for this year, and that it will involve
Armenians. This is a very exciting and important development, and I am
hopeful that the work can be started before it is too late.
N.C.: Dr. Maranci, thanks to your efforts Mren was included in the World
Monuments Fund Watch List 2014-2017. How can this contribute to the
preservation of the monument?
Christina Maranci: The importance of the Watch List is that it brings
attention to otherwise obscure monuments- the Watch List is a kind
of
official, but non-governmental recognition that a monument is worth
saving-and this, in itself, is a good first step towards establishing the
basis for a project. I hope in the future that other sites in historic
Armenia also achieve this status. It is also important to note that unlike
UNESCO World Heritage Site system, the WMF Watch List is not a permanent
designation; rather, it is intended as a call to action, and that is what
we hope will happen at Mren in the next two years while it is on the list.
N.C.: Is it now possible to access the site or does it still remain
closed for the visitors?
Christina Maranci: Yes and no. I am frankly unsure of the current status
of the region of Mren as part of a restricted military zone. For all I
know, it may still be officially closed, although the area seems less
militarized. But having said that, empirical evidence suggests that Mren is
now accessible to visitors: I know of increasing numbers of people who have
gone to Mren recently, including myself!
N.C.: What other steps have been and should be taken to save Mren?
Christina Maranci: I think that the process of raising awareness of the
church is an important first step towards saving Mren. Now, the next step
will be a good survey of the site and the monument, and then the
stabilization of the weak parts. I think these two things should be done as
soon as possible, hopefully this year.
N.C.: How can one get involved in this campaign?
Christina Maranci: Anyone who is interested should tell friends and
colleagues about Mren and its importance. The more people know about it,
the better. To learn more about the World Monuments Fund, go to their
website: http://www.wmf.org/project/cathedral-mren.
N.C.: How would you describe the overall state of Armenian monuments and
churches in Western Armenia under Turkish rule? Are most of them endangered
(any other cases to highlight)?
Christina Maranci: It varies, but many of them are in bad shape. And too
many of them are not known very well.
Khtskonk, the monastery buildings of Hoá¹=99omos, Bagnayr, and so many
others
are in perilous condition.
N.C.: What would you say is the general approach of the Turkish
government towards the Armenian monuments there?
Christina Maranci: It is a complicated question to answer. My instinct
would be to say negative, but my own experience has been that there has
also been a lot of indifference... However, I would also like to say that
there are many non-governmental individuals - scholars, philanthropists,
etc.-in Turkey who have been at the forefront of campaigning for the
Armenian monuments. I must be hopeful that the changes, which can be
glacial in politics and diplomacy, will happen soon enough to save these
monuments.
Interview by Nvard Chalikyan
http://www.panorama.am/en/interviews/2015/01/21/mren/
21/01/2015
CHRISTINA MARANCI: SAVE MREN CATHEDRAL FROM COLLAPSING - CALL FOR ACTION
Mren Cathedral (in Kars region of Western Armenia), which is considered a
Masterpiece of world art and the product of the Golden Age of Armenian
Architecture, is still on the verge of collapse. Mren is included in the World
Monuments Fund Watch List and needs urgent action to be saved. Panorama.am
has conducted an interview on this issue with Dr. Christina Maranci=80`
Arthur H. Dadian and Ara T. Ozetemel Associate Professor of Armenian Art at
Tufts University and one of the world's authorities on the Cathedral of
Mren.
Nvard Chalikyan: Dr. Maranci, in 2013 you issued a call to save the 7th
century Mren Cathedral in the Kars region of Western Armenia (present-day
Turkey). You have warned that the Cathedral, which is referred to as =80=9Ca
masterpiece of world art and the product of the Golden Age of Armenian
Architecture', is on the verge of collapse. What is the main significance
of Mren Cathedral both as an architectural and religious monument?
Christina Maranci: Mren is important as the largest surviving domed
basilica of seventh-century Armenia, and one of the largest (Ani Cathedral
is actually slightly shorter in length). It is a particularly refined
example of the domed basilica - with carefully moulded piers articulating
and emphasizing the soaring verticality of the central domed bay. It is
rightly called one of the masterpieces of the `Golden Age'
of Armenian
architecture for these reasons. It also preserves, as I have shown
recently, the most extensive fresco program of seventh-century Armenia, and
the earliest Armenophone biblical inscription (preserving Psalm 92/93:5),
located in the triumphal arch. Scholars have also called attention to the
church as a critical monument of the eastern frontier and the Byzantine
consolidation of this region by the emperor Heraclius (610-641)-he
is named
in a precious inscription on the west façade of the church, and may be
represented in the bas-relief on the north portal lintel, returning the
True Cross to Jerusalem. The west façade portal is also sculpted with
images of Christ, angels, saints, clerics, and princes, making this church
of great value for its architecture, epigraphy, and sculpture.
N.C.: What is currently the condition of Mren?
Christina Maranci: Very bad. The south wall collapsed, as is known, in
the early twentieth century. What was a large hole in the southwest corner
of the church in the 1990s gradually became larger, and now the façade,
along with its corpus of medieval inscriptions, is on the ground. There is
also now a crack running along the northwest corner of the church. The dome
piers have been undermined and damaged, as have the remaining facades, and
so there is little to support the superstructure, and the dome is not
sufficiently or symmetrically supported. The famous lintel showing
Heraclius (most likely) is also not supported on its left side, but simply
hangs in the air.
N.C.: What is the approach of the Turkish authorities to the fate of this
cathedral?
Christina Maranci: For many years, there was no possibility of doing
anything to this site, in part because of the fact that Mren lies in a
military zone. But I have just learned that the Ministry of Culture has
authorized a project there for this year, and that it will involve
Armenians. This is a very exciting and important development, and I am
hopeful that the work can be started before it is too late.
N.C.: Dr. Maranci, thanks to your efforts Mren was included in the World
Monuments Fund Watch List 2014-2017. How can this contribute to the
preservation of the monument?
Christina Maranci: The importance of the Watch List is that it brings
attention to otherwise obscure monuments- the Watch List is a kind
of
official, but non-governmental recognition that a monument is worth
saving-and this, in itself, is a good first step towards establishing the
basis for a project. I hope in the future that other sites in historic
Armenia also achieve this status. It is also important to note that unlike
UNESCO World Heritage Site system, the WMF Watch List is not a permanent
designation; rather, it is intended as a call to action, and that is what
we hope will happen at Mren in the next two years while it is on the list.
N.C.: Is it now possible to access the site or does it still remain
closed for the visitors?
Christina Maranci: Yes and no. I am frankly unsure of the current status
of the region of Mren as part of a restricted military zone. For all I
know, it may still be officially closed, although the area seems less
militarized. But having said that, empirical evidence suggests that Mren is
now accessible to visitors: I know of increasing numbers of people who have
gone to Mren recently, including myself!
N.C.: What other steps have been and should be taken to save Mren?
Christina Maranci: I think that the process of raising awareness of the
church is an important first step towards saving Mren. Now, the next step
will be a good survey of the site and the monument, and then the
stabilization of the weak parts. I think these two things should be done as
soon as possible, hopefully this year.
N.C.: How can one get involved in this campaign?
Christina Maranci: Anyone who is interested should tell friends and
colleagues about Mren and its importance. The more people know about it,
the better. To learn more about the World Monuments Fund, go to their
website: http://www.wmf.org/project/cathedral-mren.
N.C.: How would you describe the overall state of Armenian monuments and
churches in Western Armenia under Turkish rule? Are most of them endangered
(any other cases to highlight)?
Christina Maranci: It varies, but many of them are in bad shape. And too
many of them are not known very well.
Khtskonk, the monastery buildings of Hoá¹=99omos, Bagnayr, and so many
others
are in perilous condition.
N.C.: What would you say is the general approach of the Turkish
government towards the Armenian monuments there?
Christina Maranci: It is a complicated question to answer. My instinct
would be to say negative, but my own experience has been that there has
also been a lot of indifference... However, I would also like to say that
there are many non-governmental individuals - scholars, philanthropists,
etc.-in Turkey who have been at the forefront of campaigning for the
Armenian monuments. I must be hopeful that the changes, which can be
glacial in politics and diplomacy, will happen soon enough to save these
monuments.
Interview by Nvard Chalikyan
http://www.panorama.am/en/interviews/2015/01/21/mren/