Tweet
Washington Post
Aug 30 2008
Russian Offensive Hailed in Mideast
By Ellen Knickmeyer
Washington Post Foreign Service
Saturday, August 30, 2008; Page A18
CAIRO -- For some in the Middle East, the images of Russian tanks
rolling into Georgia in defiance of U.S. opposition have revived warm
memories of the Cold War.
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad flew last week to Moscow, where he
endorsed Russia's offensive in Georgia and, according to Russian
officials, sought additional Russian weapon systems.
Saif al-Islam Gaddafi, Libyan leader Moammar Gaddafi's influential
son, echoed the delight expressed in much of the Arab news
media. "What happened in Georgia is a good sign, one that means
America is no longer the sole world power setting the rules of the
game," the younger Gaddafi was quoted as telling the Russian daily
Kommersant. "There is a balance in the world now. Russia is resurging,
which is good for us, for the entire Middle East."
In Turkey, an American and European ally that obtains more than
two-thirds of its natural gas from Russia, the reaction was more
complex. Turks watched as the United States, NATO and a divided
European Union hesitated in the face of Russian military
assertiveness, leaving them more doubtful than they already were about
depending on the West to secure U.S.-backed alternative oil and gas
supply lines.
"This Russian invasion of Georgia is a turning point in the relations
of the Atlantic community with Russia, including, of course, Turkey,"
Ozden Sanberk, a former Turkish ambassador to Britain, said by
telephone from Turkey. "There is a change in the paradigm, a change in
assessment."
Since Aug. 8, when Russia sent troops and tanks across its southern
border in a confrontation with Georgia's pro-Western government, many
Turkish newspapers have urged the Turkish government to improve
relations with Russia, in pragmatic acceptance of the possibility that
Russia could directly or indirectly control most oil and gas supplies
from Central Asia to Europe.
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan for the past two weeks has
sought to persuade leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Russia
to put their political differences aside in the interest of keeping
oil and gas flowing.
Russian leaders, angry at Turkish military aid to Georgia, repeatedly
refused to take Erdogan's calls, Turkish news media reported.
Russia has been paying closer attention to the needs of the United
States' least favorite Middle East countries, Syria and Iran.
Russia's ambassador in Tehran, Alexander Sadovnikov, told Iranian news
media this week that Russia was committed to helping Iran finish work
on its Bushehr nuclear plant as soon as possible. At the same time,
Iran's oil minister declared his country's eagerness to do more
business with Russia's main energy company, Gazprom.
The United States has tried to discourage European countries and
Turkey from turning to Iran for oil and gas. With Russia demonstrating
its ability to control supplies through Georgia and the rest of the
Caucasus, Iran's supplies are going to look more attractive to
U.S. allies in Europe, analysts noted.
And with the United States and Russia at odds, Iran also can expect
more help from Russia in blocking U.S. efforts at the U.N. Security
Council and other international bodies to sanction Iran over its
nuclear program, said Flynt Leverett, a former Bush administration
Middle East policy director and now a senior fellow at the New America
Foundation in Washington.
Especially with Assad's visit to Moscow, Russians are signaling that
there is more they can do to undermine U.S. policies, Leverett said.
Syrian officials this week denied reports in Russian news media that
Assad had sought Russian ballistic missiles on his visit to Moscow and
had offered to host a Russian naval post again, as Syria did in the
Cold War to ward off any attack by Israel.
Iranian officials, mindful of a possible U.S. or Israeli strike, also
have voiced hopes of obtaining Russia's most advanced antiaircraft
missile systems.
In Israel and the United States, there is "definitely rising concern
Russia may go ahead and deliver those systems as a way of further
indicating how unhappy it is with U.S. policy," Leverett said.
Russia, however, also has been building relations and trade with
Israel, and has denied selling its most advanced systems to Syria or
Iran. Syria itself is in indirect peace talks with Israel. Russian
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said last week that Russia was ready to
sell Syria arms of a "defensive character that do not violate the
strategic balance of power in the Middle East."
Israel said Prime Minister Ehud Olmert planned to travel to Russia to
discuss any Syria-Russia arms deals, amid statements from Israeli
officials that the arms could be used to bolster Syrian ally
Hezbollah.
Middle East governments have experience with Russian-made weapons,
which haven't worked so well, said Abdel-Moneim Said, director of the
al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies in
Cairo. Egyptians still blame their defeats in wars against Israel
partly on their Russian-supplied weapons.
Many Arab analysts initially cheered Russia's flexing of its military
muscles. An opinion piece in the United Arab Emirates-based Gulf News
called it "long overdue." Editorials in some Arab news media this week
and last expressed second thoughts, questioning whether Russia has the
stability, surety of purpose or strength to be a leader among
countries.
"All that ended up to be a kind of nostalgia, or looking for a new
kind of Cold War, when there was not only one, single power dominating
the world, the United States, and its ally, Israel," Said said.
Now, "there's a realization that Russia has a lot of interests with
the West. Also that Russia is still a limited power," he said. "It's
no match. There is no new Cold War coming."
Aug 30 2008
Russian Offensive Hailed in Mideast
By Ellen Knickmeyer
Washington Post Foreign Service
Saturday, August 30, 2008; Page A18
CAIRO -- For some in the Middle East, the images of Russian tanks
rolling into Georgia in defiance of U.S. opposition have revived warm
memories of the Cold War.
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad flew last week to Moscow, where he
endorsed Russia's offensive in Georgia and, according to Russian
officials, sought additional Russian weapon systems.
Saif al-Islam Gaddafi, Libyan leader Moammar Gaddafi's influential
son, echoed the delight expressed in much of the Arab news
media. "What happened in Georgia is a good sign, one that means
America is no longer the sole world power setting the rules of the
game," the younger Gaddafi was quoted as telling the Russian daily
Kommersant. "There is a balance in the world now. Russia is resurging,
which is good for us, for the entire Middle East."
In Turkey, an American and European ally that obtains more than
two-thirds of its natural gas from Russia, the reaction was more
complex. Turks watched as the United States, NATO and a divided
European Union hesitated in the face of Russian military
assertiveness, leaving them more doubtful than they already were about
depending on the West to secure U.S.-backed alternative oil and gas
supply lines.
"This Russian invasion of Georgia is a turning point in the relations
of the Atlantic community with Russia, including, of course, Turkey,"
Ozden Sanberk, a former Turkish ambassador to Britain, said by
telephone from Turkey. "There is a change in the paradigm, a change in
assessment."
Since Aug. 8, when Russia sent troops and tanks across its southern
border in a confrontation with Georgia's pro-Western government, many
Turkish newspapers have urged the Turkish government to improve
relations with Russia, in pragmatic acceptance of the possibility that
Russia could directly or indirectly control most oil and gas supplies
from Central Asia to Europe.
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan for the past two weeks has
sought to persuade leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Russia
to put their political differences aside in the interest of keeping
oil and gas flowing.
Russian leaders, angry at Turkish military aid to Georgia, repeatedly
refused to take Erdogan's calls, Turkish news media reported.
Russia has been paying closer attention to the needs of the United
States' least favorite Middle East countries, Syria and Iran.
Russia's ambassador in Tehran, Alexander Sadovnikov, told Iranian news
media this week that Russia was committed to helping Iran finish work
on its Bushehr nuclear plant as soon as possible. At the same time,
Iran's oil minister declared his country's eagerness to do more
business with Russia's main energy company, Gazprom.
The United States has tried to discourage European countries and
Turkey from turning to Iran for oil and gas. With Russia demonstrating
its ability to control supplies through Georgia and the rest of the
Caucasus, Iran's supplies are going to look more attractive to
U.S. allies in Europe, analysts noted.
And with the United States and Russia at odds, Iran also can expect
more help from Russia in blocking U.S. efforts at the U.N. Security
Council and other international bodies to sanction Iran over its
nuclear program, said Flynt Leverett, a former Bush administration
Middle East policy director and now a senior fellow at the New America
Foundation in Washington.
Especially with Assad's visit to Moscow, Russians are signaling that
there is more they can do to undermine U.S. policies, Leverett said.
Syrian officials this week denied reports in Russian news media that
Assad had sought Russian ballistic missiles on his visit to Moscow and
had offered to host a Russian naval post again, as Syria did in the
Cold War to ward off any attack by Israel.
Iranian officials, mindful of a possible U.S. or Israeli strike, also
have voiced hopes of obtaining Russia's most advanced antiaircraft
missile systems.
In Israel and the United States, there is "definitely rising concern
Russia may go ahead and deliver those systems as a way of further
indicating how unhappy it is with U.S. policy," Leverett said.
Russia, however, also has been building relations and trade with
Israel, and has denied selling its most advanced systems to Syria or
Iran. Syria itself is in indirect peace talks with Israel. Russian
Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said last week that Russia was ready to
sell Syria arms of a "defensive character that do not violate the
strategic balance of power in the Middle East."
Israel said Prime Minister Ehud Olmert planned to travel to Russia to
discuss any Syria-Russia arms deals, amid statements from Israeli
officials that the arms could be used to bolster Syrian ally
Hezbollah.
Middle East governments have experience with Russian-made weapons,
which haven't worked so well, said Abdel-Moneim Said, director of the
al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies in
Cairo. Egyptians still blame their defeats in wars against Israel
partly on their Russian-supplied weapons.
Many Arab analysts initially cheered Russia's flexing of its military
muscles. An opinion piece in the United Arab Emirates-based Gulf News
called it "long overdue." Editorials in some Arab news media this week
and last expressed second thoughts, questioning whether Russia has the
stability, surety of purpose or strength to be a leader among
countries.
"All that ended up to be a kind of nostalgia, or looking for a new
kind of Cold War, when there was not only one, single power dominating
the world, the United States, and its ally, Israel," Said said.
Now, "there's a realization that Russia has a lot of interests with
the West. Also that Russia is still a limited power," he said. "It's
no match. There is no new Cold War coming."