Tweet
Australian Financial Review
March 28, 2015 Saturday
THE OTHER HUNDREDTH ANNIVERSARY
A rags-to-riches banker with a haunting family background insists
Australia must acknowledge the Armenian genocide, writes Geoff
Winestock.
Michael Carapiet had a stellar career in finance. He ran the
infrastructure division of Macquarie Bank and now, in semi-retirement,
he sits on a dozen of the most prestigious corporate and government
boards. But we won't be talking about any of that. I have instead
invited Carapiet to lunch beside the glistening waters of Sydney
Harbour because he is also one of Australia's most prominent
Armenians.
It is topical because the centenary of the Armenian genocide
officially falls on April 24, just one day before Anzac Day. On that
day in 1915, with the British and Australian attack on the Dardanelles
imminent and the Russians invading from the east, the Turks launched a
year of murder and deportations that killed about 1.5 million
Christian Armenians, who were accused of disloyalty. More than half
the Armenian population of the Ottoman empire perished.
When I had called to set up the lunch, Carapiet had warned he was not
an expert on the topic, just a finance guy who happened to be from the
50,000-strong Armenian community.
But, after just half an hour of talking, the topic gets his blood
running hot. At one point, he erupts with frustration that the
Australian government is refusing even to use the word "genocide"
because it is afraid Turkey might stop our dignitaries attending the
Gallipoli centenary ceremonies.
Foreign Minister Julie Bishop recently described what happened to the
Armenians as an "alleged genocide".
It drives Carapiet wild. "There is overwhelming evidence. Julie Bishop
came out and said 'alleged'. Alleged genocide! Who wrote that for
you?" he almost shouts at her imagined presence. "The Department of
Foreign Affairs advises and they blindly follow and ignore the moral
compass."
We are dining at Graze, the outdoor restaurant just in front of the
Museum of Contemporary Art on Circular Quay. Carapiet suggested it
because it is close to his private office and it won't "break the
budget" since, as is usual with these lunches, I had offered to pay.
Carapiet's sense of a good deal reminds me both that Armenians are
renowned the world over as traders and that Carapiet is a
rags-to-riches migrant himself, with an understanding of the value of
money.
The other thing about the choice of restaurant is that, at various
points in the conversation, the contrast between the terrible events
of 100 years ago and the bobbing ferries and delighted tourists in
front of our table makes Carapiet laugh at how seriously Australians
take their First World problems.
"We have pretty much the best of everything. Look at this," he
exclaims gesturing at our surroundings.
No wine for lunch. Carapiet orders salad but no onions or capsicum. I
am gluten-free and go for a sirloin with nothing. We agree to have a
coffee later.
Just like Gallipoli, the Armenian genocide was a long time ago, so
only the middle-aged grandchildren of the survivors are alive.
Carapiet, 56, retired from Macquarie in 2011 and chairs Smartgroup
Corporation, an ASX-listed salary packaging company. He is on the
boards of the federal government's Clean Energy Finance Corporation
and Infrastructure Australia, and a few NSW state government
businesses. He has two daughters and a granddaughter, and lives with
his wife, Helen.
Carapiet's connection to the genocide is less direct than some,
including Treasurer Joe Hockey, whose grandfather survived one of the
forced death marches of Armenians into the Syrian desert in 1915.
Carapiet's parents and grandparents spent the terrible year of 1915 in
the safety of the diaspora in British India and were not directly
affected. Carapiet grew up there and migrated here only in 1975. His
father dropped the typical Armenian surname ending "-yan" or "-ian".
Carapetian became Carapiet.
Until the young Carapiet married, the genocide came up only in
remembrance services in the Armenian Orthodox Church, which is the
focus of the diaspora community. Then, when he was 15, his father gave
him a copy of a classic 1930s historical novel, The Forty Days of Musa
Dagh, which was written by an Austrian Jew and celebrates one small
group of heroic Armenians who took up arms against the Turks instead
of accepting slaughter.
What brought the genocide home was marrying his wife and meeting her
family. Helen's mother's family fled from western Turkey to Bulgaria
with only what they could cram on a cart.
Helen's father's family was not so lucky. From Keyseri in eastern
Turkey, where the genocide was most fierce, her grandfather was sent
on and survived the death march into the Syrian desert.
Helen then experienced the dislocation that followed the genocide for
so many Armenians. She herself was born in Yerevan, the capital of the
Soviet Union's autonomous republic of Armenia, a sliver of land
squeezed between Turkey and Russia. After the Second World War, her
parents and many others emigrated to the Soviet Union as an
alternative to the uncertainty of stateless exile in the Middle East.
"It was a terrible decision," Carapiet says. As Josef Stalin's terror
raged, Helen and her family fled to neighbouring Georgia, where they
made a living making shoes, including for Stalin's daughter. From
there they somehow emigrated to Australia in the '70s.
It was by talking to Helen's mother and her genocide-survivor
grandfather that Carapiet improved his basic Armenian. He listened as
the old man bled history. But Carapiet was also repelled by the
savagery of the politics of the Armenian exiles.
In the 1970s and '80s, radical Armenian exiles waged a terror campaign
and assassinated Turkish diplomats, including the consul in Sydney, in
1982. Carapiet says he was busy earning, stacking shelves for
Woolworths, working as a bank teller at National Australia Bank and
then, by 1985, was one of the first to join Macquarie Bank.
"I worked out pretty early that my skill was in commerce like a lot of
Armenians and because of my somewhat direct views and occasional lack
of patience with people I found these debates somewhat..." Carapiet
waves his hand dismissively.
We tuck in and my steak is perfect although I slightly regret not
ordering sides. Sydney Harbour is turning on a lovely show. But we are
quite engrossed in a very different time and place.
The politics changed again in 1991 when the Soviet Union collapsed
and, for the first time in 80 years, the Armenians had their own
country.
"My wife always said when the wall came down, 'I don't believe this is
happening."'
Carapiet visited the newly independent former Soviet republic of
Armenia with his children but it was a confusing experience. On the
one hand, this was the spiritual homeland where everybody on the
street looked like a relative. Carapiet visited the well where St
Gregory the Illuminator, patron saint of the Armenia, the world's
oldest Christian country, was imprisoned in the fourth century.
On the other hand, Soviet Armenia had evolved very differently from
the diaspora. It was desperately poor, less worried about the past and
at war with neighbouring Azerbaijan. Carapiet still gives money to
Armenian charities and still feels a certain abstract loyalty to the
homeland but he felt rather uncomfortable during his visit.
Even though he has the time and money to travel, he has never been
back. "People in Armenia aren't affluent, it's a tough gig. I could go
back but I have never got around to it," he says.
Independent Armenia's attitude to the genocide was also subtly
different from that of the diaspora. The tiny republic's primary focus
was on survival in the dangerous Caucasus region and it wanted to end
its bad relations with Turkey, which had imposed a blockade on its
crucial land border.
In 2009, Armenia's president tried to establish normal trade and
diplomatic relations with Turkey. In exchange, Armenia was considering
dropping its demand for an apology for the genocide and settling for a
vague promise to create a working group of historians to look into
what happened.
As the details of this diplomatic stitch-up leaked out, one of the key
factors that killed it was the opposition from the diaspora, including
Carapiet. He is sympathetic to tiny Armenia's desire not to make
enemies but equally adamant it must not sell out to Turkey. Carapiet
happened to be at a World Bank meeting in Istanbul in 2009 when Turkey
and Armenia were talking about this peace-for-silence deal, and was
outraged Armenia might not extract a clear apology for the genocide.
"I don't think they should have done a deal. There's an order to
things. I think you have to take these things a step at a time.
"First you have to say, 'Yes, this was a wrong,' and then you think,
'How do you right the wrong?'
"Look at the Aboriginal population here. Not everybody is happy with
just an apology but there are huge swaths of people who are more
satisfied than before [Kevin] Rudd said he was sorry."
We have flat whites and not the thick Turkish coffee drunk in Armenia.
In the past decade in Turkey, a new moderate Islamist government with
no ties to the old military establishment has allowed more discussion
about the events of 1915, so the idea of admitting a genocide might
one day be conceivable.
But Carapiet thinks an apology might not be enough. Like many in the
diaspora, Carapiet still thinks an apology should be just a prelude to
reparations to survivors' families. I suggest that, after so many
years, Turkey will never accept this but he says Turkey has to change.
"I have got no links to Turkey but I can recognise that for other
people the symbolism isn't enough. There will be certain instances
where assets were taken that can be given back and should be given
back, and there will be cases where they cannot and they will make
other arrangements," he says.
I ask him if he shares the dream of many exiles that Turkey will give
territory back to Armenia. He says only that he thinks it is funny
that Armenia's national symbol, Mount Ararat, where Noah landed the
biblical ark, is now across the border in Turkey and not Armenia.
Which brings us back to Gallipoli. He is disgusted that politicians
are refusing to talk truth to Turkey just so they can have a seat on
the podium at Anzac Cove on April 25. Carapiet says NSW and South
Australia have specifically acknowledged the genocide and the subject
can be taught in their schools, but the federal government says
nothing. Hockey made speeches in opposition about the genocide but now
remains silent.
Frenchmen also died in their thousands in the Dardanelles campaign but
French President Francois Hollande will miss Turkey and travel to
Armenia to honour the 1.5 million. Carapiet says Australia's past
links to Turkey make it the perfect country to press the genocide
issue.
"I think friends are the best people to call out other friends. If a
friend came and told you the truth, you would actually do something
about it. And if [saying the truth] meant you lost their friendship,
it was not a friendship in the first place."
Carapiet himself has none of the visceral hatred of the Turks that
Armenians did a generation ago. Helen grew up speaking Turkish and
enjoys visiting Istanbul, where many of the traders are still ethnic
Armenians or Armenians who converted to Islam in 1915.
As we turn our gaze back to Sydney Harbour, I ask Carapiet what it
will mean for his children to be Armenian since they will never have
met a survivor and have almost no direct connection to the events of
1915.
Carapiet's answer is relevant to many migrants whose cultures have
been fundamentally changed by catastrophe. "You have to try harder
because you don't have a safety net. There is no safety net."
As we part, Carapiet pulls out his mobile phone. "That's him."
He shows me a scan of a sepia photo of a man dressed in black. It is
Helen's grandfather who survived the death march to Syria and who, in
old age, told his story to her Australian-Armenian husband, the young
Carapiet.
Just as other Australian businessmen might have iPhone snaps of
relatives who fought at Gallipoli, Carapiet always wants to be
reminded of knowing someone who actually survived the death march of
1915. "He really walked," Carapiet says.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
March 28, 2015 Saturday
THE OTHER HUNDREDTH ANNIVERSARY
A rags-to-riches banker with a haunting family background insists
Australia must acknowledge the Armenian genocide, writes Geoff
Winestock.
Michael Carapiet had a stellar career in finance. He ran the
infrastructure division of Macquarie Bank and now, in semi-retirement,
he sits on a dozen of the most prestigious corporate and government
boards. But we won't be talking about any of that. I have instead
invited Carapiet to lunch beside the glistening waters of Sydney
Harbour because he is also one of Australia's most prominent
Armenians.
It is topical because the centenary of the Armenian genocide
officially falls on April 24, just one day before Anzac Day. On that
day in 1915, with the British and Australian attack on the Dardanelles
imminent and the Russians invading from the east, the Turks launched a
year of murder and deportations that killed about 1.5 million
Christian Armenians, who were accused of disloyalty. More than half
the Armenian population of the Ottoman empire perished.
When I had called to set up the lunch, Carapiet had warned he was not
an expert on the topic, just a finance guy who happened to be from the
50,000-strong Armenian community.
But, after just half an hour of talking, the topic gets his blood
running hot. At one point, he erupts with frustration that the
Australian government is refusing even to use the word "genocide"
because it is afraid Turkey might stop our dignitaries attending the
Gallipoli centenary ceremonies.
Foreign Minister Julie Bishop recently described what happened to the
Armenians as an "alleged genocide".
It drives Carapiet wild. "There is overwhelming evidence. Julie Bishop
came out and said 'alleged'. Alleged genocide! Who wrote that for
you?" he almost shouts at her imagined presence. "The Department of
Foreign Affairs advises and they blindly follow and ignore the moral
compass."
We are dining at Graze, the outdoor restaurant just in front of the
Museum of Contemporary Art on Circular Quay. Carapiet suggested it
because it is close to his private office and it won't "break the
budget" since, as is usual with these lunches, I had offered to pay.
Carapiet's sense of a good deal reminds me both that Armenians are
renowned the world over as traders and that Carapiet is a
rags-to-riches migrant himself, with an understanding of the value of
money.
The other thing about the choice of restaurant is that, at various
points in the conversation, the contrast between the terrible events
of 100 years ago and the bobbing ferries and delighted tourists in
front of our table makes Carapiet laugh at how seriously Australians
take their First World problems.
"We have pretty much the best of everything. Look at this," he
exclaims gesturing at our surroundings.
No wine for lunch. Carapiet orders salad but no onions or capsicum. I
am gluten-free and go for a sirloin with nothing. We agree to have a
coffee later.
Just like Gallipoli, the Armenian genocide was a long time ago, so
only the middle-aged grandchildren of the survivors are alive.
Carapiet, 56, retired from Macquarie in 2011 and chairs Smartgroup
Corporation, an ASX-listed salary packaging company. He is on the
boards of the federal government's Clean Energy Finance Corporation
and Infrastructure Australia, and a few NSW state government
businesses. He has two daughters and a granddaughter, and lives with
his wife, Helen.
Carapiet's connection to the genocide is less direct than some,
including Treasurer Joe Hockey, whose grandfather survived one of the
forced death marches of Armenians into the Syrian desert in 1915.
Carapiet's parents and grandparents spent the terrible year of 1915 in
the safety of the diaspora in British India and were not directly
affected. Carapiet grew up there and migrated here only in 1975. His
father dropped the typical Armenian surname ending "-yan" or "-ian".
Carapetian became Carapiet.
Until the young Carapiet married, the genocide came up only in
remembrance services in the Armenian Orthodox Church, which is the
focus of the diaspora community. Then, when he was 15, his father gave
him a copy of a classic 1930s historical novel, The Forty Days of Musa
Dagh, which was written by an Austrian Jew and celebrates one small
group of heroic Armenians who took up arms against the Turks instead
of accepting slaughter.
What brought the genocide home was marrying his wife and meeting her
family. Helen's mother's family fled from western Turkey to Bulgaria
with only what they could cram on a cart.
Helen's father's family was not so lucky. From Keyseri in eastern
Turkey, where the genocide was most fierce, her grandfather was sent
on and survived the death march into the Syrian desert.
Helen then experienced the dislocation that followed the genocide for
so many Armenians. She herself was born in Yerevan, the capital of the
Soviet Union's autonomous republic of Armenia, a sliver of land
squeezed between Turkey and Russia. After the Second World War, her
parents and many others emigrated to the Soviet Union as an
alternative to the uncertainty of stateless exile in the Middle East.
"It was a terrible decision," Carapiet says. As Josef Stalin's terror
raged, Helen and her family fled to neighbouring Georgia, where they
made a living making shoes, including for Stalin's daughter. From
there they somehow emigrated to Australia in the '70s.
It was by talking to Helen's mother and her genocide-survivor
grandfather that Carapiet improved his basic Armenian. He listened as
the old man bled history. But Carapiet was also repelled by the
savagery of the politics of the Armenian exiles.
In the 1970s and '80s, radical Armenian exiles waged a terror campaign
and assassinated Turkish diplomats, including the consul in Sydney, in
1982. Carapiet says he was busy earning, stacking shelves for
Woolworths, working as a bank teller at National Australia Bank and
then, by 1985, was one of the first to join Macquarie Bank.
"I worked out pretty early that my skill was in commerce like a lot of
Armenians and because of my somewhat direct views and occasional lack
of patience with people I found these debates somewhat..." Carapiet
waves his hand dismissively.
We tuck in and my steak is perfect although I slightly regret not
ordering sides. Sydney Harbour is turning on a lovely show. But we are
quite engrossed in a very different time and place.
The politics changed again in 1991 when the Soviet Union collapsed
and, for the first time in 80 years, the Armenians had their own
country.
"My wife always said when the wall came down, 'I don't believe this is
happening."'
Carapiet visited the newly independent former Soviet republic of
Armenia with his children but it was a confusing experience. On the
one hand, this was the spiritual homeland where everybody on the
street looked like a relative. Carapiet visited the well where St
Gregory the Illuminator, patron saint of the Armenia, the world's
oldest Christian country, was imprisoned in the fourth century.
On the other hand, Soviet Armenia had evolved very differently from
the diaspora. It was desperately poor, less worried about the past and
at war with neighbouring Azerbaijan. Carapiet still gives money to
Armenian charities and still feels a certain abstract loyalty to the
homeland but he felt rather uncomfortable during his visit.
Even though he has the time and money to travel, he has never been
back. "People in Armenia aren't affluent, it's a tough gig. I could go
back but I have never got around to it," he says.
Independent Armenia's attitude to the genocide was also subtly
different from that of the diaspora. The tiny republic's primary focus
was on survival in the dangerous Caucasus region and it wanted to end
its bad relations with Turkey, which had imposed a blockade on its
crucial land border.
In 2009, Armenia's president tried to establish normal trade and
diplomatic relations with Turkey. In exchange, Armenia was considering
dropping its demand for an apology for the genocide and settling for a
vague promise to create a working group of historians to look into
what happened.
As the details of this diplomatic stitch-up leaked out, one of the key
factors that killed it was the opposition from the diaspora, including
Carapiet. He is sympathetic to tiny Armenia's desire not to make
enemies but equally adamant it must not sell out to Turkey. Carapiet
happened to be at a World Bank meeting in Istanbul in 2009 when Turkey
and Armenia were talking about this peace-for-silence deal, and was
outraged Armenia might not extract a clear apology for the genocide.
"I don't think they should have done a deal. There's an order to
things. I think you have to take these things a step at a time.
"First you have to say, 'Yes, this was a wrong,' and then you think,
'How do you right the wrong?'
"Look at the Aboriginal population here. Not everybody is happy with
just an apology but there are huge swaths of people who are more
satisfied than before [Kevin] Rudd said he was sorry."
We have flat whites and not the thick Turkish coffee drunk in Armenia.
In the past decade in Turkey, a new moderate Islamist government with
no ties to the old military establishment has allowed more discussion
about the events of 1915, so the idea of admitting a genocide might
one day be conceivable.
But Carapiet thinks an apology might not be enough. Like many in the
diaspora, Carapiet still thinks an apology should be just a prelude to
reparations to survivors' families. I suggest that, after so many
years, Turkey will never accept this but he says Turkey has to change.
"I have got no links to Turkey but I can recognise that for other
people the symbolism isn't enough. There will be certain instances
where assets were taken that can be given back and should be given
back, and there will be cases where they cannot and they will make
other arrangements," he says.
I ask him if he shares the dream of many exiles that Turkey will give
territory back to Armenia. He says only that he thinks it is funny
that Armenia's national symbol, Mount Ararat, where Noah landed the
biblical ark, is now across the border in Turkey and not Armenia.
Which brings us back to Gallipoli. He is disgusted that politicians
are refusing to talk truth to Turkey just so they can have a seat on
the podium at Anzac Cove on April 25. Carapiet says NSW and South
Australia have specifically acknowledged the genocide and the subject
can be taught in their schools, but the federal government says
nothing. Hockey made speeches in opposition about the genocide but now
remains silent.
Frenchmen also died in their thousands in the Dardanelles campaign but
French President Francois Hollande will miss Turkey and travel to
Armenia to honour the 1.5 million. Carapiet says Australia's past
links to Turkey make it the perfect country to press the genocide
issue.
"I think friends are the best people to call out other friends. If a
friend came and told you the truth, you would actually do something
about it. And if [saying the truth] meant you lost their friendship,
it was not a friendship in the first place."
Carapiet himself has none of the visceral hatred of the Turks that
Armenians did a generation ago. Helen grew up speaking Turkish and
enjoys visiting Istanbul, where many of the traders are still ethnic
Armenians or Armenians who converted to Islam in 1915.
As we turn our gaze back to Sydney Harbour, I ask Carapiet what it
will mean for his children to be Armenian since they will never have
met a survivor and have almost no direct connection to the events of
1915.
Carapiet's answer is relevant to many migrants whose cultures have
been fundamentally changed by catastrophe. "You have to try harder
because you don't have a safety net. There is no safety net."
As we part, Carapiet pulls out his mobile phone. "That's him."
He shows me a scan of a sepia photo of a man dressed in black. It is
Helen's grandfather who survived the death march to Syria and who, in
old age, told his story to her Australian-Armenian husband, the young
Carapiet.
Just as other Australian businessmen might have iPhone snaps of
relatives who fought at Gallipoli, Carapiet always wants to be
reminded of knowing someone who actually survived the death march of
1915. "He really walked," Carapiet says.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress