Tweet
Pravda, Russia
Aug 16 2005
Russian storm troopers: myth or reality?
08/16/2005 12:54
Referring to 50 thousand skinheads, it is just a phantom
Moscow Bureau for Human Rights made a report, which said that "there
are about 15 thousand adult fighters and up to 50 thousand teenage
skinheads under arms of Russian nationalistic organizations" and "these
groups are already responsible for several terrorist acts and riots."
Sixty-five thousand fighters is a whole army. Hitler had about ten
times less storm troopers in 1933 not to mention a handful of Russian
Bolsheviks in 1917. If such an army existed for real in Russia it
would have occupied Moscow long time ago and solved the national
question. It is obvious that such an organization that forms armed
groups and organizes operations would not be left unnoticed. In
fact there is no such army or regiment or battalion of skinheads in
Russia. This conclusion can be drawn from the report itself.
To advance a slogan is one thing, but to support it with facts
is absolutely different. It is not clear what was meant by the
terrorist acts in the report. There was no incident mentioned in
the report, which can be regarded as such. There are some examples:
several buildings where Gypsies lived were burnt in the Novosibirsk
region, a so-called "Che Guevara squad" smashed several cars, which
presumably belonged to drug dealers in Yaroslavl, Cossacks sacked
local Armenians' houses near Novorossiysk. Three Polish people were
beaten in Moscow. There is more: "nationalists in the Komi Republic
threatened with massacre to several scientists and human rights
activists, whom they accused of espionage for the US."
Those are certainly crimes. However, it is a lame argument to prove
the existence of 65-thousand-strong army. Human rights activists
themselves almost admit that they made up this figure. In fact, it is
hardly possible to count the number of armed nationalists. Suppose,
that 15 thousand were deduced by simple calculation of members of
seven nationalistic parties and movements - Russian National Unity,
Brown Season and others. However, it was nationalists themselves, who
counted their members. It is obvious that they did so in order to show
off. It is unclear why the human rights advocates believe them though.
Referring to 50 thousand skinheads, it is just a phantom. The report
clearly states: "there is no unified skinheads organization in Russia,
they are scattered in small groups." It continues with "their number
is estimated at 10 thousand to 50 thousand people." The second figure
is meant to impress, of course. It is stated in the beginning of
the report, but afterwards it is admitted that the figure cannot be
proved. A gap of 40 thousand is too much. It is impossible to count all
the people who belong to these bands and gangs (not the troops). How
can you differentiate between mere street thugs and devoted skinheads?
Moscow Bureau for Human Rights statements that 10 people were killed
by skinheads and more than 200 were beaten in the first half of 2005
can be proved neither by facts nor by testimonies. Seems like the
responsibility for any crime can be shifted on skinheads.
It would be wrong to deny that that there is enough scum in Russia
who loathe Caucasians, Gypsies, Chinese, Jews and who are ready to
beat and even kill foreigners. But there is such a scum in every
society. They must be fought. And they are fought in fact! The human
rights activists said, "During the first half of 2005 there were 6
trials. As a result 21 extremists were sentenced to 4-19 years in
prison for committing grave crimes on the ground of national hatred."
Those are the real figures.
Igor Dmitriev
Aug 16 2005
Russian storm troopers: myth or reality?
08/16/2005 12:54
Referring to 50 thousand skinheads, it is just a phantom
Moscow Bureau for Human Rights made a report, which said that "there
are about 15 thousand adult fighters and up to 50 thousand teenage
skinheads under arms of Russian nationalistic organizations" and "these
groups are already responsible for several terrorist acts and riots."
Sixty-five thousand fighters is a whole army. Hitler had about ten
times less storm troopers in 1933 not to mention a handful of Russian
Bolsheviks in 1917. If such an army existed for real in Russia it
would have occupied Moscow long time ago and solved the national
question. It is obvious that such an organization that forms armed
groups and organizes operations would not be left unnoticed. In
fact there is no such army or regiment or battalion of skinheads in
Russia. This conclusion can be drawn from the report itself.
To advance a slogan is one thing, but to support it with facts
is absolutely different. It is not clear what was meant by the
terrorist acts in the report. There was no incident mentioned in
the report, which can be regarded as such. There are some examples:
several buildings where Gypsies lived were burnt in the Novosibirsk
region, a so-called "Che Guevara squad" smashed several cars, which
presumably belonged to drug dealers in Yaroslavl, Cossacks sacked
local Armenians' houses near Novorossiysk. Three Polish people were
beaten in Moscow. There is more: "nationalists in the Komi Republic
threatened with massacre to several scientists and human rights
activists, whom they accused of espionage for the US."
Those are certainly crimes. However, it is a lame argument to prove
the existence of 65-thousand-strong army. Human rights activists
themselves almost admit that they made up this figure. In fact, it is
hardly possible to count the number of armed nationalists. Suppose,
that 15 thousand were deduced by simple calculation of members of
seven nationalistic parties and movements - Russian National Unity,
Brown Season and others. However, it was nationalists themselves, who
counted their members. It is obvious that they did so in order to show
off. It is unclear why the human rights advocates believe them though.
Referring to 50 thousand skinheads, it is just a phantom. The report
clearly states: "there is no unified skinheads organization in Russia,
they are scattered in small groups." It continues with "their number
is estimated at 10 thousand to 50 thousand people." The second figure
is meant to impress, of course. It is stated in the beginning of
the report, but afterwards it is admitted that the figure cannot be
proved. A gap of 40 thousand is too much. It is impossible to count all
the people who belong to these bands and gangs (not the troops). How
can you differentiate between mere street thugs and devoted skinheads?
Moscow Bureau for Human Rights statements that 10 people were killed
by skinheads and more than 200 were beaten in the first half of 2005
can be proved neither by facts nor by testimonies. Seems like the
responsibility for any crime can be shifted on skinheads.
It would be wrong to deny that that there is enough scum in Russia
who loathe Caucasians, Gypsies, Chinese, Jews and who are ready to
beat and even kill foreigners. But there is such a scum in every
society. They must be fought. And they are fought in fact! The human
rights activists said, "During the first half of 2005 there were 6
trials. As a result 21 extremists were sentenced to 4-19 years in
prison for committing grave crimes on the ground of national hatred."
Those are the real figures.
Igor Dmitriev