Tweet
A CANADIAN GENOCIDE IN SEARCH OF A NAME
The Toronto Star
July 19, 2013 Friday
Canadians have been staggered by the news arising from a University of
Guelph study which proves that in our lifetime Canadian authorities
knowingly and wilfully starved aboriginal children in residential
schools. Their incomprehensible rationale: they wanted to conduct
nutritional experiments on these famished children for future study.
It is time for Canadians to face the sad truth. Canada engaged in a
deliberate policy of attempted genocide against First Nations people.
And the starvation experiments were only the first of a litany
of similar such attempts to control, delegitimize and, yes, even
annihilate First Nations to suit the needs of a growing Dominion.
Some have argued that the beginnings of this genocide had its seeds
with the establishment of the Indian Act of 1876, which legalized
First Nations as an inferior group and made them wards of the state.
In truth, these were just words on paper compared with accusations
lodged against the Canadian government by our first Chief Medical
Officer, Dr. Peter Bryce, in 1907.
According to an academic study undertaken by Adam Green for the
University of Ottawa, Dr. Bryce uncovered a "national crime" pertaining
to the health of First Nations people. In a book Bryce wrote after
he was summarily dismissed from his position for blowing the whistle
on the Canadian government's complicity in the mass deaths from
tuberculosis of aboriginals on reserves and in residential schools,
Bryce outlined in detail what he observed.
According to Bryce, Canada's aboriginal people in Manitoba, Alberta
and Saskatchewan were being "decimated by tuberculosis and that the
federal government possessed the means to stop it." Instead, it chose
a such minimalist approach that, in the medical opinion of Dr. Bryce,
it "amounted to almost nothing."
The government of the day sought to hide Bryce's findings from
the general public and chose to bury the report and relieve Bryce
of his duties. This had the effect of ensuring that no real steps
would be taken to help save the lives of natives on reserves and in
residential schools from the ravages of this disease. Indeed, Bryce
was so frustrated that in the end he charged that "the government's
treatment of its Aboriginal Peoples amounted to nothing less than an
infuriating and criminal disregard to the country's Treaty pledges."
It would be the easy course for us to continue to turn our backs and
pretend that Canada would simply never have engaged in a deliberate
attempt to destroy aboriginal people. However, the facts seem to
point ominously to that conclusion.
We must ask ourselves: When does genocide become genocide? This might
seem an absurd question, but history isn't always forthcoming with
a neat little package bearing the label "genocide, open with caution."
The definition of genocide is quite clear, however:
... any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in
whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group,
as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated
to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
- Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide,
Article II
Under this definition, Canada's treatment of its First Nations,
even in our own lifetime, meets the genocide test:
The recently exposed nutrition experiments carried out in the
residential schools meets the criteria under point (b).
The residential school system itself, and the practice of forcibly
removing First Nations children from reserves and placing them with
adoptive non-aboriginal families, common in the 1960s, and referred
to as Sixties Scoop, meet the criteria under point (e).
The decision by the government in the 1900s to allow native children
to die of tuberculosis meet the criteria under point (c).
This list is by no means exhaustive.
In 1910, Duncan Scott, then head of Canada's residential schools,
refuting the high death rate in his schools as reported in the Bryce's
study, wrote:
"But this does not justify a change in the policy of this Department
which is geared toward a Final Solution of our Indian Problem (our
emphasis)."
The Government of Canada currently recognizes five genocides: the
Holocaust, the Holodomor, the Armenian genocide, the Rwandan genocide
and Srebrenica.
The time has come for Canada to formally recognize a sixth genocide,
the genocide of its own aboriginal communities; a genocide that began
at the time of first contact and that was still very active in our
own lifetimes; a genocide currently in search of a name but no longer
in search of historical facts.
Phil Fontaine is the former National Chief of the Assembly of First
Nations, Dr. Michael Dan and Bernie M. Farber are the president
and senior vice-president respectively of Gemini Power Corporation,
working with First Nations to build sustainable industries.
The Toronto Star
July 19, 2013 Friday
Canadians have been staggered by the news arising from a University of
Guelph study which proves that in our lifetime Canadian authorities
knowingly and wilfully starved aboriginal children in residential
schools. Their incomprehensible rationale: they wanted to conduct
nutritional experiments on these famished children for future study.
It is time for Canadians to face the sad truth. Canada engaged in a
deliberate policy of attempted genocide against First Nations people.
And the starvation experiments were only the first of a litany
of similar such attempts to control, delegitimize and, yes, even
annihilate First Nations to suit the needs of a growing Dominion.
Some have argued that the beginnings of this genocide had its seeds
with the establishment of the Indian Act of 1876, which legalized
First Nations as an inferior group and made them wards of the state.
In truth, these were just words on paper compared with accusations
lodged against the Canadian government by our first Chief Medical
Officer, Dr. Peter Bryce, in 1907.
According to an academic study undertaken by Adam Green for the
University of Ottawa, Dr. Bryce uncovered a "national crime" pertaining
to the health of First Nations people. In a book Bryce wrote after
he was summarily dismissed from his position for blowing the whistle
on the Canadian government's complicity in the mass deaths from
tuberculosis of aboriginals on reserves and in residential schools,
Bryce outlined in detail what he observed.
According to Bryce, Canada's aboriginal people in Manitoba, Alberta
and Saskatchewan were being "decimated by tuberculosis and that the
federal government possessed the means to stop it." Instead, it chose
a such minimalist approach that, in the medical opinion of Dr. Bryce,
it "amounted to almost nothing."
The government of the day sought to hide Bryce's findings from
the general public and chose to bury the report and relieve Bryce
of his duties. This had the effect of ensuring that no real steps
would be taken to help save the lives of natives on reserves and in
residential schools from the ravages of this disease. Indeed, Bryce
was so frustrated that in the end he charged that "the government's
treatment of its Aboriginal Peoples amounted to nothing less than an
infuriating and criminal disregard to the country's Treaty pledges."
It would be the easy course for us to continue to turn our backs and
pretend that Canada would simply never have engaged in a deliberate
attempt to destroy aboriginal people. However, the facts seem to
point ominously to that conclusion.
We must ask ourselves: When does genocide become genocide? This might
seem an absurd question, but history isn't always forthcoming with
a neat little package bearing the label "genocide, open with caution."
The definition of genocide is quite clear, however:
... any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in
whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group,
as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated
to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
- Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide,
Article II
Under this definition, Canada's treatment of its First Nations,
even in our own lifetime, meets the genocide test:
The recently exposed nutrition experiments carried out in the
residential schools meets the criteria under point (b).
The residential school system itself, and the practice of forcibly
removing First Nations children from reserves and placing them with
adoptive non-aboriginal families, common in the 1960s, and referred
to as Sixties Scoop, meet the criteria under point (e).
The decision by the government in the 1900s to allow native children
to die of tuberculosis meet the criteria under point (c).
This list is by no means exhaustive.
In 1910, Duncan Scott, then head of Canada's residential schools,
refuting the high death rate in his schools as reported in the Bryce's
study, wrote:
"But this does not justify a change in the policy of this Department
which is geared toward a Final Solution of our Indian Problem (our
emphasis)."
The Government of Canada currently recognizes five genocides: the
Holocaust, the Holodomor, the Armenian genocide, the Rwandan genocide
and Srebrenica.
The time has come for Canada to formally recognize a sixth genocide,
the genocide of its own aboriginal communities; a genocide that began
at the time of first contact and that was still very active in our
own lifetimes; a genocide currently in search of a name but no longer
in search of historical facts.
Phil Fontaine is the former National Chief of the Assembly of First
Nations, Dr. Michael Dan and Bernie M. Farber are the president
and senior vice-president respectively of Gemini Power Corporation,
working with First Nations to build sustainable industries.